HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENTS OF KOREAN CAPITALISM The Hyundai Business Group, 1940s-1990s
SCHOOL OF INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS AND ORGANISATIONAL BEHAVIOUR WORKING PAPER SERIES ISSN 1325-8028
HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENTS OF KOREAN CAPITALISM The Hyundai Business Group, 1940s-1990s1
Seung-Ho Kwon Abstract The chaebol, family-controlled conglomerates, which now dominate the South Korean economy constitute a unique type of business enterprise in the development worldwide of capitalist economies. With the support of a developmentalist state, the chaebol played a central role in rapid industrialisation of the South Korean economy, which in turn facilitated the transformation of what were originally small, family capitalist enterprises in the late 1940s, to large scale industrial enterprises in the 1990s. The chaebol employed aggressive diversification and expansionary strategies to achieve monopoly capitalism through dominant market advantages derived from economies of scale and scope. While the chaebol was initially managed by members of the founder’s family, as it expanded, increased reliance on a cadre of professional managers was necessary. However, despite the inevitable devolution of managerial control from founder to second generation and the rise of a powerful managerial cadre, the essential nature of this unique form of proprietary capitalism has so far been retained, along with its economic pre-eminence. The genesis and evolution of the chaebol is examined through an in-depth case study of a leading Korean industrial conglomerate, the Hyundai Business Group, from its origins in the 1940s to the early 1990s.
INTRODUCTION The historical development of large scale capitalist business entities is a frequently canvassed topic of research across the economics, business history and organisational structure disciplines. Most of these studies have focussed on large scale capitalist enterprises in advanced countries such as the United States, England, Europe and Japan.2 In contrast, scant attention has been paid to these enterprises in the newly emergent capitalist economies of the 1
I am indebted to Lawson Smith, Diane Fieldes and Ian Hampson for numerous helpful comments and suggestions in relation to an earlier version of this paper. Expressions of opinion, other than those referenced in the conventional way are my own. 2 See For examples, Chandler, 1962, 1990; Lazonick, 1991; Prais, 1976; Fligstein, 1990; Schmitz, 1993.
East Asian regions, especially those in South Korea (hereafter Korea). This is surprising, given the dominant role of family-controlled conglomerates, the chaebol, in the course of Korea’s rapid industrialisation.3 This paper addresses the evident gap in the literature through a detailed, in-depth case study of a leading industrial conglomerate, Hyundai Business Group, in Korea from its origins in the 1940s to the 1990s.
One of the prevalent themes in the study of large scale industrial enterprises is the evolutionary nature of capitalism, including the logic of economic transformation. Based on his strategy and structure framework, Chandler charts the transformation of American capitalism from that of single entrepreneur-owned and controlled enterprise4 to stock exchange listed companies governed by professional managers, who initiated the development of large scale and multi-divisional industrial capitalism in the early twentieth century, in response to market forces (Chandler, 1962, 1977).
Some studies have provoked controversy by asserting that variations in the timing, degree and forms of growth as between European and American firms, gave rise to somewhat disparate enterprise and country-specific paths of capitalist transformation. (Schmitz, 1993: 28-48). However, many studies have thrown up somewhat similar patterns of capital transformation, for example, those of large scale industrial enterprises in Europe.5
Lazonick (1991) identifies a different pattern in...
References: Ansoff, H. (1969), Business Strategy, Penguin Books: London. Amsden, A. (1989), Asia’s Next Giant: South Korea and Late Industrialisation, Oxford: NY. Bank of Korea (1990), Annual Reports on Economic Statistics, BOA, Seoul. Chandler, A.(1962), Strategy and Structure, MIT: Cambridge. ......................(1977), The Visible Hand: The Managerial Revolution in American Business, Belknap Press: London. ......................(1982),‘The M-Form: Industrial Groups, American Style, European Economic Review, 19, 3-23. ......................(1990), Scale and Scope: The Dynamics of Industrial Capitalism, Belknap Press: Cambridge. Chandler, A., and Daems, H. (1980: eds), Managerial hierarchies: Comparative Perspective on the Rise of the Modern Industrial Enterprise, Harvard Uni. Press: Cambridge. Chang, C. S.(1988), ‘Chaebol: The South Korean Conglomerates’, Business Horizons, 31, March and April, 51-57. Cheon Beom-seong (1984), Chung Juyung, Seomundang, Seoul. Cho Dong-seong (1991), Hankukchaebol Yeonku (A Study of Korean Chaebol), Maeil Economic Newspaper: Seoul. Chung Ku-hyeon (1989), Hankukkiyeobeui Seongjang Jeonrakkwa Kyungyoungkujo (Growth Strategy and Managerial Structure of Korean Companies), Korean Commercial Industry: Seoul. Church, R.(1993), ‘The Family Firm in Industrial Capitalism: International Perspective on Hypotheses and History’, Business History, 35: 4, October, 17-43. Elbaum, B., and Lazonic, W. (1986: eds), The Decline of the British Economy, Oxford: Clarendon. Fligstein, N. (1990), The Transformation of Corporate Control, Harvard Uni.: Cambridge. Jones, L. and SaKong, Il (1980), Government, Business and Entrepreneurship in Economic Development: The Korean Case, Cambridge: MA. Hyundai Engineering and Construction Corporation (HECC: 1982), Hyundai Geonseol 35nyeonsa (A Thirty-five Year History of Hyundai Engineering and Construction), HECC, Seoul. Hyundai Heavy Industries (HHI: 1992), Hyundai Junggongeobsa (History of Hyundai Heavy Industries), HHI: Seoul. Hyundai Motor Company (HMC: 1987), Hyundai Jadongcha 20nyeonsa(A Twenty Year History of Hyundai Motor Company), HMC: Seoul Hyundai Motor Company (HMC: 1992), Hyundai Jadongchasa (The History of Hyundai Motor Company), HMC: Seoul. Hofstede, G. and Bond, M. (1988), ‘The Confucius Connection: From Cultural Roots to Economic Growth’, Organizational Dynamics, American Management Association, 16: 4, Spring, 5-21. Hong Deok-rul (1985), Hankukchaeboleui Hwankyungtongjae Kijaeea Kwanhan Yeonku (Environment Control Systems of the Chaebol), Master’s Thesis, Seoul National University: Seoul. Hyundai Group Public Relations Office (1994), ’94 Hyundai, Hyundai Group Public Relations Office, Seoul. Hyundai Electronics Industries (HEI: 1994), Hyundai Jeonja 10nyeonsa (A Ten Year History of Hyundai Electronics Industries), HEI: Seoul.
