Preview

How Is Masculinity Portrayed in Looking for Alibrandi

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
621 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
How Is Masculinity Portrayed in Looking for Alibrandi
How is Masculinity Portrayed in Looking for Alibrandi?
The movie Looking for Alibrandi has many aspects of masculinity even though it centres around a female character’s life’s changes through time and experience and the affects and influences of people; especially male around her. The term masculinity as defined by an Oxford dictionary means ‘having the properties characteristic of the male sex’. Several aspects of masculinity can be found through thorough analysis of Josephine’s relationships with others, most distinguished being Jacob Coote, John Barton and Michael Andretti.
During the time period at which Josephine starts year twelve and ends it, she falls in love twice with two boys; Jacob Coote and John Barton. Both young men represent two different opposing types of personality, social status and primarily; masculinity. John Barton is shown to be gentle and popular and his strong English accent indicates high status. He is serious about his work, is the captain of the school and someone that appears to be very attractive to many females. During a scene in the film when he walks into the girl’s school, god like music is played and the facial expressions of the girls are shown to be in bliss. Although John displays many masculine factors he still lacks some as in the countless conversations he has with Josie, he continues to mention how he does not have a clear path indicating what to do with his life evidencing his lack of independence and strength.
“You get into punch-ups with other girls, you wipe your nose with your sleeve... you're my kind of chick.” Jacob Coote on the other hand is more of the care free, slightly rough and belonging to the ‘lower classes’ in society. His figure is very muscular and sport like and his personality reflects his behaviour and outer shell as he appears to be very casual in the way he dresses and talks. The way Jacob perceives the world is different to the way John sees it as Jacob is an atheist and John is a Christian.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Two of those characters who were searching for the meaning of masculinity were Frank Stark and his son Jim Stark. On many occasions, Jim struggles with how to be masculine, like when he is faced with The Kids group leader Buzz who challenges him to a drag race. Jim feels the need to prove himself to the group and everyone he meets that he is a man with his rebellious actions. Jim looks to his father for help on how to actually show the world that he is a man, but his father cannot come up with an answer for Jim. Frank cannot produce an acceptable model of masculinity for Jim to follow because he himself is unsure of how to appear masculine part of which is from his overbearing wife who believes she is always right. (lecture/film, 11/12)…

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the novel and towards the ending Michael is genuinely reflected as a positive fatherhood figure for Josie. With Michael and Josie both dismissing each other at the beginning, Michael shows persistence in wanting to re try the father role which results in Michael and Josie to see each other more often. When Josie gets herself in a pickle at school with a girl named Carly, she depends on her father to help her out. When Michael defends his daughter, Josie truly accepts Michael as her father. “For a few minutes I knew how it felt walking alongside one’s…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    So I hit her with it.” Carly’s father demands that Josie get a lawyer so she rings her father. “Andretti walked in... he was also glaring at me so sharply that I felt no need for celebration.” Here Josie is fed up with Carly’s racist comments so she hits her. She is sent to the principal’s office to await her punishment. Josie takes the risk of calling her father to get her out of the mess she’s created. This example is important because it helped me understand them both better and like them both a bit more because Michael does come and he is constructive as he resolves the conflict. She “liked the feeling of having her father beside her when she walked out of school”. Josie relies on her father for the first time. This helped me to understand her ‘hang ups’ as most teenage girls have a cool dad to help them out, should they ask. In my opinion this shows that Josie is starting to develop feelings towards Michael as she has depended on him. Also Michael had to leave work to help her. He’s not used to being a dad but came anyway. This shows that he too, is starting to warm to the idea of a new family member. Their relationship takes off from…

    • 666 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The novel Looking for Alibrandi effectively explores the theme of change, it is seen through the novel that Josephine Alibrandi, the main character and narrator, significantly changes as an individual, friend and family member as her perspective on life changes throughout the year. First person narration gives the responders an insight into Josie’s mind and reveals how her feelings change towards Jacob Coote and the changes that occur in her life. As she is “beginning to realize that things don’t turn out the way you want them to” the readers feel empathy and suspense as she narrates her inspirational story. Another technique Marchetta uses to create suspense and also add tension to the storyline is by adding ellipsis which leads up to what Josie reveals to the readers. As Josephine is almost peer pressured into becoming intimate with her short term boyfriend, she stops and says “until … maybe until I’m engaged”. The use of ellipsis illustrates the tension between Jacob and Josie, but reveals that Josie does not change even though Jacob is pressuring her, this adds to the character of Josie and proves to the audience that she is strong and will stand up for herself. Therefore Marchetta portrays that change may be hard to avoid, although the right change is needed to become the person we desire to be. Josephine is strong enough to…

    • 1012 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Quote page 8 “it makes me feel like I will never be part of there society and I hate that because im just as smart as they are” all josie wants to fit in and be liked by her pears and even thought she was originally voted school captain but instead given the post as vie captain she ignores the fact that she was voted by her fellow students and is actually in fact quite popular and is a trend setter within the school. Sister Louise tells josie on page 184 that she has to” learn that sometimes you have to keep your mouth shut, because what you do reflects on this school and on me and others” this was a shock to josie because she didn’t believe she had a impact on…

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Oh Josie is a wonderful and social friend to talk and fun to play with. She talks open-mindedly and truthfully, listens to what other people says and replies back with respect” says Sera, one of Josie’s best friends. Sera is the only person from school that has the same nationality as Josie. “Because we have the same ancestry we have a thin bond, we always have most of situations and attitudes in common like when we greet each other how we talk to each other and hate each other”, she laughs.…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Among the many relationships Josephine develops throughout the novel, the relationship she establishes with Michael Andretti her father is by far the most important. The bond between Michael and Jose doesn’t really exist until Josie hits carly in the face with her science book, breaking her nose and most likely her modeling career, although carly provoked the attack her father is determined to sue Jose. As Michael comes to redeem her, Josie feels proud to have a…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Despite the fact John and Vincent live in two completely different worlds over three centenaries apart they both experience the same struggle against society and are both considered failures in their communities but grow by overcoming their inadequacies. Miller uses John who is a man who holds a great belief in holding and maintaining a respectable title within the community to show how his suffering can lead to growth. John suffers through his own actions when his affair with young woman, Abigail Williams, sets in motion a series of events that eventually ends with him being accused of witchcraft. John is given two choices, either lie and offer a public confession to witchcraft and be saved from the gallows or tell the truth and refuse to confess. Initially John signs his confession but not willing to allow to whole town to think he is a witch, ruining the reputation he has worked so hard to earn. He passionately tears the confession in two and when asked why he exclaims "Because it is my name! Because I cannot have another in my life! ... I have given you my soul, leave me my name!" Miller uses this tearing of the confession to signify the moment in which John's suffering turns into growth as he rallies the courage to stand up to the court and retain his good name. Unlike John, Vincent is born with his inferior genetic makeup and suffers from birth as he "…belonged to a new underclass, no longer determined by social status or the colour of your skin." The underclass Vincent is referring to is a group of people who are known as the 'In-valids' who posses an…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Masculinity is a theme that has been addressed in society for many years the issue of masculinity is expressed in the texts All new people and Streetcar named desire, the men are seen as brutal forces of society but from different perspectives; One of the 1950’s post war reality and the other reflects the modern freedoms .In the play A Streetcar named Desire, masculinity means aggression, control, physical dominance, and even violence. Accompanying these traits is a general lack of refinement, manners, and sensitivity. One point of view expressed in the play is that this sort of brute masculinity is primitive and sub-human another is that it is attractive and sexually appealing, alternatively freedom and liberalism has left the men in All New People as victims of society, and it has left them without strong role models, power, community, faith or rules.…

    • 2014 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Looking for Alibrandi

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Josephine Alibrandi’s relationship with her family has its highs and lows. Josie’s family impacts her as an individual in different ways and makes Josie feel suffocated by her family and religion. Josie and Jacob are in a strong relationship and Josie’s family culture as a 'wog' controls her love life and friendship life, and restricts her from going to places. “I'll run one day. Run for my life. To be free and think for myself...I'll run to be emancipated.” .The relationship between Josie and John changes in various ways at different stages. Through this relationship Josie discovers more about what is important in life and learns to accept herself for who she is. As years pass, she and Nonna develop a connection the leads to Nonna Katia revealing a big family secret that has a huge impact on the Alibrandi family’s name.…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Looking for Alibrandi

    • 1103 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The characters of John Barton and Jacob Coote have several similarities. John and Jacob are in a same age group of same generation; both are high school year 12 students. They both have leadership in their school, one is the captain of cook high and one is the private college’s student leader (Marchetta, 1992). Their leadership attributes attract Josephine becoming a friend with them. Also John and Jacob have been experiencing the adolescence’s periods as well as Josephine. These two boys have self yearn and both of them want freedom and the rights to choose their own future (Marchetta, 1992). The novel shows John has significant communication problems with his parents and families; there is a serious gap between him and his parents. Part of the reason is because they are politician and have excessive expectation from John which makes him feel extremely stressful and unconfident. Similarly, Jacob has the same communication problems with his families. Eventually the lack of communication, the ignorance and indifference in john’s feeling from his family culminates in…

    • 1103 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Pigman

    • 11745 Words
    • 47 Pages

    He is a sophomore in a New York City high school. He is terribly dissatisfied with his life and misbehaves in interesting ways to try to give meaning to his own existence. He appears to have great potential and wants to be an actor. Like most teens, he will eventually discover that he, and he alone, makes his life whatever it will become. John is a complicated guy. First of all, he has a real problem with any kind of authority. He is in constant conflict with his father; he lies to his teachers and refers to them as "retarded." In fact, he lies to pretty much everybody, except Lorraine. In school he spends his time setting off firecrackers in the bathroom and playing pranks on substitutes, though he says those days are behind him now. Despite disliking authority figures and school, he's really smart and can get good grades when he wants to. However, more often he uses his intelligence, good looks, and charm to manipulate people. Lorraine tells us that John is "extremely handsome" (2), and John immodestly agrees: "Like Lorraine told you, I really am very handsome and I do have fabulous eyes" (3). John writes that he's "going to be a great actor" (3), and, with his good looks and imagination, we can well believe it. John also has a softer, compassionate side, and thinks deeply about the meaning of life and death. Lorraine tells us that John would be "the last person on earth" (2) to show that he has compassion, and that he pretends he doesn't care about anything in the world. He is only fifteen, but is already a heavy drinker and a heavy smoker. Let's break this down:John and his ParentsJohn does not get along with his parents, especially his father, whom he refers to as "Bore." One of the first things we learn…

    • 11745 Words
    • 47 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Looking For Alibrandi

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The emotive word ‘bastard’ got directed towards Josie many times which made her feel alone yet through pathos moments did she realize that being illegitimate was unimportant. “I always hated being illegitimate. I always did until the other day when I realized it was nothing.” Josie yearned to be society’s definition of ‘cool’ and her clouded judgment directed her beliefs of what she wanted into an entirely different direction. “Please God let me be accepted by someone other than the underdog”. She deemed that the hierarchy of events in her life to be ruled by acceptance from others and it became a motif that repeated itself until one day when she understood. Only when she reached her identity did the trivial and material parts of her life vanish and the real ones cemented.…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Society interrupts a child’s growth and individuality. In the case of Joan / John, he was living a “double life”. He knew at a very young age that something was wrong. He didn’t like being put in dresses or playing…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Another example of how masculinity is depicted in the novel is the society’s view on farming. In the third chapter it says, “His mother and sisters worked hard enough, but they…

    • 1291 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics