According to the authors of the essay 's "School is Bad for Children" and "School 's Out" John Holt and Daniel Pink think there are many flaws in the United States ' educational system. They also feel that there is a need for a change. They recommend and think that the teachers should have different types of teaching techniques, the curriculum should not just be taught in the class room, but taught with example, and that standardized test should be abolished.
Holt believes that the curriculum doesn 't allow children to become and individual. Every since they started school they were told to sit down and pay attention to a teacher talk. That 's it. The student cannot talk to his friends or walk outside and that can only be done on school trips. Holt believes that a student will learn by leaving the school building. He believes that the student should be supplied with the hands on approach to learning. If the class is learning about an event in history they should be brought to a historical place and learn by actually seeing what they are being told. This will give the child an opinion. When the child has an opinion this makes a class discussion more interesting because now the discussion is not only between the teachers to the students. Now the student actually has something to say back. Now let 's look at it from Pink 's point of view. He thinks that the teacher is not keeping the students attention. He thinks that the teacher is forcing them to learn instead of wanting them to learn. If the student were given more choices for what they would want to learn instead of being forced to learn. Due to the lack of classes that caught the attention of the students, the students fall of task. The army is the only thing trying to give the students something to look forward to because they are offering free schooling and a job. The parents that are not pleased with how the school is teaching there child are just removing their child from the school and home schooling them.
Another issue that these authors had was with standardized testing. Holt believes a test can 't tell how smart a student is. All test tell you is what a student does wrong. If a test has ten questions on it and a student gets five wrong and five right. A student will most likely get in trouble for the five wrong be for the student receives praise for the five he got right. This both Pink and Holt believe that students have different learning styles. Some students may not be good test takers. Others may, but know one is focusing on those students who are not good test takers. The school system only looks at one learning style and everyone can 't adjust to this learning style.
Both authors have different opinions on standardized testing. Pink believes that the test is a way of having control of, or controlling the students, and Holt just does not like them and believes that tests do not help students. A common phrase you will here a teacher say is if you do not get good grades on your test you will not get in to a good school. When the teacher says this he or she is trying to make the students feel better than on another. So if the student does not pass the test he or she is not as good as the people who did, and as a result will not be successful. Both Pink and Holt believe that this is wrong to do and fell that the test should be abolished. I the teacher really wanted a student to be successful than the teacher would try to cater to each students learning style.
The way a child learns is a critical aspect in teaching a child. Some children learn by reparation and some learn by a teacher talking to them for eighty-two minutes. There are many different ways but teachers only know one way. A student does not always understand how to do things a certain way. So if a teacher can teach it more than one way the student will learn it. Pink says, "One size fits all." This may be the case when it comes to costumes, and spandex pants, but not when it comes to children and their learning ability to learn. And again if the student didn 't learn what the teacher taught that day in class and has to take a test the following day. The student will do bad because he did not understand. This can also make the student feel lower than others because the people than did understand got better grades than he or she did.
Even though Daniel Pink and John Holt 's opinions are far from alike they both see eye to eye and think the educational system and the way teachers teach has many flaws that need to be work out immediately. In the present day you may see some of the flaws they stated changed. Today there are more field trips and some teachers are learning to teach in many different ways, but something 's just wont change.
Work Cited
Pink, Daniel. "School 's Out" Kirzner and Mandell 112-123
Holt, John. "School is Bad for Children" Kirzneer and Mandell 106-111
Cited: Pink, Daniel. "School 's Out" Kirzner and Mandell 112-123 Holt, John. "School is Bad for Children" Kirzneer and Mandell 106-111
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In today’s society, private and public schools have paid more attention on education; however, there is abundance of room for the private and public schools to improve on their ways to teach education. What schools need to do is bring in new and appropriate academic class, to maintain control and to make sure that they are teaching on a continuous base and using the current standards provided by their department of education (Colliver, 2011).…
- 969 Words
- 4 Pages
Powerful Essays -
“Waiting for a School Miracle”by Diane Ravitch is an article about the current Educational System. In the text we can see how the author is discontent with the current system. This is evident from the very first few sentences of the article, “Ten years ago, Congress adopted the No Child Left Behind legislation, mandating that all student must be proficient in reading or mathematics by their school would be punished.” From this sentence alone can see the differences between Diane and the system. Diane believes that the achievement if student must be appreciated collectively.…
- 319 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In both essays, “Against school: How Public Education Cripples Our Kids, and Why” by John Taylor Gatto and “The Naked Source” written by Linda Simon, the problems with education system and how to reform it is demonstrated. They both declare that how courses curriculum ruins students’ curiosity and imagination by dividing them with test ratings. However, in order to make the best out of each person teachers must support student’s abilities. Talent development is essential in order to satisfy their infinite curiosity. Nowadays, obedient citizens are the product of obligatory schooling. Inevitably, It leads to mental exhaustion. When the reason of children’s boredom was asked by John, the students demanded to do “Something Real” rather than sitting…
- 334 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Fake and gay. Most people would have the same sentiment about the primary and secondary school systems in America. While the argument against the public school system is often presented to the masses in segmented bits and pieces, John Taylor Gatto attacks the meat of the issue in his essay, “Against School.” A retired teacher of thirty years, he engages readers in a conversational dialogue and outlines the ways the educational system fails to address the age-old question: how do I reach these kids? It turns out that the solution is not to try to reach these kids, but to make these kids reach for the knowledge themselves. By differentiating between the definitions of…
- 935 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In the essay, Against School, John Taylor Gatto, expresses his strong belief in middle diction of how students in the typical public schooling system are conformed to low-standard education in order to benefit the society much more than the student themselves; causing schooling to be unnecessary as opposed to education . He believes that children and teachers are caught in extreme boredom as a result of repeated material. This boredom also causes a lack of maturity and independence in the students. Gatto wrote this essay in 2003 which appeared in Harper’s magazine. He gathered these observations during his 30 years of teaching in the best and worst schools of New York City. In 1991, he was named the New York City Teacher of the Year and later on New York State Teacher of the Year. He has written many publications on his experience with being an educator including Dumbing Us Down: The Hidden Curriculum of Compulsory Schooling (1992) and The Underground History of American Education (2001). This essay was most likely written to inform any American reader (student, parent, and teacher) of the reality of our modern schooling, based on Gatto’s use of modes of development and formal diction.…
- 890 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In the story “Against school: How public education cripples our kids, and why” the author, John Taylor Gatto, establishes the idea of how public education can lead to a negative impact on students. School train kids, “[to become] employees and consumers…” (Gatto 231) instead of teaching kids how to deal with certain situations that my come across in life. The story was directed to parents with kids in elementary school.…
- 458 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
John Gatto is the last one would expect to be a retired school teacher, as he preaches the flawed ways of the public school system to anyone who will listen. In his 2003 essay, Against School, Gatto interprets six ideas from Alexander Inglis’s Principles of Secondary Education. These concepts were founded on the basis that with a large Prussian influence in American culture, an educational system was founded with the goal of rendering citizens less capable. Gatto witnesses this in the first of Ingis's purposes, titled “the adjustive/adaptive function.” The adjustive function describes how schools are designed to teach students to properly…
- 1173 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Many people of all ages have different views on education. In the following essay I will compare two authors’ ideas on the educational system in America. I will share my thoughts from the essays titled “Against School” by John Gatto and “I Just Wanna Be Average” by Mike Rose and how they relate to my experiences and schools today.…
- 470 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Have you ever wondered if you received the best education growing up? Can you recall a bad teacher that made you hate the class they were teaching? For some of us, having good teachers meant getting good marks in school. In "Waiting for Superman", Davis Guggenheim, demonstrates throughout his documentary on the importance of good teachers and schools, and how they have a tremendous impact on students and their education. We can make our students futures brighter, if schools get more involved in the education of their students. Rather than making decisions that are not in the best interest for our children's education, schools need to focus on providing better education for children. To stop so many schools from being failure factories.…
- 752 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
As a teacher of 30 years, John Gatto had a first hand experience with the cruelty of standardized testing and the curriculum derived around it. What Gatto found was that teachers and students agreed on being bored, but blamed one another for the boredom. Students claimed the teachers were not interested in the subject nor knew much about the subject. Teachers claimed the students to be rude and uninterested. Both sides are a products of the 12 year school program’s conditioning creating an endless factory of childishness. Gatto states instead of creating a prison-like environment for students and teachers alike, we should encourage the best qualities of being young by being more [flexible] with time and tests. Thus creating more competent adults.…
- 303 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
One of the biggest problems with Mr. Moore’s essay is that he doesn’t have a clearly defined purpose. He has an opinion, no doubt, but the purpose of the essay is somewhat unclear. Throughout the essay, it seems as if Mr. Moore is trying to educate the reader about the problems of the American education system and who is to blame for those problems. But then near the end of the essay, Mr. Moore addresses high school students and provides specific direction on what they can do to “stir it up”. While this section is humorous, it doesn’t seem to go along with the essay and is not a good enough ending to tie everything together.…
- 782 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
He wrote an article called "Still Separate, Still Unequal" about poverty schools compared to wealthy schools. This article also included a story about a student teacher wanted to bring in a pumpkin for her students because it was around Halloween. The only way that the teacher would be able to bring in something like that would to try to apply it to some curriculum to help educate the children while they carve the pumpkin. So she created a curriculum that would contain science, arithmetic and some language of arts. Even though she created a lesson for them, it still did not apply to California's standardized test that the children would have to take but it did give the children a new insight on objects such as pumpkins. This lesson even though it would not help them would stick with them for a while. They are always the strongest topics when a teacher actually takes their time to develop a lesson that would help a child learn the curriculum rather than the curriculum just handed to them right away like in Mike Rose article on "I Just Want to Be Average." Mike Rose, a professor of education from UCLA, wrote this article about the segregation in schools and how differently classes can be taught. He said in this article that one of his teacher as a kid was not very educated in English that the students would have to "read the district's required text Julius Caesar aloud for the whole semester and once they were done, the students would continue to read the book over and switch parts." Does this really educate a student? To just give a children a book and say "here, you read this and find the meaning out for yourself." I find that doing activities and at least talking about the book gives you different…
- 1015 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Educational programs demand effort and dedication to be successful. Barber expresses his concern for the lack of literacy in America. In Barbers essay, he states, “As America’s educational system crumbles, the pundits, instead of looking for solutions, search busily for scapegoats” (Barber, 2014, pp.210). America’s government takes minimal actions toward the educational crisis. The situation resembles a hole in the wall that needs fixed, but instead of fixing it America’s society hangs a picture over the hole. The lack of educational reforms causes the America’s youth to fall behind other countries youth in literacy. The lack of effort from the government, from schools, parents, teachers, and students put a strain on learning. Some American citizens proclaim that they want a change in the school systems, but nothing results from it. Barber states, “With all the goodwill in the world, it is still hard to know how schools can cure the ills that stem from the failure of so many other institutions. Saying we want education to come first won’t put it first” (Barber, 2014, pp.217). Society labels schools as “prisons,” and sadly, some are less safe than actual prisons. The lack of safety forces students to focus on their own safety rather than learning. Not all schools provide safe environments for students; The result of this problem is conflicts and disinterest for learning. The lack of effort put forth by America’s society and government is only one factor in this multitude of…
- 822 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
School reform includes a number of programs and policies. A reform normally changes or affects the way a school is ran; there are two types of reforms; one deals with curriculum the other administration. Today, many school reforms are driven by the idea that U.S. students need to be more competitive. To retain this country 's international leadership, our schools must prepare all students to be productive in the world marketplace. In a highly competitive world economy, business leaders are concerned about the future of our workforce. Educators think we expect too little from our children. Basic skills are no longer enough. Students need not only to have a good understanding of the core academic subjects, they must also be able to solve problems, make decisions, and be prepared for responsible citizenship and productive employment in our nation 's modern economy (What does School Reform means to my neighborhood Schools?, 2010). The purpose of the paper is to discuss standard school base reform; its beginning and how it affects the students today.…
- 1360 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Gatto, John Taylor. "Against school: how public education cripples our kids, and why." Harper 's Magazine Sept. 2003: 33+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 9 Apr. 2012.…
- 2556 Words
- 11 Pages
Better Essays