Hyundai Group Trade Union Association (1994), Hyunchongryeon Danhyeobjaryojib (Data for Collective Bargaining of the Hyundai Trade Union Association), HGTUA: Seoul. Kang, Y. G. (1990), The Rise of Korean Chaebols from the Perspective of Organisation Theory, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Arizona: Arizona. Kim, K. C. and Kim, S. (1989), ‘Kinship Group and Patrimonial Executives in a Developing Nation: A Case Study of Korea’, The Journal of Developing Area, 24, October, 27-46. Kim Beoyong-ha (1991), Chaebolheyoungkwa Kiyeobka Hwaldong (Formation of Chaebol and their Entrepreneurs), Hankuk Neungyeulhyeobhoe: Seoul. Eun-Mee Kim (1997), Big Business, Strong State: Collusion and Conflict in South Korean Development, 1960 - 1980, State University of New York Press: NY. Kim Hyo-gun (1986), Hankukcaeboleui Seongjang Baljeoneoinae Kwanhan Yeonku (The Developmental Factors for the Growth of the Chaebol), Master’s Thesis, Seoul National University: Seoul. Kim Young-ho (1985), Kyungjaeeui Hyeonjang (Reality of Economy in Korea), Dongcheonsa: Seoul. Kong Byeong-ho (1992), Chaebol, Binanbadaya Hanneunka? (Why Should The Chaebol Be Criticized?), Yeyeumsa: Seoul. Kong Jae-wuk (1993), 1950nyeondaeui Hankukeui Jabonga Yeonku (Korean Capitalists in the 1950s), Baeksan: Seoul. Korean Shipbuilding Industries Association (1991), Annual Reports on Shipbuilding Industries, KSIA: Seoul. Kwon, S.H. (1997), Control and Conflict: The Historical Development of Labour Management within the Hyundai Business Group, 1946-1995, Unpublished Ph.D. Thesis, University of New South Wales: Sydney. Kuk, M. H.(1988), The Relationship between Government and Private Companies in the Industrial Development of South Korea, Ph. D. Thesis, University of Illinois, Urbana. Lazonick, W.(1986), ‘Strategy. Structure and Management Development in the United States and Britain’, in Kobayashi, K., and Morikawa, H. (eds) Development of Managerial Enterprise, University of Tokyo: Tokyo, 101-146. ........................(1991), Business Organisation and the Myth of the Market Economy, Cambridge: Cambridge. Lee Ho (1993), Jeongsangeun Yuyeonhi Ojianneunda: Chung Seyungkwa Hyundai Motor Company (Chung Seyung and Hyundai Motor Company), Wukseok: Seoul. Lee Jong-nam (1985), Chaebol, Heyonjae: Seoul. Lee Jong-seon (1989), Jungkongeob Geodaedogjeomkieobeaseoeui Nodongwundongea Kwanhan Yeonku (The Labour Movements in Large Scale and Monopolistic Heavy Industries), Master’s Thesis, Korea University: Seoul. Lee Jung-jae (1994), Chaebol Iryeokseo (The Chaebol and its Status), Hankuk Newspaper: Seoul. Lee Sung-tae (1990), Gamchueojin Dokjeomchaeboleui Yeoksa (Hidden History of Monopolistic Chaebol), Nokdu: Seoul. Maeil Economic Newspaper (1975-1994), Annual Corporation Reports, MEN: Seoul. K. Nikagawa (ed), Strategy and Structure of Big Business, Proceedings of the First Fuji Conference, University of Tokyo: Tokyo. Park Byung-yun (1982), Chaebolkwa Jeongchi (The Chaebol and Politics), Hankuk Yangseo: Seoul. Park Dong-sun (1979), Chaeboleui Bburi (Roots of the Chaebol), Taechang: Seoul.
Park Hee (1992), Hankuk Daekieubeui Jojik Kwanriwa Nosakwangaeei Kwanhan Yeongu (Organisational Operation and Labour Relations in Big Corporations, Ph. D. Thesis, Yonsei University: Seoul. Park, Moon-Kyu(1987), ‘Interest Representation in South Korea’, Asian Survey, 27: 8, 904919. Prais, S. (1976), The Evolution of Giant Firms in Britain, Cambridge: Cambridge. Rhee, J. C. (1994), The State and Industry in South Korea: the Limits of the Authoritarian State, Routledge: London. Schmitz, C. (1993), The Growth of Big Business in the United States and Western Europe, Macmillan: London. Steers, R., Shin, Y. K. and Ungson, G. (1989), The Chaebol: Korean’s New Industrial Might, Harper Collins: NY. Tamio, H.(1986), Hankukkieubeui Kujowa Jeonrak (Strategy and Structure of Korean Firms), Beobmun: Seoul. Yang Yoo-jin (1991), Hankuk Jabonjuei Bunseok (Analysis of the Korean Capitalism), Ilbit: Seoul. Wade, R. (1990), Governing the Market: Economic Theory and the Role of Government in East Asian Industrialisation, Princepton: NY.
Please join StudyMode to read the full document