Preview

How Far Was the Dispute over Berlin in the Years 1958 – 1961 the Primary Cause of the Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962?

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
3914 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
How Far Was the Dispute over Berlin in the Years 1958 – 1961 the Primary Cause of the Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962?
Between the years 1958 and 1961, the dispute over Berlin (often known as the ‘Berlin Crisis’) was one of the main issues between the USA and USSR, and caused a considerable amount of growing tension between the two states. The dispute over Berlin was a continuing issue over who was to occupy Berlin, the capital city of Germany. The city was seen as an important area for both states and led to several conflict issues throughout the time period. It could be argued that this issue and the tension caused by this was the primary reason (or, the main reason) for the Cuban missile crisis in 1962. The Cuban missile crisis was an issue over the placement of nuclear weapons on the island of Cuba by the Soviet Union and brought the world closer than ever to nuclear war. However, the Cuban missile crisis cannot be solely blamed on the dispute over Berlin. Other reasons that could be linked to the development of the Cuban missile crisis include Bay of Pigs, the actions of individuals (such as Kennedy’s personal views and actions over Fidel Castro and Cuba), the existence of US Jupiter missiles in Turkey, the validity of storing Soviet missiles on Cuba and the need to close the missile gap. This essay will examine the significance of each of these possible causes and how far they affected the Cuban missile crisis, in comparison to the dispute over Berlin.
The Berlin crisis between 1958 and 1961 was a primary issue for the USA and the USSR. Since the end of World War Two in 1945, Berlin had been divided into the West Berlin (for the USA, UK and France) and East Berlin (for the USSR). Both sides were determined to keep control of their half of Berlin and it was seen as vital in the strength and success of each country as a whole. US General Clay said ‘when Berlin falls, western Germany will be next. If we mean to hold Europe against communism we must not budge’. This suggests that keeping control of West Berlin was incredibly important to the Americans and if they were to lose



Links: like these made Cuba and the Soviet Union closer and gave Khrushchev a reason to defend Cuba when it was found that the USA were not pleased with a communist society so close to them. The placement of nuclear missiles in Cuba helped ensure this security. The Soviet Union saw the Cuban revolution as a success for Marxism-Leninism and therefore needed the support. The USA could not attack after this support out of fear of devastating retaliation. In December 1962 after the crisis had ended, Khrushchev claimed ‘our purpose was only the defence of Cuba.’ This is supported by Paterson in 1990, saying the USA made efforts ‘to harass, isolate and destroy the radical government in Havana’. This revisionist view suggests that Khrushchev’s placement of missiles on Cuba was necessary to protect the country and that it was not done so in an intention to threaten the USA. However, despite the intention of protecting Cuba, the actions of Khrushchev had repercussions of endangering the USA which therefore lead to the Cuban missile crisis. If Khrushchev truly wanted to protect Cuba, he could have done so in a way that did not involve nuclear weapons. This suggests that although Khrushchev may have wanted to protect Cuba, it also provided a good outlet for him to show the nuclear strength of the Soviet Union. After the Berlin crisis, it appeared that Khrushchev had the upper hand in Cold War relations. It could be suggested that, to improve on and take advantage of this, Khrushchev developed Cuba as a big issue to show and continue his success. By deliberately antagonising the USA with the placement on nuclear missiles so close to them, Khrushchev was able to develop a situation where he had the opportunity to address the Soviet Union as the leading world power. This did not happen – it may be that the Cuban missile crisis grew larger than Khrushchev ever expected and therefore lost control. However, it was a good opportunity for Khrushchev and also allowed Russia to readdress themselves as the leading communist power. The rapid growth of China (a communist state) was threatening to Russia as they may begin to lose their communist power to China, therefore a deliberate antagonism on the issue over Cuba gave the Soviet Union a chance to show how they remain the strongest communist force in the world. Due to propaganda within China, the general view of Khrushchev was that he was reluctant to back revolutionary movements. The placement of missiles in Cuba, a country with revolution, would instantly prove this propaganda wrong. It is likely that Khrushchev was trying desperately to continue the power and success he has achieved so far in the Cold War and in the spread of communism and by using Cuba to antagonise the USA, one of the world’s leading powers, Khrushchev could reaffirm the strength and power of the Soviet Union as a whole and show to the world that communism can be strong. However, as the Cuban missile crisis became so close to nuclear war and wide-spread destruction, it is likely that Khrushchev did not intend to make such a large crisis through his deliberate antagonism – it caused too much of a crisis than expected. From the above evidence, it can be suggested that although the dispute over Berlin in the years 1958 – 1961 was one of the causes of the Cuban missile crisis of 1962, it was not the primary cause. The crisis was caused by a variety of factors shown above – primarily the tactical placement of the nuclear missiles so close to the USA and the need for protection of the borders of the USA and Cuba. The Cuban missile crisis was brought about by building tension between the USA and the USSR following World War Two and cannot be solely blamed on one event over a short period of time. The dispute over Berlin helped create the tension that led to the actions of the USA and USSR – for instance, if Kennedy was not humiliated over Berlin, he may not have felt the need to prove his strength with the Cuban missile crisis. However, it was not the primary causation and the Cuban missile crisis was caused and developed by a combination of factors from the USA and USSR.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In October of 1962, John F. Kennedy was faced with the first crisis of his administration. The Soviets were building nuclear missile sites on Cuba, and one of JFK’s first actions was to give his famous Cuban Missile Crisis speech on October 22, 1962. JFK uses repetition, ethos, and pathos to discredit the USSR’s international standing in the world. JFK give his speech to show the people that the government has their best interests at heart. He tells the citizens about what the government has learned and what they intend to do about it. To reassure the people of the US, he describes what he has done so far, and what he plans to do in the future. In the main part of the speech, JFK turns to what the Soviets have done and the implications of this. He does this to unify the country against the Soviets. To unify them he explains how the Soviets have endangered everyone who lives in the western hemisphere, and how this has never been done before. He reinforces this by repeatedly stating that what the Soviets have said are lies. To further discredit the Soviets he shows their disregard for international agreements and for the people living in the western hemisphere.…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unit 9 Final Project

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In 1962, The United States caught The Soviet Union building nuclear installations In Cuba. This event embodied the dangerousness of the nuclear arms race in that it very nearly caused the end of the world. The article title reads, “Khrushehev Offers to Scrap Cuba Bases.” This event was brought to its heights when Kennedy ordered a blockade of Cuba preventing any ships from coming or leaving the island. The Soviet ships actually closed within miles of the blockade before being ordered to turn around by their president. Had the Soviets crossed the blockade they would have surely been blown out of the water thus starting a likely nuclear holocaust.…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Cuban Missile Crises also can be called the October Crisis, had occurred on October of 1962 for 13 nerve wreaking days. Nerves were high not only for the American people who believed the Soviets could and would annihilate their very existence, but also the people of Cuba and the whole world. The blockade of navy ships surrounding the island of Cuba would only be a reaction to a nuclear war and cause a World War III. Everyone was on edge, the whole world would be affected in one way or another and millions would die. The fate of the world laid with three men, U.S. President John Kennedy, Nikita Khrushchev, and Fidel Castro. “It is insane that two men, sitting on opposite sides of the world, should be able to decide to bring an end to civilization.”…

    • 1801 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The president soon learned that the leaders of the Soviet Union had different plans regarding the United States and the spread of the communist influence. During these years, the Soviet Union sought to extend their ideas to neighboring countries such as Cuba and other close by European countries in order to eventually make communism a worldwide idea practiced by all prominent nations. This presentation of the Soviet Union's determination portrays a possible reason as to why Kennedy may have felt obliged to engage militarily with the potential communist nation (Cuba) in order to resolve these conflicts of disagreement and reluctance to communism itself. As tensions worsened, military confrontation in Cuba approached. The relationship between Cuba (Fidel Castro) and the Soviet Union (Nikita Khrushchev) is an important one to mention. The connection between these two nations resulted directly with Kennedy's apprehension to the idea of communism gradually spreading to neighboring countries. The relation between Castro and Khrushchev developed during Eisenhower's presidency (1960 to be exact), when Khrushchev gave aid to Cuba. As Eisenhower learned about this growing relationship between the two, he immediately broke diplomatic relations with Cuba (1961 - one of the final acts of his during his…

    • 3633 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    For many who remember President Kennedy favorably, the answers to those questions are likely: JFK and the Soviet Union, respectively. This analysis of the Cuban missile crisis lacks nuance and is riddled with bias. To understand the history of the missile crisis, it is necessary to understand what shaped President Kennedy’s actions during those thirteen days and break from the popular account of Kennedy’s heroism and calculated strategy in diverting a nuclear…

    • 2042 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Jfk Was a Great President

    • 1443 Words
    • 6 Pages

    On October 22, 1962, President John F. Kennedy “informed the world” that the Soviets were building secretive missile bases in Cuba, very close to Florida. President Kennedy decided to take the peaceful route in handling is major crisis. As President, his first move was to talk to Premier Nikita Khrushchev and demand the removal of all missile bases, and “deadly content” in Cuba. Secondly, President Kennedy had “U.S. forces around the world…placed on alert. More than 100,000 troops deployed to Florida for a possible invasion of Cuba. Additional naval vessels were ordered to the Caribbean. B-52s loaded with nuclear weapons were in the air at all times.” (The World). He ordered a naval quarantine/blockade on Cuba to prevent Russian ships from bringing additional missile and construction materials to the island (Goldman).…

    • 1443 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Berlin dispute was a pivotal factor throughout the cold war period and should be considered a primary cause of the Cuban crises. West Berlin was a enclave deep in East Germany. Its very existence repudiated the East German government’s claim to be the legitimate government of all of Germany. In 1948 and 1958 war had seemed near as the Soviet Union tried to force the west out. In 1961 the Berlin Wall had been built to prevent a mass exodus from East to West Germany, this was humiliating for the Soviets. Yet Khrushchev still wished to remove the western presence totally. Stalin was forced to resort to trapping people in East Berlin to stop them from escaping, not the best propaganda image for communism. The Soviet leadership was clearly intent on protecting Soviet interests at this juncture and viewed the west with increasing suspicion. It was a catalyst to conflict between the west and communist states and therefore a possible cause of the Cuban missile crisis. Khrushchev may have placed missiles in Cuba to use them as a bargaining tool with the US in hope that discussions would lead to the West staying out of Berlin, in exchange for the removal of the missiles in Cuba.…

    • 3288 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The trigger for the Cuban Missile Crisis occurred when reconnaissance photos taken by the United States of Cuba showed a significant Soviet build-up of strategic missiles. Cuba was 150 kilometres from the American mainland, and this was considered to be a considerable threat on behalf of the Soviets.…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    In both cases, protagonists were influenced by the particular events, their domestic and geo-political state of affairs and the signals delivered and counter offers made from parties involved. This essay analyses the scenario, role of actors, and description of the outcomes of the two crises. The paper argues that the advent of the nuclear age, following World War II in 1945, shaped contemporary international relations. What makes the Cuban Missile Crisis fundamentally different was precisely because it occurred during nuclear age. This essay will outline some of the concepts such as deterrence, mutual assured destruction doctrine, and the concept of balance of terror to justify why the nuclear age has shaped events after World War II. The essay concludes by affirming the need to rethink and revisit the role of nuclear weapons in the 21st century.…

    • 2601 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Presidential Doctrines

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Hershberg, J. (n.d.). The Cuban Missile Crisis, 1962: Anatomy of a Controversy. The George Washington University. Retrieved July 31, 2011, from http://www.gwu.edu/~nsarchiv/nsa/cuba_mis_cri/moment.htm…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This author provides a concise but not oversimplified review of the many complicated aspects of this affair; wich brought the world to the age of nuclear war. This book helps me to have a better point of view about all Cuban Missile Crisis revolution of 1962 including some Cuban points of view and also American points of view, wich are very important to have a better understanding of this big event.…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, other historians such as Paul Du Quenoy argue that it was in fact the degrading of Soviet image worldwide that caused Khrushchev to be ousted. In the Cuban Missile Crisis of 1962, Khrushchev had ordered nuclear missiles to be placed on Cuba in order to counter those which the United States had placed on Turkey. However, when the United States discovered the missile bases which were being constructed, President Kennedy authorized a blockade on Cuba, preventing any missiles from being delivered. The standoff resulted in Khrushchev backing down and removing the missiles bases on Cuba. The perception was that Khrushchev had loss his battle of wits with Kennedy, causing a major humiliation…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In 1959, the Cuban government was overthrown putting Fidel Castro in place as leader. The United States did not support Castro so he turned to the Soviets for help and they supported him and the new Cuban government became a communist government. In May of 1962, the Soviets then secretly built nuclear weapons in Cuba, and they largely went unnoticed. However, the Soviets were not the only ones with nuclear weapons pointed at their enemy. The United States had nuclear missiles in Turkey aimed directly at the Soviet Union. In October of that year, an American U-2 spy plane spotted the missiles and things turned tense. Congress debated whether or not they should attack and destroy said missiles in Cuba. They were unsure if more missiles were on Cuba and were afraid that there might have been. Tense negotiations took place between the two leaders at the time, Kennedy and Khrushchev. Attacks were expected to happen, however they never came. On October 28th, both sides had backed down and agreed to remove their respective nuclear weapons. This event came to be known as the Cuban Missile Crisis.…

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists (2016), have recently moved the doomsday clock, a symbolic indicator of the end of the world to 3 minutes to midnight much closer than it has ever been. In the aftermath of World War II, two global superpowers emerged, each with acutely divergent outlooks on future geopolitics. The Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR) and the United States of America would become embroiled in a crisis that would bring the two nations closer to war than ever before. This paper will assert that if not for expert diplomacy and superior crisis management skills exhibited by President Kennedy, the Cuban missile crisis would perpetuate increased tensions resulting in war between the Soviet Union and the United…

    • 122 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The personalities of who was to be blamed for the Cuban missile crisis can be traced as one looks at the events in th1950s which led to Cuba's deteriorating relations with the USA and its subsequent alignment with the USSR, which led to the placement of missiles in Cuba and the consequent tensions that followed. This relations has its origins in the quest for self interest by newly elected leader, Fido Castro, as while as search for national security by both superpowers from the tension passed down from the cold war in Europe ( qualify). Kennedy's search for national security precipitated the crisis when his search translated into actions that directly went against Cuba and pushed Cuba away from the US and into support of the USSR. Kennedy failed to consider that Castro's intention to establishing diplomatic relations with the USSR was not to antagonize the US or threaten its national security but mostly for economic benefits. ( the US had earlier refused to grant a loan to Cuba and there were continuing disputes over American property in Cuba). This failure to interpret events correctly led US on its intense quest for national security by instituting economic embargoes on Cuba and direct intervention as seen in the Bay of Pigs invasion. However, such actions were needlessly aggressive for its national security was not threatened in the first place. This however caused a deep…

    • 1392 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays