top-rated free essay

HHS Abortion and Contraception Mandate: When an Abortion Is Not an Abortion

By yelaanne Jan 22, 2014 823 Words
Ariela Ann Dimaano
BSIT II-2

When Is an Abortion Not an Abortion? When the Media Says So. By Drew Belsky & Dustin Siggins
Shortly before the New Year, a number of religious organizations were given protection from the HHS abortion and contraception mandate.  While social conservatives and defenders of the First Amendment cheered, numerous prominent media organizations manipulated basic scientific facts to deny that the mandate -- required byfederal law -- forces people to fund abortion-inducing drugs. Media Matters did this at least twice, on January 1 and January 2, with the The New York Times and NBC News doing likewise.  While Pew Research did not deny that the mandate requires abortion funding, its weaselly assessment of the debate surrounding the mandate was almost as bad.  To wit, Pew stated that many with religious beliefs "oppose abortion and believe that using emergency contraception like the morning-after pill is akin to abortion" (emphasis added). Like Pew, Politico tried to have its cake and eat it, too (emphasis added): While the FDA calls those products [i.e., intrauterine devices (IUD) and "morning-after pills" like Plan B and ella] contraception, many organizations say that they could prevent the implantation of a fertilized embryo, which they consider akin to abortion. These excerpts are symptomatic of the media's aggressive push to frame the HHS mandate as a contraception issue.  But the coverage of potentially abortifacient drugs like Plan B and ella, as well as indisputably abortifacient intrauterine devices (IUD), makes this an abortion issue as well. As pointed out at JustFactsDaily.com last February:

[R]egardless of whether Plan B, Next Choice, or ella cause abortion, the Obama administration is forcing insurers, and thus, their customers to pay for devices that destroy embryos before they implant, which many doctors, scientists, and citizens consider to be abortion. And this says nothing about IUDs, of which HHS's own Office of Women's Health says, "It [sic -- If] fertilization does occur, the IUD keeps the fertilized egg from implanting in the lining of the uterus." So how do Media Matters, the Times, and others justify their claim about the mandate's abortion requirements?  They say life begins at implantation, not fertilization, and thus drugs and devices like Plan B, ella, and IUDs do not cause abortions. This is a Clintonian strategy: it all depends on what the definition of "conception" is.  Also "pregnancy," "contraception," and "abortion." First, "conception": in 1965, the American Congress (then the "College") of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) changed its definition of this term to denote implantation of a human blastocyst in the uterine wall, rather than the union of spermatazoon and ovum to form a unique single-celled human organism.  Under this new definition of "conception," any drug or device that destroys the new human being after fertilization but before attachment to the mother's uterus is a contraceptive rather than an abortifacient. But doctors are not above being wrong.  And with a moment's scrutiny, even the average citizen can tell that this definition is absurd. First and foremost, one can find ample scientific evidence that human life begins at fertilization.  Likewise, embryology textbooks declare fertilization, not implantation, the beginning of a human's existence. One can also simply apply common sense: are we human beings because of what we do (implant in our mothers' uteruses), or because of what we are (living organisms with human DNA)?  The latter definition resonates on a fundamental level -- indeed, advocacy groups from abolitionists to suffragettes have used it to push for rights and privileges based on common, inherent humanity, not on actions or behavior.  Even homosexual activists use this tactic to great effect. With the above understood, one's definition of "conception" will necessarily color what one means when referring to "contraception" and "abortion."  Using ACOG's -- and Planned Parenthood's -- "implantation" definition of conception (and, therefore, pregnancy), there would have to be six to twelve days when a woman's body shelters and supports a new human life -- yet, according to ACOG, she is not pregnant. Semantic gyrations like these are as ludicrous after nine months as they are after nine days.  Take the other end of the pregnancy spectrum: the left often defines abortion as "termination of pregnancy," which means that even C-sections and births by induced vaginal delivery qualify under this absurd definition, as do miscarriages. It's clear that when one uses the accurate definitions of "conception" and "pregnancy" -- founded on fertilization -- any drug or device that prevents implantation in the mother's womb is an abortifacient.  The copper IUD, included in HHS's mandate, qualifies without question, because it is designed to kill a baby after fertilization and before implantation. Regarding Plan B and ella, there is intense debate about whether these drugs, and others like them, interfere with implantation.  However, packaging warns that the drug may destroy a newly conceived human being (referred to as "a fertilized egg" on the box), and the scientific evidence strongly indicates that ella kills "a fertilized egg."

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Abortion

    ...Abortion Should be Legalized             The issue of abortion is very controversial in today's society.  Although many people think it shouldn't be legalized, there are just as many who  think it should.  Your opinion rests with you and possibly the values you were  brought up with.  Whether you think women shou...

    Read More
  • abortion

    ...Abortion is the termination of pregnancy by the removal or expulsion from the uterus of a fetus or embryo before viability.[note 1] An abortion can occur spontaneously, in which case it is often called a miscarriage, or it can be purposely induced. The term abortion most commonly refers to the induced abortion of a human pregnancy. After viabili...

    Read More
  • abortion

    ...“Abortion” Thesis: Unintended pregnancies and induced abortions are common and occur among women of all social and economic groups. Where the abortion rate is high, it likely reflects that levels of contraceptive use are not sufficient to meet the fertility desires and family planning needs of women and couples. A. I am against ab...

    Read More
  • Abortion

    ...Abortion It is a growing problem in today’s society the rate at which young women are choosing to make the decision for an abortion. There have been debates over what is right and wrong in the form of abortion, whether it should be legalized or banned. The most notable being the 1973 Roe vs. Wade court case that inevitably in ended in the leg...

    Read More
  • Abortion

    ... Abortion Should Remain Legal Ashley English 3° February 21, 2013 Abortion Should Remain Legal Keeping abortion legal would protect women’s health, provide families with an alternative choice, and eliminate pregnancy laws that conflict with our free society. I. Protect women’s health ...

    Read More
  • abortion

    ...happen? Why me? How are you going to take care of a child that you are not ready for? Then abortion pops in your mind, thinking that will be the best, fastest way to fix the unwanted problem, but it is not. Nothing good comes from aborting that is why it should be illegal. There are many reasons why but the three main reasons why I believe it sh...

    Read More
  • Abortion

    ...Abortion has been one of the biggest controversies of all time. Many people believe it is immoral and even consider it to be murder. The definition of abortion is; “The termination of pregnancy by the removal or expulsion from the uterus of a fetus or embryo prior to being capable of normal growth.” 1 These pro-life believers do not support ...

    Read More
  • Abortion

    ...Abortion- Should it be legalised or not in Mauritius? Abortion means the termination of pregnancy before its completion. Abortion medically exists in two major forms. 1. The SPONTANEOUS abortion, which is defined as the termination of pregnancy without any medical or criminal interference. 2. MEDICAL abortion, which means the termination of ...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.