Top-Rated Free Essay

Goodbye Columbus Day

Good Essays
Let’s Abolish Columbus Day
Everyday children are taught that Christopher Columbus is a hero and that he discovered America, but they aren’t taught about what he did to Native Americans while discovering America and the real truth about whom he was and what he did. Although Columbus encouraged European exploration of the “New World”, he is not the hero that everyone believes him to be. He had very little knowledge of where he was and Native Americans were badly mistreated under his command.
It is evident that Columbus encouraged European exploration, but it is also evident that he did not in fact know where he was and that he had landed on an unknown part of the world. When Columbus conquered land for the Spanish and brought back goods, it inspired other nations to send out explorers such as, Cabot, an English explorer who sailed to the coast of Canada, Pizarro, a Spanish explorer who conquered land among the Pacific coast of South America, and Vespucci, an explorer for both Spain and Portugal who was the first to realize that this land across the ocean was a New World not Asia. Columbus is responsible for the way the Americas are today and if he had not sailed across the Atlantic Ocean, the world might be completely different.
When Columbus first sailed across the Atlantic Ocean in 1492, he thought that he had landed on Asia and three voyages later, he still thought that the island of Cuba was a part of Asia, South America was only an island, and that the coast of Central America was near the Ganges River. As indicated in Document 5, the painting shows Columbus landing on America as a celebration even though he thought he was in Asia. Also, the Columbus Doors shows that the whole world acknowledges Columbus’ accomplishment but he wasn’t the one that declared that this land that he sailed to was in fact a “New World”. In 12 years of exploring the Americas, he never once realized that it was not Asia. Columbus thought he had made it to Asia, and called this area the Indies, and called its inhabitants Indians contributing to the long history of calling Native Americans, Indians.
Celebrations on Columbus Day are based on myths. According to Document 2, Columbus Day is insulting to Americans Natives whose ancestors have been on the Americas for thousands of years prior to the landing of Columbus. This document also states that a national holiday should be one that is nationally accepted by all Americans thus giving more reason to abolish the holiday. Children are taught that Columbus was a hero and that he discovered America making him seem courageous and magnificent (Document 6). The need for a hero and symbol to give the United States a unique place in history and to break their ties with European nations, they looked to Columbus and instantly magnified him as a hero for the United States completely disregarding his extreme cruelty (Document 4). Columbus Day is a celebration of the start of one of the greatest waves of genocide in history which is not something that needs to be celebrated.
When Columbus sailed to the islands of the Caribbean, his men enslaved many of the American Natives. The Spanish monarch funded Columbus’ voyage if Columbus would repay the monarch in gold and spices from Asia. Columbus was unable to acquire gold and spices, so he seized over one thousand natives and crammed them onto his ships and sent them to Spain to be sold into slavery splitting up many families. Seized natives that were not shipped to Spain were forced to work on plantations and in mines. In only four years, through beating, raping, torturing, killing and hunting natives for sport, Columbus and his men managed to make the Taino peoples’ population decrease by one-third and in eventually in 50 years go extinct. Immoral methods were used to kill natives such as: greyhounds being used as weapons to hunt natives killing one hundred people in one hour (Document 8). Columbus Day should not be celebrated because that indicates that forcing people to do labor and selling them as if they are crops or someone’s property is not wrong. It indicates that tearing children from their parents and wives from their husbands is okay when it’s not. It indicates that the United States as a nation supports slavery and agrees with what Columbus did which is not true because slavery in the United Stated was outlawed in 1865. Therefore, Columbus Day should not be celebrated as a national holiday.
Why is Columbus the only European explorer that we celebrate? Why not have an Amerigo Vespucci Day, when he’s who the Americas were named after and the one who realized that this land that Columbus sailed to was not Asia. Or why not have a John Cabot Day; he actually sailed to the North American mainland near Canada for England, the nation that founded the 13 colonies that soon became the United States of America. Both of these explorers are just as important as and maybe even more important to the United States than Christopher Columbus.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Goodbye Columbus

    • 1940 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Sometimes there are two novels that have the same theme, and sometimes they have the same plot, but in the case of the two novels, The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald, and the novel Goodbye Columbus, by Philip Roth they explore the same dynamics of the chase of the American dream. In both novels there are similar themes, they both use the idea of sex and money as a form of power. Both novels can relate to each other because the authors decided to show how the pursuit of the American dream may…

    • 1940 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Goodbye, Columbus

    • 1660 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Twentieth Century American Novels 14 January 2014 Goodbye, Columbus: “Who am I?” "Who am I?" This is a question everyone asks themselves at a point in their life, and is the exact question that Neil Klugman faces. In Phillip Roth 's novella Goodbye, Columbus, there is an ongoing search by Neil Klugman who, according to Helge Nilsen, "is involved in a struggle to develop and preserve an identity of his own amid different environments and conflicting impulses within himself," (Nilsen, 97). This…

    • 1660 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Goodbye Columbus

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As humans, people often times create their own ideas and perceptions over certain individuals or a place. In Goodbye, Columbus, by Philip Roth, the story’s main character, Neil falls into that trap when he meets a girl, Brenda, and his entire life is turned upsides down. “and though we did not want to go, the little boy and I, the boat was moving and there was nothing we could do about it” (Roth 74). When Philip Roth decided to add Neil’s dream of him and the little boy visiting an island and then…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In this article Goodbye Columbus people tearing down statues of important historical characters is ridiculous. The left side’s claim that some statues represent that oppression, racism, genocide etc. is true to a certain extent, but it’s necessary that they need to understand that those actions made us who we are today as a whole and took place in the past. The leftist side strives for change which can only be achieved in the present but wanting to destroy a piece of history is not only dwelling…

    • 170 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Goodbye, Columbus? I agree with this article for numerous reasons. Mainly because if we start taking down statues of our history because someone is shook up we will have to take down and put up new statues as soon as some people are angry about what went on in that time also. Continuing on that topic, not just Washington but almost if not all Presidents owned slaves before it was outlawed. By the left's view point here they were all bad people and should not be remembered because they stood for…

    • 640 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    interpretation which is different amongst all people. The thing that would be most apparent in the novella, “Goodbye Columbus”, is that there is an obvious focus around power struggles. These power struggles could be anything physical, mental, or emotional between separate parties that could result in one being supreme over the other. All parties wish to be supreme of the others. The novella, “Goodbye Columbus”, is written on the premise of constant power struggles that resonate throughout the novella expressed…

    • 1332 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This picture demonstrates the theme of the reality of housewives in Goodbye, Columbus. In the story we are presented with two different housewives. One, Neil's aunt, and two, Brendas mother. Neil's aunt is the typical housewife who does all the cleaning and cooking. She even goes as far as making a different meal for every single person in her family. Brenda's mother, unlike Neil's aunt is not a typical house wife. She has the luxary of having a maid who does everything for her. Even though she does…

    • 204 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Columbus Day

    • 593 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Columbus Day When asked should Columbus Day be celebrated? The answer we get is yes because we have a holiday on Monday of the second week of October. Columbus Day is the celebration of the day Christopher Columbus apparently discovered America. If I was asked that question I would say most definitely we shouldn’t celebrate Columbus Day. First, he brought disease that spread around the Americas killing 9off the Native Americans. Second, most people think that by celebrating Columbus Day we are…

    • 593 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Even after being “legal” to live as Jews, anti-Semitism and Gentleman’s agreement have made their lives hard as Jews. The movie “Gentleman’s Agreement” and “Goodbye, Columbus” explore what it is to be a Jew in America in post-World War II. Nevertheless, not all Jewish literature is religious; in “Gentleman’s Agreement” and “Goodbye, Columbus” we see how deception is used to accomplish their goals conscious and subconsciously deceiving themselves and other along the progression of the text/film.…

    • 1686 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the essay ‘Rethinking History Class on Columbus Day’, the author is able to argue that Columbus Day is a controversial issue by providing many sources that prove that people have very different opinions of the holiday. He overwhelms the readers with a collection of facts, stories, and records of Christopher Columbus; in fact, the essay seems like a research paper by manner because it is a compilation of sources. The author does not include any opinions, instead he uses sources, twenty-one to…

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays