Hy Dairies Case

Topics: Marketing, Employment, Strategic management Pages: 6 (1034 words) Published: October 14, 2012
➢ Who has to make recommendation/decision: Rochelle Beauport ➢ Has to do what: To decide to either confront Gilman and change what she perceives as sexist and/or racist practices or to leave the company ➢ Why: Despite improving the sales of her brand (ice cream) for Hy Dairies she believes she is being “sidelined” because the company did not want women or minorities in top level management positions. ➢ When: Within the next few days, before she is assigned to her new job. ➢ To Whom do they make recommendation: Syd Gilman

Analysis

A. Issues and Symptoms (cause and effects)
OB issue: Potential sexist and racist practices
Evidence:
1. At Beauport’s previous job she was told that women would not be able to handle a marketing management job. 2. She believes this movement is a way to remove her from high level market management

OB issue: Lack of communication
Evidence: Gilman assumes that Beauport will appreciate the movement within the company and gain more marketing experience. He feels this is a reward for increased sales while she feels she is being moved away from her desired career path.

B. External Analysis

STEP analysis – (Any items of important?)
|Social |Technological | |Beauport believes she is being removed from management because |No significant information | |she is a physical minority | | |There is poor communication between employees and superiors | | |focusing on career goals | | | | | |Economic |Political (& Environmental) | |No significant information |Beauport may be denied a management position because she is a | | |women and not seen as a capable leader |

C: Internal Analysis

1) Detailed company information
• Although there is no proof of discrimination at Hy Dairies at Beauport’s previous place of employment, a similar position at another food production firm, she was clearly told that women and minorities could not handle a position in marketing management • Hy Dairies and Gilman believes that they are rewarding Beauport for her hard work and increased sales

2) Financial Analysis – Irrelevant to case

3) SWOT Analysis
|Strengths |Weaknesses | |Knows she wants to stay in marketing management |Poor communication with superiors on goals and direction within | |Good at her current marketing job (increased sales) |the company | | |Doesn’t see the benefits of working as marketing research | | |coordinator | |Opportunities |Threats | |Marketing research coordinator position could educate and help |Being stuck in a “backroom” job with no chance of advancement | |develop marketing skills |Being...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Hy Dairies Case Study Essay

    ...Sample Assignment  Read Case Study 3.1, Hy Dairies, on pages 85 and 86 in your textbook, and answer Discussion Questions 1–3 on your own before checking the suggested answers below.  Suggested Answers to Case 3.1  1. Apply your knowledge of stereotyping and social identity theory to explain what went wrong here. It may seem that this case involves stereotyping—specifically, that Syd Gilman has stereotyped Rochelle Beauport. In fact, there is no apparent evidence of this stereotyping. From all accounts, Gilman is sincere in assigning Beauport to the marketing research coordinator job. He seems to be providing—or believes that he is providing—a good career opportunity for further advancement. If stereotyping exists in this case, it involves Rochelle Beauport’s stereotyping of Syd Gilman as a typical sexist and racist white male. Social identity theory (McShane & Steen, 2012, pp. 68–69) applies to this case in that Rochelle Beauport has an explicit sense of her social identity as a woman and member of a visible minority in a management position. This likely occurs because these are distinctive features for someone in management, as indicated by her statement that she was “one of the top women and few visible minorities in brand management at Hy Dairies.” This strong social identity may have contributed to her perception of her...

    Read More
    677 Words 3 Pages
  • Case Study

    ... Hy Dairies, Inc. Case Study Analysis September 26, 2014 HY Dairies, Inc. Analysis Rochelle Beauport an assistant brand manager for HY Dairies and is one of the few women of color in brand marketing management. She played a prominent role in increasing the organization’s sales volume, and market share by improving sagging sales of their popular gourmet ice cream. This achievement did not go by un-noticed; Rochelle’s boss, Syd Gilman the vice president of marketing promptly offered Rochelle a promotion to a lateral position of market research coordinator. Syd justified assigning the role of market research coordinator to Rochelle because it gives her broader experience, and access to high profile work, which would enhance her career. Syd took the same path to the office of vice president of marketing; Rochelle thought this promotion was a demotion in “job status” and not a route to top management, and an implied assumption of racial inequality. Syd obviously overestimated Rochelle’s belief of moving to market research coordinator would be the same as his, and now Syd’s false “consensus effect” has threatened Rochelle’s values and dedication to HY Dairies. Concept Complexity Complexity is the distinct role or identity that people perceive about themselves; to this point Syd did not see himself as stereotyping Rochelle because...

    Read More
    773 Words 3 Pages
  • Case 3.1 Hy Dairies Essay

    ...Case Study 3.1 HY DAIRIES, INC. Discussion Questions: 1. Apply your knowledge of stereotyping and social identity theory to explain what went wrong here. The case covers issues of how perceptions affect individual decision-making process. As an introduction, Syd Gilman, the vice marketing president at Hy Dairies perceived Rochelle Beauport as a potential marketing staff responsible to improve the sagging sales of Hy’s gourmet ice cream brand, thus decided to reward her with a new post of a marketing research coordinator that was taken by him as a valuable post in marketimg field. Rochelle Beauport, unfortunately had a different perceptions and expectations that leading her into a difficult decision making situation of whether to confront Gilman on perceived discrimination issue or to leave the company. What went wrong in the case were the organizational conflicts that stemmed from merely misperceptions by Syd Gilman and Rochelle Beauport who had differing background, characteristics and work experiences, thus different social identity. These, therefore had shaped their differing social identity and engaged them in stereotyping. Gilman misperceived that Beauport would like his proposal because he had previously gone through the process which he adored very much without recognizing Beauport’s different self and social concepts as enlisted below....

    Read More
    1681 Words 6 Pages
  • Case Study: Hy Dairies, Inc.€ Essay

    ...Case Study Hy Dairies, INC.” The case study, “Hy Dairies, Inc.”, highlights an individual, Rochelle Beauport, whose career with the company seemed promising after a successful two quarters of increased sales of Hy’s gourmet ice cream. Syd Gilman, the vice president of marketing, was so impressed with Beauport’s effort and hard work that he decided to positively reinforce her achievement by offering her a position where he believed she would gain experience from higher profile work (Human Behavior in Organizations 377). During their meeting where Gilman presented the position to Beauport, she immediately drew false conclusions about the position as well as Gilman’s character without complete knowledge of the circumstance. In the following essay, we examine what occurred, what perceptual errors took place, and how these errors could have been prevented (Human Behavior in Organizations 372). When Syd Gilman approached Rochelle Beauport with the offer, Rochelle immediately jumped to the conclusion that she was being demoted from her current position as an “assistant brand manager” to a “technical support position” which Beauport thought would leave her stranded with little to no room for growth (“Hy Dairies, INC.”). Rochelle utilized the recency effect to distort her perception by basing her conclusion on her recent experience with an employer who “made it...

    Read More
    855 Words 3 Pages
  • Case Study: Hy Dairies, Inc.” Essay

    ...Case Study Hy Dairies, INC.” The case study, “Hy Dairies, Inc.”, highlights an individual, Rochelle Beauport, whose career with the company seemed promising after a successful two quarters of increased sales of Hy’s gourmet ice cream. Syd Gilman, the vice president of marketing, was so impressed with Beauport’s effort and hard work that he decided to positively reinforce her achievement by offering her a position where he believed she would gain experience from higher profile work (Human Behavior in Organizations 377). During their meeting where Gilman presented the position to Beauport, she immediately drew false conclusions about the position as well as Gilman’s character without complete knowledge of the circumstance. In the following essay, we examine what occurred, what perceptual errors took place, and how these errors could have been prevented (Human Behavior in Organizations 372). When Syd Gilman approached Rochelle Beauport with the offer, Rochelle immediately jumped to the conclusion that she was being demoted from her current position as an “assistant brand manager” to a “technical support position” which Beauport thought would leave her stranded with little to no room for growth (“Hy Dairies, INC.”). Rochelle utilized the recency effect to distort her perception by basing her conclusion on her recent experience with an employer who “made it...

    Read More
    866 Words 3 Pages
  • Hy Dairy Ltd. Case Study Essay

    ...Name: Charles A. Ford____________________Case #: 1 2 3 Date:_14 Feb 2013__ 1. Skim the Case Key Person: Rochelle Beauport | Position: Assistant Brand Manager | Other People: Syd Gillman VP of Marketing | What: Rochelle believes women and minorities cannot hold a position in upper management | Why: Rochelle received a lateral position instead of a management position | When: The situation needs to be resolved Immediately | 2. Identify the issues and related OB concepts Issues or Problems | Related Course Topics | 1.Lack of communication by Syd Gilman as well as Rochelle Beauport | The Communications Process Model encoding message experiences and noise | 2. Lack of women and minorities in management positions at Hy Dairies Ltd. | Ethical sensitivity, Neuroticism(Five Factor Model)Surface level Diversity | 3. Mrs Beauport made assumptions about the company that may or may not be true. | Perception, Role Perceptions(MARS model) | 4. External & Internal Factors Internal Factors Low visibility of minorities/women Available Positions Company Policy Previous encounters Low visibility of women and minorities Company Image External Factors 5. Alternatives to Solve Issues Options | Pros | Cons | 1. Sit and talk to Mr. Gilman and make your thoughts known. | May get a better understanding of what Mr. Gilman’s intentions are. | His answers may not sway your...

    Read More
    439 Words 3 Pages
  • Hy Dairies Essay

    ... Q 1. What are symptoms/ Red flags exist to suggest something has gone wrong? • Difference in opinions: Gilman offered Beauport marketing research coordinator position to reward Beauport’s contribution to recent increase in ice cream sales and market share because he thought that the position would broaden Beauport’s experience and boost her career at Hy Dairies. Beauport did not share the same idea: she thought that the position offered was a “backroom job” and not a route to top management. Beauport felt that she was sidelined because she was a visible minority and a woman. • Misunderstanding response: When Beauport was given a job offer by Gilman, she took a long silence before thanking Gilman because she was shocked and felt too belittled to protest. Gilman recognized this response as a sign of positive surprise: Beauport was too thrilled to respond quickly. Q 2. What are the root causes that led to these symptoms? • False-Consensus Effect: Perception differs person by person because nobody in this world shares exactly the same belief system, past experiences and social influences as you. In this case, Gilman’s perception of the market research coordinator position was the opposite of Beauport’s perception of the position. When Gilman was offered a position as a market research coordinator several years ago, he was delighted. He had a positive experience with the transfer because the coordinator position grew his...

    Read More
    961 Words 3 Pages
  • Case Study Hy Dairies, Ltd Research Paper

    ...Case Study Hy Dairies, Ltd. 1. What symptoms exist to suggest that something has gone wrong? The sales volume and market share of Hy Dairies’ gourmet ice cream brand had picked up significantly over the past two quarters compared with the previous year. As the vice president of marketing at Hy Dairies, Syd Gilman credited this achievement to Rochelle Beauport, the assistant brand manager at the time, and decided to reward her with a newly vacated post of marketing research coordinator. Based on his own career experience, Gilman was very much convinced that the marketing research coordinator job would provide Beauport with greater career potential with Hy Dairies. However Rochelle Beauport, being one of the top women and few visible minorities in marketing management at Hy Dairies, was shocked rather than excited when hearing her boss’s job transfer proposal. The contrary expectation and totally different perception led her feeling that she had been sidelined purely because of her gender and race. As a result she was put into a difficult decision of whether to confront Gilman on the company’s perceived discrimination practices or to simply leave there. These symptoms suggest that something must have gone wrong in the case. 2. What are the root causes that led to these symptoms? Before answering...

    Read More
    810 Words 4 Pages

Popular Essays

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free