“Couple sentenced in largest human trafficking cases in Canadian history” A Hungarian couple was arrested for being a part of one of the largest human trafficking cases in the country. Joszef Domotor, 45 and his wife Kristina Csaszar, 33 were caught for trafficking of humans and their enslavement. Upon detainment they admitted to being involved in a criminal organization specializing in the enslavement and trafficking of humans. The organization recruited at least nineteen other victims from Hungary, promising them a better lifestyle and employment in Hamilton, ON. However, shortly after coming to Canada the victims were treated like slaves, physically and mentally abused, and given no pay. Also, their movements were controlled by the organization and were threatened into lying to immigration and welfare. The couple had lied their way into Canada and adopted the lifestyle of the wealthy. They kept “slaves” who cared for them and their children. Four “slaves” testified against them in court. Szalaine Ban and her husband Imre Szalai were brought to Canada under the wrong impression of employment and immigration for their children, which never happened. The court ordered to pay back the fifty thousand dollars that the defrauded from Ontario Works. Domotor was sentenced to serve six years plus an extra twenty-four months after pleading guilty. Csaszar had already served eleven months in pretrial custody and ruled to be deported after pleading guilty. A total of eight pleaded guilty for all the human trafficking accusations. This case is an international concern because on an international level people are being deceived into leaving their native countries in search for some sort of employment or a better life but they are finding themselves exploited and abused. Since these victims are unaware of their rights and freedoms they would not be able to report the mistreatment. This violates Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms because the victims are held against their will, violating their right to liberty, and are subjected to cruel and unusual punishment. Not only does it infringe the Canadian Constitution but also The Universal Declaration of Human Rights violating the Articles that give them the right to liberty, not be subjected to cruel or inhuman treatment or punishment, and no one shall be subjected to arbitrary arrest or detention. This case presents an infringement on countries worldwide when victims are becoming a part of this deception. In this case, Canada, Hungary and many other nations where the victims were brought from are affected because their country’s rights are breached. Human trafficking holds a great significance on a global level. In the past decade there have been many cases of human trafficking were the victims would be forced into slavery or prostitution. In 2010, after viewing the case of Rantsev v. Cyprus and Russia the courts found that human trafficking fell in scope of Article 4 of the European Convention on Human Rights prohibiting slavery or any sort of forced labour. Many nations such as Cyprus, Germany and Cambodia validated international jurisdiction to their domestic human trafficking cases. Therefore, any citizen a part of a human trafficking case can be prosecuted no matter where the offence actually took place. Canada has also adopted the Extraterritorial laws and linked it with many of its Criminal Code offences such as cases of human trafficking and sex tourism. A total of fifteen were arrested on accounts of mislead immigration and welfare fraud along with involvement with human trafficking making this the largest human trafficking case in the Canadian history. This case also sets a precedent for future human trafficking cases that may come before the courts.
Works Cited
Birkett, Kathy. “Hamilton trafficking case- an update.” Lutheran Women. Web. 31 Mar. 2013. <www.lutheranwomen.ca/>.
“Human Trafficking- Bill C-310 – Extraterritorial Offences.” Joy Smith MP Kildonan – St Paul. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. <www.joysmith.ca/>.
O’Reilly, Nicole. “Couple sentences in largest human trafficking case in Canadian history.” The Star. Web. 27 Mar. 2013. <www.thestar.com/>.
“Constitution Act, 1982: Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.” Justice Laws Website. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. <laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/>.
“Forced labour and trafficking.” European Court of Human Rights. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. <www.echr.coe.int/>.
“The Universal Declaration of Human Rights.” United Nations. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. <www.un.org/>.
--------------------------------------------
[ 1 ]. O’Reilly, Nicole. “Couple sentences in largest human trafficking case in Canadian history.” The Star. Web. 27 Mar. 2013. .
[ 2 ]. “Constitution Act, 1982: Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.” Justice Laws Website. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. .
[ 3 ]. “The Universal Declaration of Human Rights.” United Nations. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. .
[ 4 ]. “Forced labour and trafficking.” European Court of Human Rights. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. .
[ 5 ]. “Human Trafficking- Bill C-310 – Extraterritorial Offences.” Joy Smith MP Kildonan – St Paul. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. .
[ 6 ]. Birkett, Kathy. “Hamilton trafficking case- an update.” Lutheran Women. Web. 31 Mar. 2013. .
Cited: Birkett, Kathy. “Hamilton trafficking case- an update.” Lutheran Women. Web. 31 Mar. 2013. <www.lutheranwomen.ca/>. “Human Trafficking- Bill C-310 – Extraterritorial Offences.” Joy Smith MP Kildonan – St Paul. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. <www.joysmith.ca/>. O’Reilly, Nicole. “Couple sentences in largest human trafficking case in Canadian history.” The Star. Web. 27 Mar. 2013. <www.thestar.com/>. “Constitution Act, 1982: Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.” Justice Laws Website. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. <laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/>. “Forced labour and trafficking.” European Court of Human Rights. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. <www.echr.coe.int/>. “The Universal Declaration of Human Rights.” United Nations. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. <www.un.org/>. [ 2 ]. “Constitution Act, 1982: Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.” Justice Laws Website. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. . [ 3 ]. “The Universal Declaration of Human Rights.” United Nations. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. . [ 4 ]. “Forced labour and trafficking.” European Court of Human Rights. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. . [ 5 ]. “Human Trafficking- Bill C-310 – Extraterritorial Offences.” Joy Smith MP Kildonan – St Paul. Web. 30 Mar. 2013. . [ 6 ]. Birkett, Kathy. “Hamilton trafficking case- an update.” Lutheran Women. Web. 31 Mar. 2013. .
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
This leads to the primary arguments Perrin makes in his book. Perrin emphasizes that human trafficking is persistent around the world. Even a first-world, respected country such as Canada is complicit. Another argument Perrin discusses throughout his book surrounds the victims- profiling the types of women and girls who are most frequently targeted. However the most important argument that Perrin makes is how all levels of government should address this travesty and what steps should be taken to eliminate it (xvi). He is very direct in his criticism of Canadian processes or lack thereof, surrounding trafficking and sexual exploitation. Perrin’s preface describes the moment he realized that not only were Canadians contributing to sexual exploitation…
- 1753 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
Next thing you know, you 're on the streets selling tricks and having to make at least five hundred dollars a night, and if you don 't, you get beat and abused horribly by "Daddy". This horrible tragedy happened to a woman named Tina Frundt. She told this story to The Woman Funding Network in the article "Enslaved in America: Sex Trafficking in the United States". The horrific story is used to inform U.S Citizens that sex trafficking is real and it is still happening today in our own towns and surrounding areas to more girls than anyone would expect. In this article, told by Frundt, the problem of human trafficking is addressed with as much importance as there possibly can be as she tells her story about how this had happened to her and how it could happen to anyone. As she explains how this tragedy had happened to her, she also…
- 932 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Since that time changes to the legal system have been undertaken; threat risk assessments on human trafficking have been carried out; the new Canadian Human Trafficking Action Plan was unveiled; victims have received confirmation a new Victims Bill of Rights will be drafted; and the mobilization of non-government organizations [NGO’s] have begun meeting to determine protocols on sharing information. Despite past challenges these new initiatives provide an opportunity and fresh start to refocus and take a leadership and coordination role to combat Human…
- 4101 Words
- 17 Pages
Best Essays -
This article discusses the history of human trafficking. It explores the first worldwide study conducted on the topic. The study was conducted during the 1920’s by the League of Nations and included Canada as one of 28 countries to…
- 572 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In her article, "Human Trafficking: An International Problem with an International Solution Requiring National Implementation", Melanie Franco analyzes the obstacles that victims of human trafficking face in being identified and properly cared for on in the United States. She provides an overview of legal issues in the enforcement of international human rights, focusing especially on the need for better training and administration in the U.S. Significant disparity exists between the fight against human trafficking in the U.S. and the U.N. Franco asserts that the discrepancies between the two hinder the anti-trafficking movement because the United States does not hold itself to the same standards as other countries. The Trafficking Victims Protection Act, the United States' official stance on human trafficking, provides a firm foundation for proper legal treatment of victims but is lacking in its method of identifying severely trafficked victims. Implementing international law on a national level, Franco insists, will greatly improve the effectiveness of anti-human trafficking efforts.…
- 500 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Human trafficking can be a problem. People selling human’s for money. The law is a dynamic system of regulatory initiatives that is constantly adapting to meet social change. During the last 20 years the west has seen a massive reduction in all forms of crime, for the most part, due to social economic development. This has caused major problems for the judiciary, law enforcement and attorneys like me by severely limiting our income.…
- 489 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Agencies have offered aid to victims of human trafficking; however, these offers include a requirement where “victims must agree to cooperate in the criminal investigations of their abusers” (Source F). Victims of human trafficking are more than likely too hesitant in trusting a person of authority, and those who agree are often faced with more threats either towards themselves or their loved ones (Source F). These are common reasons that prevent victims from coming forward and accepting the help that is offered to them. Without the knowledge of comfort and safety in the situation, they are more inclined to reject the offer and walk away than to speak about their experiences because they are too scared of what might happen if they do. Some appeals that were formed to defend victims have resulted in “further violations of their rights” (Source D). To demand victims to “go through the arduous task of proving themselves survivors” (Source F) is unnecessary and only shames them and their involvement. These requirements discourage victims to contribute to the prevention of human trafficking, therefore failing to raise awareness of the issue and allows both the victims and the business to remain…
- 679 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Sex trafficking is not the only form of human trafficking that happens in developed countries. Trafficking for forced labour is also an issue. In Canada, there are indications that foreign nationals have been transported and exploited by employers as domestic servants. Investigations have been conducted and charges pressed in places like Ontario and British Columbia. However, obtaining cooperation from foreign victims can be tough. They are often alone and communication efforts can be often hampered by language barriers. Additionally, victims may have a fear of law enforcement officers and think that there is nothing to be gained from cooperation.…
- 214 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
- Victim Impact Statement (Hamilton forced labor status): This Threat Assessment is the first major overview that identifies trends in Canada and provides strategic guidance for implementation efforts. It also guided government actions by preventing and combating trafficking in human beings, strengthening policies and programs to address victims' needs and target traffickers. The Royal Canadian Mounted Police constantly conducts threat assessments of this…
- 447 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Human trafficking is an ongoing criminal industry that affects the lives of many people in America, as noted before and nowhere near to being terminated. Sex trafficking, labor trafficking, and debt bondage are the three major kinds of human trafficking where traffickers generate vast amount of money and single profiling is nonexistent. Victims have diverse ethnic and socio-economic backgrounds, varied levels of education, may be documented or undocumented, etc. When focusing on the U.S. entirely, all across the map there are different reporting’s of human trafficking, and there will be a continuation of it. However, it’s essential to recognize the signs to prevent someone from being trafficked, or simply providing information and/or resources regarding human trafficking. It’s time to be conscious of the dilemma occurring in the U.S., and discuss…
- 450 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Human trafficking is very common in the United States (Mallory, 2012). Each year there are about 20,000 people falling victim to human trafficking in the U.S., typically women and children (“United States of America,” n.d., n.p.). It has been found that, “The United States of America is principally a transit and destination country for trafficking in persons” (“United States of America,” n.d., n.p.). The United States government has been active in the attempt to ending human trafficking in our country and internationally (“United States of America,” n.d.). An act was created called The Trafficking Victims Protection…
- 383 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Did you know human trafficking is the fastest increasing criminal industry in todays world, coming in second after illegal drug-trade? This type of vicious crime is considered as a modern day slavery where human beings are being traded illegally for forced labor or for exploitation. Contrary to popular beliefs, it not only exists in foreign countries, but in fact in the United States as well. I chose this topic because human trafficking is a growing problem in contemporary society which needs to be well known. An approximate of 17,500 foreigners are trafficked each year in the United States alone, the number of U.S citizens trafficked within the United States are surprisingly even higher. It is acknowledged that women and young…
- 818 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
This essay will concentrate on the two types of trafficking and how America has over looked the problem all of these years. Those two types of tracking are labor and sex trafficking. The laws that have changed concerning human trafficking have changed in the last few years. A young frighten lonely girl has run away from home. What wait for her out in the big bad world is abuse, torture, and intimidation? A man will observe her and when he talks to her he will seem very compassionate. This poor unsuspecting child has no idea that this kind understanding man is in charge of the largest human trafficking type in the United States. The type of human trafficking is called “sex trafficking”. This…
- 1124 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Human trafficking is the illegal act of forcing people, commonly women and children, to perform slave actions. Everyone knows human trafficking is a global problem, but most people do not realize it happens in the United States as well. Thousands of people are affected by this awful crime in the U.S. every day and most of the people that commit it are never caught. Sadly, most trafficking cases occur in massage parlors and spas while the customers are completely oblivious to it. The worst part about human trafficking is that kids, who are forced to commit these awful actions, are often caught and arrested for prostitution, vandalism, or curfew…
- 893 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Plotkin, M., & Hill, M. (2011, Jan 11). National human trafficking awareness day. The York Dispatch Retrieved from…
- 474 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays