It has been argued that "Trainspotting" by Irvine Welsh is a critique of materialism in western society. Do you agree?

Topics: Karl Marx, Social class, Marxism, Bourgeoisie, Heroin, Working class / Pages: 7 (2330 words) / Published: Apr 15th, 2004
Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels believed that Capitalist society, which is based on the right of each individual to own private property, is the cause of the main class divides evident in today's society. That the basic right to own property results in the ruling class, the bourgeoisie, becoming obsessed with the accumulation of possessions and, as a consequence, becoming slaves to commodities; Commodity fetishism. This resulted, they argued, in the widening of class divisions. Capitalist society is described by some as protecting freedom and individuality. However, it also, undeniably, encourages self-interest, greed and - as Marx argued - an obsession with private property. It is a society whose basis lies in the fundamental need to accumulate property. The people within this society who do not have the means to amass material possessions are pitied, considered the underclass. They are seen to be lacking in something, incomplete, and are encouraged to 'make something' of themselves. To acquire qualifications, a job that pays well, to set themselves up so that they too can begin to accumulate material goods. This, society argues, is what everyone should strive for.

It has been said that Irvine Welsh's Trainspotting is a critique of both excess, and the culture of, materialism. The characters in Trainspotting are drug users and have alienated themselves from society. However, is this a rejection of materialistic society or is it a result of their exclusion from society, and their inability to 'succeed' due to their social class?

Trainspotting is a poignant story told with a certain rawness and harsh resignation that exposes the reality of the ruthless world in which the characters of the novel are born into. They are working class and, it can be argued, the very name of their school, birthplace, accent and mannerisms are all indicators of the fact that they will remain working class for the rest of their lives:

"The kid's name wis doon fir H.M.Prison Saughton

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Trainspotting: a Novel by Irvine Welsh
  • Do you agree
  • Trainspotting
  • trainspotting
  • Trainspotting Analysis
  • Do you agree with the statement that America has no culture?
  • Smartphone Is a Blessing to the Society. Do You Agree?
  • Do You Agree With The Modernisation The
  • Materialism in Society
  • It Has Been Argued That the Uk Banking System Is an Oligopoly