Top-Rated Free Essay

History Evaluation of Sources

Good Essays
History Part C: Evaluation of Sources
(Source 2)
‘The History of Philippines’ by Kathleen M. Nadeau.
This source originates from the United States and was first published on 2008 by Greenwood Publishing. Greenwood specializes in publishing academic and general interest books, texts, books for librarians and other professionals. We can thus assume that the purpose of the book was for educational purposes, where it was written to inform people. The fact that it originated from the United States and not Philippines, this source can be targeting an American audience, most likely being students, with the purpose to educate and teach them about events that have occurred in the past. The author, Kathleen M. Nadeau, is an assistant professor and applied anthropology coordinator at California State University; the book is most likely meant to be for educating university students, as the author is a professor in that field.
This source is valuable as the text was published rather recently on 2008, it shows that information could be more accurate as more data or documents could have been collected and corrected. It would also be more up to date, where information could cover a wider range as more time has passed for collecting information and after discussions and clarifications, the information presented could possibly be more accurate as compared to previous texts. Though this can also prove to be a limitation as information could have been lost as well throughout the years, such as through misinterpretation or through manipulation of information where certain countries can be more biased. Loss of information could have also happened as time passes, such as documents being lost or destroyed or witnesses to the event passing away.
The source can also be valuable as it is a book to educate University students, this shows that the information they give would be accurate and less biased, considering as well the time it is published, where the main focus of the book was to present information. Though, since this was created in America and the Americans were involved in the history of Philippines, the information could have a more biased representation of the information, where they document the events that took place in their point of view. The purpose of educating American University students poses a limitation as well as America may show their involvement in the history of Philippines in a more positive light, wanting to educate their younger generation to see their country in a positive image as well. Though seeing the close relationship America has with the Philippines, their prejudice towards their own country may not be so extreme. Though on the other hand, the limitation of which their point of view may be prejudiced, other readers are able to attain information about Philippine history in the American point of view.
Nadeau, Kathleen M.. "The Colonial Rule." The history of the Philippines . Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 2008. 54-63. Print.
(Source 4)
‘Philippine History and Government’ by Gregorio F. Zaide and Sonia M. Zaide
This source originated from Philippines and was published by All-Nations publishing on 2007. All-Nations publishing is an organization with a Christian vision for the nation. Their objectives being to serve the nation with the present elementary, high school and college with textbooks written by Christian authors and integrating biblical Christian values as well as to uphold biblical principles of living and management. From this we can assume that the purpose of this book is to teach students of the Philippines the history of their country and its government through biblical Christian values. Another purpose could be simply a general reference book for anyone who wishes to gather information about Philippine history and government.
One of the values of this source is that it originates from Philippines and it is about Philippine history and government, thus the information would be in Philippine’s point of view, which would result in a more accurate portrayal of Philippine government and history as it is able to present first hand accounts as well as a more inside view and perspective of the events that had occurred in the Philippines. Though this can also prove to be one of its limitations as the Philippines would be biased towards their own country and people, where in cases in the past such as government ruling or the American and Japanese occupations, the book can portray Philippines as a more innocent party in these events as victims rather than a neutral stand of simply portraying the events that had occurred. Seeing as how the book was published under the All-Nations publishing’s, where they uphold Christian values and wish to integrate textbooks with these values, the book would be a valuable resource as it is able to explain the events that occurred with moral Christian values, though it is also a limitation as it may prove to be judgmental and biased to those only who practice Christianity. It can also be a limitation as they may manipulate the information so as to best fit Christian values such as censor out any inappropriate content which may be a bad influence to its readers.
The authors, Sonia and Gregorio Zaide, are both professionals in their field. Sonia is the first Filipina to attain a Master of Science (M. Sc.) and Doctor of Philosophy (Ph. D.) degree while Gregorio was a Filipino historian and a multi-awarded author. He was one of the founders of International Association of Historians of Asia (IAHA) and he was thrice president of the Philippine Historical Association. This shows that the book is valuable as the authors have credibility and are reliable sources in their field and thus the book would provide accurate and useful information as both authors specialize in history as well as politics. Though both authors are form Philippines as well, once more this can be a limitation as they may be biased towards the Philippines, though this can also be useful as they can provide a Filipino perspective and insight to the events that had occurred.
Zaide, Gregorio F., and Sonia M. Zaide. "UNIT 2 the colonial area." Philippine history & government . Fifth ed. Metro Manila: National Book Store, 1987. 133-166. Print.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    evaluation of source

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Contents 1. Definition 1 a. How to do evaluation of sources 2 1. Definition e-val-u-a-tion /ɪˌvæljuˈeɪʃən/ (noun) [ uncountable and countable ] A judgment about how good, useful, or successful something is. Synonym: assessment (Longman Dictionary, Professor John Wells, Jan. 10 2011) Word family Word origin verb evaluate Date 1700 - 1800 noun evaluation Language French Origin évaluation, from évaluer ‘to evaluate’, from value ‘value’ Example Sentences:…

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Evaluation of Sources

    • 298 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Aasim Sayani Evaluation of Sources HOA Published in 2010, Dick Weissman’s book Talkin’ ‘bout a Revolution: Music and Social Change in America focuses on music in America that dates back to the early 1900’s, but incorporating key facts about the music of the 1960s. Weissman goes in depth about the different musicians that had an impact during the 1960s, and also talks about how the history of America and music were interrelated. Weissman states specifically how and why historical events such…

    • 298 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Source Evaluation

    • 2340 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Source Evaluation: Patient Informatics Introduction Frequently in healthcare valuable time, finances, and resources are spent due to the lack of communication and accessibility of patient information. This waste of resources comes in the form of unnecessary testing, because a similar test had been completed at another facility; and unnecessary questions that could have already been answered, such as allergies and confounding health issues. This reduction in efficacy is manifests in higher than…

    • 2340 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Source Evaluation

    • 673 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Source Evaluation I have decided, because my career goal is to become a Neonatal Nurse Practitioner (NNP), that I will investigate the role and job outlook for this position—to educate myself and to produce a source evaluation paper at the same time. Since I have had to look for sources before, I know that the online database ProQuest is an excellent way to find reliable and credible sources. The title of the source that I found on ProQuest is called “Working Together: Neonatal Nurse Practitioners…

    • 673 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Source Evaluation

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages

    chose. I will set out to prove that fast food is not to be blamed for obesity. A source that I am considering using is an Article titled “Fast Food Consumption and Increased Caloric Intake: a Systematic Review of a Trajectory Towards Weight Gain and Obesity Risk,” by R. Rosenheck. I will need to read and review this source to see if it is relatable to my research topic as well as if it is credible enough to use as a source. Author’s Credentials Robert A. Rosenheck graduated from Yale Medical School…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Introduction History is about learning about the past, acquiring knowledge and information to validate facts. Historians will analyse and examine a sequence of historical sources ranging from artefacts, films, and oral interviews. Such sources may serve as some sort of historical evidence to historians, but it’s thus important for them to consider the validity and authenticity of their sources. Evaluating sources and documents is the main priority this paper will be clarifying, and thus discuss…

    • 519 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Source Evaluation Example

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Source Evaluations This source, “Parental Mediation, Online Activites, and Cyberbullying,” comes from SIRS. Author, Dr. Gustavo S. Mesch, has a Ph. D in sociology. Dr. Mesch did a study on cyber bullying. This study was part of CyberPsychology & Behavior Volume 12, November 4, 2009. Mesch automatically establishes himself as a trustworthy source by writing Ph. D. after his name. In his references he uses other studies from journals and periodicals. Mesch goes on to talk about what cyber…

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sources of History

    • 2195 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Sources of History Sources of information provide the evidence from which the historian obtains facts about the past. In writing history, the historian not only relies on past thoughts rather re-enacts it in the context of analysing the documents and other records left. This is an indispensable condition in the quest for historical facts. Primary sources are those that have witnessed the event that took place or have been part of the incident being studied. These include written records…

    • 2195 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Source Evaluation Police brutality has been a continuously debated topic for decades, between the American people and law enforcement. In recent years, the controversy of police misconduct lead to countless publications of books, articles, newspapers, and well-known online sites that discuss the issue on hand in America. Being an arguable topic for decades, there are sources about the controversy that are entitled with bias. With that being said, it's crucial when researching for sources that it…

    • 1474 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    such with how Vincent is shot dead by Butch, but returns on-screen a few scenes later due to the timeline. Another example being how the opening scene of the movie isn’t resolved until the end, as Tarantino employs a major distortion of real time. Evaluation: Kevin Barr presents a clear and well stated thesis that introduces the article and is well supported throughout the reading and within the film. His thesis is that even though the term ‘narrative’ has been used to describe the overall connection…

    • 1086 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays