Immigration Reform and the Economic Impact of Tax Revenues

Topics: Immigration to the United States, Immigration, Illegal immigration Pages: 8 (1788 words) Published: June 10, 2014


Immigration Reform and the Economic Impact of Tax Revenues
DeVry University

Immigration Reform
The occurrence of undocumented or illegal immigration and immigration policy reform is a highly contested issue in the United States today. The US Census Bureau surveyed in 2010 that there were over 309 million people in the United States. The numbers of immigrants were surveyed to be about 40 million and it is estimated that about 11 million undocumented immigrants are in this country. The population of immigrants in California is the largest in the nation, with over twenty-five percent of all immigrants living here. While being registered as an Independent and primarily voting as a Republican, I have been against Immigration Amnesty and have favored an Immigration Policy that did not reward those for being in this country illegally. Anti-Immigration groups have implied that our schools are overcrowded, the lines in our emergency rooms are longer, our neighborhoods have more crime, immigrants take our jobs and our taxes are higher because of illegal immigration. After my initial research I could not understand how 2.8% of the total population could overburden our social resources. Would our tax revenues actually increase if there was a process for them to start citizenship? The battle for Immigration Reform has divided our country for far too long and has assisted in obstructing our economy. This inaction keeps illegal immigrants in the status quo and will systematically hindered our economic progress and stall the social progress of generations to come. I have been influenced by a media that broadcasts that most right wing conservatives staunchly opposed immigration reform and say it would break our Social Security system and we would pay out more out in taxes than our economy receives. Others say that illegals would be a drain on our economy by overrunning our social programs. Mark Krikorian, executive director of the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS) says. “If they’re legalized then they can collect Social Security and guess what? People with low incomes get more out of Social Security, generally speaking, than they pay in,” he argues. "So the Social Security argument is actually an argument for keeping illegal immigrants illegal because that way they won’t ever collect Social Security." (Goodkind, n.d.). I had a conversation with my realtor that was naturalized as a citizen, and he was very adamant that when he sponsored his aging aunt from the Philippians she automatically started receiving Supplemental Security Income (SSI). The CIS and the Federation for American Reform have used this research to defend their activities against illegal immigration and presented data indicating illegal immigration damages our society and economy. Their investigations have stated that undocumented immigrants cost the US economy “at least 10 billion more than they contribute to the economy” (Correa-Cabrera and Rojas-Arenza, 2012). CIS goes further and claims that if an amnesty policy is approved that the cost to taxpayers will triple. They estimate that the “average illegal immigrant family uses $2700 more in services than it pays in taxes”. (Correa-Cabrera and Rojas-Arenza, 2012) Americans are concerned about illegal immigration as confirmed by a recent survey. Forty four percent of the people polled said that illegal immigration was “overburdening government services” (Fox, 2013), but a poll that was taken three years earlier found that 84% believed that illegal immigrants were overburdening services then. Another survey that was conducted in 2010 discovered “86% of Republicans, 64% of Democrats and 76% of Independents” had agreed with the question when asked “Illegal immigrants do more to weaken the U.S. economy because they don’t pay taxes but use public services” (Fox, 2013). In a different survey, 84% of those polled were “concerned that illegal immigrants might be putting an unfair burden on U.S....

References: 1. Singer, A. (2013) Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy
2. Goodkind, N. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://finance.yahoo.com/blogs/daily-ticker/social-security-risk-impact-immigration-reform-124712696.html
3. Fox, L. (2013). Reform Means Revenue. U.S. News Digital Weekly, 5(28), 8
4. Nowrasteh, A. and Cole, S. (2013) Open the Gates, USA Today
5. Correa-Cabrera, G. and Rojas-Arenza, M. (2012). The Mathmatics of Mexico-US Immigration Policy. Routledge Policy Studies
6. Eusebio, C. and Mendoz, F. (2013). The Case for Undocumented Students in Higher Education. Educators for Fair Consideration (E4FC)
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Economic Impact of Immigration Essay
  • Essay about Immigration Reform
  • The Social and Economic Benefits of an Immigration Reform Research Paper
  • Immigration Reform Essay
  • Immigration Reform Essay
  • Immigration reform Essay
  • Immigration Reform Essay
  • immigration reform Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free