Preview

Howard Zinn's Columbus And Western Civilization

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
500 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Howard Zinn's Columbus And Western Civilization
My understanding of history changed as a result of what I learned this unit. Prior to reading Howard Zinn’s Columbus and Western Civilization, I believed that history was infallible. I saw Columbus as a hero who paved the way for colonization in the Americas. What I didn’t know, were the covered up facts hidden from us by the improper reconstruction of history. I knew that Native Americans were abused by Europeans, but I never pondered the fact that Columbus abused them as well. “He ordered the natives to find a certain amount of gold . . . if they did not meet their quota, their arms were hacked off.”
“History, then, is both the past and the study of the past.” History can be used for many things. Some historians believe we can learn from the past, while others believe that there is a limit to the usefulness of history. I had no idea that the possibility of using history to solve today’s problems existed. Both points of view make sense. On one hand, world leaders tried to appease Hitler because they recognized that they had been too hasty in causing World
…show more content…
. . a group of persons united by a common error about their ancestry and a common dislike of their neighbors . . ." Historiography was originally about making one’s country seem better than others. This could be taken as if he was saying that people are united by lies about their past. As historiography developed, it became more centered around how history can be used to solve problems in the present. For example, in the middle ages, historians were trying to figure out God’s plan for humanity. Now historiography is about trying to discover hidden pieces of the past. Then again, I believe that all these methods can, and are, used in the present; however, it is up for the historian to decide. This quote from Furay says, “. . . any history we read is as much of a product of the historian . . . as of the people who actually lived the events . . .” and exemplifies the historians

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Authors Peter McDonald and Lynn Anderson said, “Where the greatest need for re-education is apparent, is in understanding that the brutal vision of conquest which Columbus ushered in so long ago continues unabated to this day.” Columbus did not discover America as so many of us have been led to believe. The definition of discover is “to see, get knowledge of, learn of, find or find out; gain sight or knowledge of something previously unseen or unknown” (Random 563). Textbooks generally disregard his many crimes committed against humanity by intentionally omitting them, simultaneously magnifying his role as a great navigator. They glorify him and humanize him to induce…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    After reading Howard Zinn’s viewpoint on Columbus, the Indians, and the human progress I can now confirm/characterize that Columbus is, as historical figure, not a hero, but somewhere in between being a hero and a villain (being more towards a villain). Throughout the whole reading the reader can notice how Colombus’ mistake of finding a new route to Asia and mistakenly discovering an unknown land to the Europeans caused great pain for the natives who were forced into labor/made into slaves to go find and bring Colombus gold, so he can give it to Spain for them to send more ships to Columbus to get more gold for the country’s wealth, and when they couldn’t find any they would be killed. Colombus’ discovery led to many deaths and the Europeans…

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Columbus, The Indians, and Human Progress,” was written in 1999 by Howard Zinn, and it discusses some of the early interactions between Europeans arriving and colonizing the Americas and the Native Americans who lived there. Zinn quite clearly states the viewpoint of this article, saying he tries, in telling history, “not to be on the side of the executioners.” In other words, Zinn’s article focuses primarily on the effects of the Europeans on the Native Americans, highlighting specific cruelties committed intentionally by the Europeans more than the effects of disease. As far as historical context goes, Zinn covers a wide range of areas, from Peru to the Eastern Coast of North America, and a relatively large range of dates, from Columbus' original…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    DuBois on his test. These writers uncover the agonizing parts of American history, with a specific end goal to give a more honest picture of occasions and how they affected groups other than the white men in authority. As to First Nations or Native Americans, Zinn scrutinizes Columbus' own newsletters and requests that the reader view the developing of colonization from the point of view of the general population whose land, employment, society, and lifestyle would be horribly stolen and assaulted. At the point when "the past is told from the perspective of governments, conquerors, ambassadors, leaders," the outcome is a skewed form of history intended just to support the idea that Europeans by one means or another conveyed enlightening power to the savages they experienced. (Zinn, Chapter 1) Schoolchildren are taught to revere Columbus, and make idols out of slave proprietors like Thomas Jefferson. As DuBois points out, the fact that these statements have for so long stay unchallenged is the core of what isn't right with history – and with the nation. Indoctrinating kids is a certain method for propagating forms of social injustice and…

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In David A. Stannard's book, American Holocaust: Columbus And the Conquest of the New World, Stannard discusses the cruelty he says Christopher Columbus inflicted upon Native Americans and how it was comparable to the genocidal acts of World War II. This debate arose roughly thirteen or so years ago, and before then people thought Columbus could not have possibly done something so horrific. However, there is evidence to support the claims, and the idea that Columbus may have been crueler than previously believed is becoming less and less taboo.…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My fellow congressmen and senators, today we convene to discuss the repercussions of events that occurred nearly three-hundred years before our nation's birth; events that, had they not occurred, it is a certainty that the United States of America would not exist as it does today. The event I am speaking about of course is the world famous voyage of the Italian explorer Christopher Columbus, and his subsequent discovery of the American continents. One thing that is not disputed by any historian of merit is the fact that Christopher Columbus' landing in the America's led directly to the European colonization of the area, and this colonization (which Columbus was directly involved in) was brutally exploitative, and fatally devastating to the natives of the area. While Christopher Columbus is a…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Zinn’s thesis for pages 1-11 talks about how history only tells itself from the viewpoint of the rulers and victors. Zinn’s goal is to tell about history from the viewpoint of the victims, such as the fate of the Arawak Indians when Columbus landed in the Americas.…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Columbian Legacy Summary

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In order to understand the extent to which Old World ideals are embedded into the fabric of our own institutions it is necessary to search for the truths about the Western discoverers amongst the plethora of myths and nationalistic propaganda. The Columbian legacy is one of discovery and dominion over native peoples, the ecological environments that natives were participants of, and all natural resources within the new found American paradise. And while it can be said that tribes of humans dominating other humans and their habitat was not uncommon in the world, including amongst the people of the Americas; the anthropocentric behaviors of Columbus and other Europeans were unique amongst the cultures inhabiting the new European discovery of the American continent.…

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Howard Zinn Critique

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Howard Zinn’s history shows an alternative point of view, but not an alternative history, compared to many historians. If many historians considered Columbus great, Zinn shows how he is not so great; if many historians say the Native…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1492 Christopher Columbus set out on a voyage of discovery (Discovery for his civilization group, for what he found was already inhabited), a voyage that would inadvertently shape the world. Today, over 500 years after his initial voyage, we still discuss the consequence of this voyage. Columbus Day in the United States is a holiday that was celebrated as early as 1905, and became an official federal holiday in 1937. Presently the debate has risen on whether this date should be recognized or celebrated, with places such as Los Angeles along with other cities moving to replace the second Monday in October to Indigenous Peoples Day. In this paper I will argue why we at Cal Poly Pomona should not “Celebrate” Columbus day, but why we should…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    History is the procedure used to analyze what was significant about chosen events, individuals, and advancements from the past. Historians utilize distinctive arrangements of criteria to help them make judgements about essentialness. All theories have to base on data. To make the country become better, people needs the data from the past to guide their country to the bright future. The old said: “the one who controls the past controls the future.”…

    • 937 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bartolome de las Casas

    • 453 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The impressions I had about Columbus’ discovery of the New World are completely destroyed by this firsthand account of the horrible truth concerning the native people of America. In both middle and elementary school, I read about the discovery of Christopher Columbus and the evils of both the settlers and Native Americans. Never before, though, had I heard of the torturous, unprovoked attacks directed at the innocent. Never before had I felt such disgust toward people claiming to be Christians. Never before had I known how good and virtuous the natives, at least a large portion of them, were toward the settlers and in their lifestyles. We spend so much time in our schools learning about the horrors of World War II and about how Jews were discriminated against to the point of extermination towards extinction. Civil rights are also studied, and I am in no way displacing the crucial reminders of what African Americans went through in the United States’ past. However, although history textbooks typically mention settlers taking lands, killing off tribes, and taking advantage of the Indians ignorance in the ways of earthly possessions and worth, all I have ever learned concerning the unfair treatment adds up to nothing more than a single scratch on a gory corpse. Compared to this brief, breathtaking, bone-chilling account, I consider my days as blissfully ignorant over as the ugly facts melt away the sugar-coated excuses of angry, murderous tribes forcing…

    • 453 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    When Historians understate the faults of columbus, rather than condemn him, he is given praise for his discovery of America. I agree with the author for saying that “... but an ideological choice. It serves- unwittingly-to justify what was done”, because instead of giving all the facts of what really happened, historians give the facts that serve the common interest of the people.…

    • 63 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The True Columbus

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages

    History has always been a topic that I personally have never thought could be wrong or false; it has always been something that I thought was unquestionable, but Hans Koning opened my eyes to the fact that we should always question history and explore things further. The stories told about Columbus are those of heroism and adventure, but Hans Koning explains in his book Columbus: His Enterprise that our beliefs on who Columbus was as a person are astray. Koning says that the story of Columbus is “Eurocentric” and told to glorify the European civilization of that time period; therefore, the most important argument that Koning makes in his book is that Columbus really was a selfish, and greedy con artist.…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Columbus Day

    • 657 Words
    • 3 Pages

    With Columbus Day rapidly approaching us, a day celebrated by millions upon millions of people who dearly believe that he is a hero, you begin to wonder. Do these people know what they are celebrating? While yes, he “discovered” the New World, however people fail to acknowledge that Columbus was in fact a mass murderer. In all likelihood, he brought to life “the worst case of genocide imposed on one nation of human beings by another”.…

    • 657 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays