Henri Fayol and Henry Mintzberg

Best Essays
Topics: Management
Henry Amm

Fayol or Mintzberg –
Who is right?
Date: 11/12/2011
Student Number: 110369257
Version 1.0

The task: Henri Fayol presented his analysis of the management function in 1916 and it has largely been superseded by the more descriptive approaches of what managers actually do, such that favored by Henry
Mintzberg. However, it could be argued that the image portrayed by Fayol is superior to that of Mintzberg, and the latter’s description is of rather ineffective management! Who do you think is right?

Fayol or Mintzberg – Who is right?

By Henry Amm

Introduction
With his work General and Industrial Management (1949, in French 1916) Henri Fayol was a pioneer on the field of management theory. (Pryor & Taneja, 2010) Many more were to follow, some supporting Fayol’s thoughts and some, i.e. Henry Mintzberg in The Nature of
Managerial Work (1973) saying that Fayol’s views are not holding true today.
This essay will take a closer look at strengths and weaknesses of both Fayol and Mintzberg and conclude that Fayol’s work still is not only relevant to our contemporary understanding of management but also superior to Mintzberg in terms of its conceptualization and applicability to modern organizations.

Description of Fayol’s work
According to Fayol (1949) all industrial organisations consist of six different groups of activities: technical, commercial, financial, security, accounting and management. As he was a manager himself, or in other words an administrator, he devoted his work to the latter activity, management.
Fayol identified five key functions or “elements” of managerial work, which is regarded as the classical theory and often referred to as the “management process” (Dessler, 1985, p. 4):
(1) Planning and forecasting: examining the future and laying out the actions to be taken
(2) Organising: laying out lines of authority and responsibility.
(3) Co-ordinating: laying out timing and sequencing of activities; binding and



References: Archer, E. R., 1990. Towards a revival of the principles of management. Industrial Management, 32(1), pp Brooks, I., 2009. Organisational Behaviour: Individuals, Groups and Organisation. 4th ed. Dessler, G., 1985. Management fundamentals: modern principles & practices. 4th ed. Reston, VA: Reston Pub Fayol, H., 1949. General and Industrial Management. London: Pitman. Fells, M. J., 2000. Fayol stands the test of time. Journal of Management History, 6(8), pp. Lamond, D., 2004. A matter of style: reconciling Henri and Henry. Management Decision, 42(2), pp Mintzberg, H., 1973. The Nature of Managerial Work. New York, NY: Harper & Row. Mintzberg, H., 1975. The Manager 's Job: Folklore and Fact. Harvard Business Review, 53(4), pp Mintzberg, H., 1979. The Structuring of Organizations. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Pettinger, R., 2007. Introduction to Management. 4th ed. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan. Pryor, M. G. & Taneja, S., 2010. Henri Fayol, practitioner and theoretician – revered and reviled Wren, D. A., 1994. The Evolution of Management Thought. 4th ed. New York, NY: John Wiley.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Henri Fayol vs. Henry Mintzberg. Functions vs. roles Henri Fayol and Henry Mintzberg are “two sides of the one coin”. Each man has his own opinion on what the manager does. Fayol has his “five functions” and Mintzberg has his “roles of management”. In this essay I will discuss both men’s opinions and try to come to a conclusion on which I think is better. Henri Fayol, a French management theorist and managing director of a French mining company, came up with the five functions…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Henri Fayol or Henry Mintzberg; Management, management today is one of the subjects with the most widely branched areas. Management is an area under discussion and criticised since many years before till today by many contributors and authors. There have been developed many ideas and notions regarding the right way to manage and been successful manager. Some of the most important contributors are Henri Fayol and Henry Mintzberg with two different views but, in the same time very similar…

    • 2001 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Fayol and Mintzberg

    • 1915 Words
    • 6 Pages

    industrialist, Henry Fayol, the classic management portrays 4 functions known as POLC: Planning, Organizing, Leading, and Controlling. However, in the late 1960’s, Henry Mintzberg undertook a careful study of 5 executives to determine what these managers did on their jobs. In Mintzberg’s framework, a manager consists of 3 roles: informational roles, interpersonal roles, and decisional roles. Throughout this essay, the structure will be first about discussion of Fayol and Mintzberg theories in management…

    • 1915 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fayol and Mintzberg

    • 892 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Fayol and Mintzberg The aim of this project is to highlight what management is all about. Management is a vague term which many theorists have different interpretation. It has become an important part of our society and also in our daily activities. Based on my research, management is the process of getting activities completed efficiently and effectively with and through people. In this essay, I will be comparing and contrasting the views of management with two profound theorists, Fayol and Mintzberg…

    • 892 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Fayol and Mintzberg

    • 2179 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Introduction Since Fayol left his general manager office, separated management from business operation and studied it, management has become an independent subject. A number of academics and entrepreneurs are desirous to find what management is and how to be a successful manager. Therefore, through varied approaches, many different views about management has been appearing such as Fayol’s function theory (1949) which based on his owe managing experience and Mintzberg’s 10 roles theory (1973) which…

    • 2179 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Henri Fayol

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Henri Fayol (Istanbul, 29 July 1841 – Paris, 19 November 1925) was a French mining engineer and director of mines who developed a general theory of business administration that is often called Fayolism.[1] He and his colleagues developed this theory independently ofscientific management but roughly contemporaneously. Like his contemporary, Frederick Winslow Taylor, he is widely acknowledged as a founder of modern management methods. Biography Fayol was born in 1841 in a suburb of Istanbul, Ottoman…

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Henri Fayol

    • 4032 Words
    • 17 Pages

    Henri Fayol (1841-1925) Principles & Functions of Management Henri Fayol, a French engineer and director of mines, was born in a suburb of Istanbul in 1841, where his father, an engineer, was appointed Superintendent of Works to build a bridge over the Golden Horn. They returned to France in 1847. Fayol studied at the mining school "Ecole Nationale Supérieure des Mines" in St Etienne. At nineteen years of age he started as an engineer at a mining company "Compagnie de Commentry-Fourchambeau-Decazeville"…

    • 4032 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Henri Fayol

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages

    2013 Henri Fayol and the Functions of Management Henri Fayol once said, “To manage is to forecast and plan, to organize, coordinate and to control”. Fayol, a French engineer and industrialist, was the first to identify the functions of management. To him these functions were known as planning, organizing, commanding, coordinating and controlling. Modern management theorist have changed these functions to only planning, organizing, commanding (leading) and controlling. Henri Fayol…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    to define management are Henri Fayol and Henry Mintzberg, both of which have similar and contrasting views of management. When discussing these two theories, one of the most commonly asked questions is: “Is the work of managers’ best described by the objectives of management or the roles one undertakes as a manager?” This is a question posed since 1971, when Henry Mintzberg established his contemporary theory on Management roles, which evidently differed to Henri Fayol’s 1949 classical theory…

    • 2558 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Henri Fayol

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Jayson Casias Principle of Management Henri Fayol Henri Fayol, a French engineer and director of mines, was born in a suburb of Istanbul in 1841, where his father, an engineer, was appointed Superintendent of Works to build a bridge over the Golden Horn. They returned to France in 1847. Fayol studied at the mining school "Ecole Nationale Supérieure des Mines" in St Etienne. At nineteen years of age he started as an engineer at a mining company "Compagnie de Commentry-Fourchambeau-Decazeville"…

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays