Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Have You Restructered for Global Success?

Better Essays
1190 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Have You Restructered for Global Success?
Harvard Business Review Reflection
Course name: Introduction to International Business
Subject matter: HBR Reflection
Details article
Title: Have You Restructered for Global Success?
Author: Nirmalya Kumar and Phanish Puranam
Journal: Harvard Busniss Review
Date of publication: October 2011

BHM Have You Restructured for Global Success?

Introduction
The article at hand ‘Have You Restructured For Global Success?’ written by Nirmalya Kumar, professor of marketing and Phanish Puranam, professor of strategy and entrepreneurship, at London Business School. They also are the codirectors of the school’s Aditya Birla India centre and the coauthors of India Inside: The Emerging Innovation Challenge to the West . It was published in the Harvard Business Review in October 2011, pages 123 – 128.

The article argues that companies should adapt to a new structure, the T-shaped country organization structure, since the existing structures are, according to the author, not sufficient enough to tap into the full potential of emerging markets.

Summary
Because of the enormous grow of emerging markets in the first decade of the 21st century multinationals were eager to develop new strategies. However, structural changes have been slow. According to the authors, the three existing structures (the front-end/back-end structures, the matrix structures and the transnational structures) are not sufficient enough to tap into the full potential of emerging markets because of three reasons. The first reason is; as of late China and India are major sources of demand with distinct consumer needs. Existing structures don’t longer anymore respond adequate to these needs in these two markets. The second reason is; China and India are becoming important sources of talent in innovation with a self-perpetuating character. The third reason is; because china and India are becoming now a company’s largest market and major source of innovation, companies have to Asianizate their top management . There are also several gaps between companies ambitions and achievements in emerging markets.

To deal with this, the authors of this article discuss a new structure, called the T-shaped country organization. This structure is a response to the fact that emerging markets are increasingly becoming lead markets as well as lead talent pools. This dual approach yields a T-shaped form (hence the name ‘T-shaped structure’). The horizontal stroke represents linkages across countries. Companies should use emeriging markets as a platform for globally segmented innovation, manufacturing and offshore services. The vertical stroke illustrates the need for depth in a country, frond-end operations must become highly localized. This means each country has to have its own area of expertise, and all areas will be necessary for developing new products and services.

Research has shown companies can use two complementary approaches to coordinate processes across geographies: separation and integration. The article concludes with three recommendations for managers.

Body text
The authors address an interesting subject. They state that companies are not adjusting their structures enough to get maximum benefit out of developing markets. This we think, is a critical observation of the business world as it is today. Further, the authors do have some strong observations and recommendations. We thought for example that the observation of the author that in China and India subsidiaries frequently complain about top management’s lack of commitment to their markets is a good remark. Another nice feature of this article is the scheme ‘What Kind of Multinational Structure Fits Your Company?’. It offers a playful way for managers to analyse the status quo of their company.

We also found some critical remarks to this article. Starting with the introduction and structure of the article. The approach of the authors was and still is not completely clear to use.
The article starts with an anecdote of Frits van Paaschen, CEO of Starwood Hotels, which is a nice anecdote but does in our opinion not contribute much the rest of the article. In the introduction we also miss a clear formulation of the purpose and structure of the rest of the article. There is no clear introduction, body text or conclusion.
This makes it really hard to read the article and understand the overall idea. For example, the part of the text ‘Falling into the Gaps’ contains some strong points, however, the contribution of this part to main idea of the article is not so clear. This brings us to the main idea, the T-shaped country organization structure. Where the rest of the article is described quite comprehensive the T-shaped structure remains relatively vague. Still, after reading the explanation and the article several times it stays tough to depict the T-shaped structure in our minds. Next time, maybe the authors could add a diagram or schema as images say more than thousand words. Further, it is also not clearly expressed where the authors base their ideas on. How did they come to these ideas? For instance, did they do research, what did they exactly investigate? What was the main question, which companies were examined?

We learned from this article that, according to the authors, companies are not tapping into the full potential of developing markets using existing structures. They should follow the example of a few companies who are showing the way and rewrite the way corporations should think about structures. We learned that R&D can be segmented vertically as horizontally and fractured geographically. It has evolved from an non-transferable FSA to an international co-operating transferable FSA. The companies are becoming somewhat ‘international projectors’ (slide 9, lecture 2). They try to benefit from global organized R&D on the back-end operations while trying to be more responsive to the home country on the frond-end operations.

This article offers to managers a new view on structure and set out some ideas and guide lines. The last part of the article deals with ‘Challenges for Top Teams’, here they mention some consequences for companies. However, this is all on a very general level and the article is not a throughout plea.

The article relates to the course Introduction to International Business because it deals with mounting pressures on multination companies’ organizational structures. The basic question of this course is where do you locate what type of activity in which way, and what effect does this have on firm and environment? The article offers some thoughts about how to locate activities as R&D and in which way.

Questions for the author

1. If you take an organization (for example a producer of clothing) that wants to be successful in a developing country like China, how do you suggest make successful use of the T-shaped structure?

2. Looking at the current situation, are there any companies that successfully use the T-shaped structure? If yes, which are the best examples and why?

3. Did you conduct research for the findings of this article? If so, what was the main question, what did you investigate and what were the limitations of the research?

References - Kumar, N. and P. Puranam, 2011. “Have you restructured for global success?”, Harvard Business Review, October, 123-128. - IB / Professor Dr. S. Beugelsdijk, 2012. Lecture 2: Competitiveness: firm and country factors, PPT, October, slide 9.

[pic]

References: - Kumar, N. and P. Puranam, 2011. “Have you restructured for global success?”, Harvard Business Review, October, 123-128. - IB / Professor Dr. S. Beugelsdijk, 2012. Lecture 2: Competitiveness: firm and country factors, PPT, October, slide 9. [pic]

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    In nowadays-globalised world, where competitiveness means more than just a word, internationalisation is a prerequisite for a competitive advantage. Thus companies of all sizes must acknowledge the importance of partnerships with foreign nations and more in particular with emerging economies as a source of potential growth. Creating an unified global market, however, goes hand in hand with numerous threats. Therefore, when contemplating to enter a fast-developing market firms should thoroughly assess the economic and political factors in the host country and implement a sustainable strategy for a long-term success.…

    • 3232 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Brose Case Study

    • 470 Words
    • 2 Pages

    | Spend a long time to adjust company’s structure to better adapt the expansion in the international business…

    • 470 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The structure of an organization, particularly ones operating in several countries, i.e. MNC’s is closely related to its strategies, as argued by (Qiu and Donaldson 2010,P 82). Their hypothesis suggests that small changes in the way an organization is structured may play a big role in how successful it is in reaching its goals. They effectively sort out different structural models that the organizations can base their structure on depending on a number of determinants. The key determinants being how responsive the organizations want to be in regards to the local market changes, how diversified they want their products to be between different countries and the degree to which they want a similar global rule, i.e. global integration. (Qiu and Donaldson 2010,P-98 ) An MNC with a more standardized product line globally such as Dell, Asus etc., which will have a more rigid approach with high centralization of authority cannot have the same strategy as another MNC which might be more accepting to selling diversified products and thus may be more willing to allow greater autonomy amongst their subsidiaries in other countries.…

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Vijay Govindarajan and Anil K. Gupta. Strategy + Business. Global Perspective. 2002. Fourth Quarter 1999. Issue 17. www.strategy-business.com/article/13866?gko=e19cb…

    • 1610 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    House of Tata

    • 2820 Words
    • 12 Pages

    In 1991 the Indian government introduced a series of drastic reforms, liberalizing its government owned and controlled economy. Product expansion and new market entry became easier for companies in virtually every sector of the economy. This presented Tata with many opportunities to leverage its strong brand equity and financial resources to enter new markets and industries. The strong brand image gave it a tremendous advantage over competitors in a variety of industries. However, the government reforms also lowered barriers to entry and increased competition in all of Tata’s industries. Foreign companies flooded into India, threatening to take market share from Tata companies. The world was globalizing and India was liberalizing its economy. Tata was forced to consider its strengths and weakness, analyze its many businesses and their industries, and evaluate the threats and opportunities presented by this changing global economy.…

    • 2820 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In lieu of a slow economy recovery and highly competitive local market, mid-size companies should take advantage of opportunities in the global markets by getting involved in the international stage. There is no doubt that there is an imminent risk of expanding any business to foreign countries, especially given the fact that there are different cultural, geographic, and political differences. Business leaders who do not increase their sight to global markets are very likely to fall behind their competitive edge or peers.…

    • 334 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    They should be able to further diversify their businesses by entering into joint ventures with other firms. Moreover, the current organization structure is highly centralized, hierarchical and traditional form of organization structure. This is not suitable for the operations of a global firm and if this is altered or changed, it can provide several opportunities.…

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Frugal Innovation

    • 3689 Words
    • 15 Pages

    Whether it’s called “reverse innovation”, “frugal innovation” or “jugaad innovation,” product development in emerging markets such as India and China is attracting more and more notice, even leading some to wonder whether these countries will not be posing a formidable challenge to the best-established Multinational Companies of the advanced nations in the near future. The essay should address the question:…

    • 3689 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Better Essays

    Base on market information for Asia Pacific, we can made conclusion that business future in Asian region has to have bright future. With 33% of the world's GDP and 50% of its population, Asia has emerged as a rapidly growing force in the global economy. Due to the cultural diversity, regulatory controls, growing base of consumer power and its own set of business "rules," the multinational corporations (MNCs) find it challenging to enter the Asian market successfully. Most MNCs are reassessing their existing strategies or formulating new strategies to sustain their growth (4).…

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Komatsu Case Study Analysis

    • 3499 Words
    • 14 Pages

    * C.W.L.Hill & Arun.K.Jain, ‘International Business – competing in the global market place’ (2009).Tata McGrawHill, New Delhi.…

    • 3499 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Philips vs. Matsushita

    • 1837 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Outsiders wondered how each company’s internal changes would affect their endless competitive battle in the industry. The case illustrates how global competitiveness depends on the organizational capability, the difficulty of overcoming deeply rooted administrative heritage, and the limitations of both classic multinational and global models.…

    • 1837 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Hill, C. (2012). International Business. Competing in the global market. 9th Ed. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill/Irwin.…

    • 3725 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    This article dwells upon the post recession (of 2008) changing global business environment for the companies of developed countries. The author here predicts that the next decade will be characterised by weak global growth, high unemployment, costlier capital, stricter regulations and taxation and even increased protectionism. The author however has revealed the huge potential in the emerging markets (namely China and India) by stating the World Banks projection saying that the two countries will account for the 50% of global GDP by 2050. So, this article has tried to explain how a change in the strategic approach of the multinational companies (MNC) can help them benefit from these opportunities.…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In today 's business environment, there is sustained pressure for companies to maximize productivity in order to be competitive in the marketplace. Many businesses are moving a variety of activities, such as manufacturing and product development, to countries with low labour costs. They are also opening up sales channels in many new markets. The resulting global organizations need to structure themselves, so that they can effectively manage operations across numerous locations. This paper looks at how the organizational structure of a global company influences decision-making at the regional level, and how this can affect the business performance. This paper will:…

    • 1620 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    International Marketing

    • 1205 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Presently, globalization and international markets are growing in importance. More companies are seizing the opportunities appearing in the international marketplace, as the world grows more connected through the use of new technology and international trends. With global companies all wanting a part of the global wealth available, competition becomes fiercer and fiercer as businesses need to prepare and implement innovative strategies in order to succeed. Effectively managing international businesses across many countries is certainly proving to be one of the major challenges in the global market today. Only the best of global companies truly profit, as international markets are places where companies with success and mediocre statuses are divided. But to succeed, a structural arrangement needs to be put in place. There are a variety of different marketing strategies out there. For multinational companies, the challenge remains as to which marketing strategy they see fit to bring them to global success.…

    • 1205 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays