top-rated free essay

Good and Evil on the Rails

By toyotamotor1 Aug 19, 2015 825 Words


Good and Evil on the Rails

3. Is the cost of positive train control justified by the likely safety gains for passengers? The cost of positive train control is not justified by the likely safety gains for passengers. The costs of positive train controls over 20 years were estimated at between $10 billion and $14 billion. The safety benefits for society were only $608 million to $931 million. Under either assumption the cost of controls was more than 15 times the benefit. There is also the fact that most of railroad related fatalities are trespassers who ride trains or enter track corridors and many more are motorists hit at crossings. In fact there were only 85 passenger fatalities in the last decade. This expensive addition to the railroads will raise shipping rates, consumer prices and passenger fares. I believe it would be more effective to implement stricter guidelines on hiring engineers and placing restrictions on the activities allowed in the cabins. Monitoring what engineers are doing in the cabin and hiring more competent engineers will decrease the chances of a human error occurring. This will be a more cost effective option as opposed to forcing railroads to equip trains with positive train control that will cost them an upwards of $55,000 per locomotive.

4. Did the Federal Railroad Administration fairly value a statistical life at 6 million? I believe that the Federal Railroad Administration valued a statistical life at 6 million fairly. Public choices about safety require estimates of the willingness of people to trade off wealth for a reduction in the probability of death. Estimates of these trade-offs are used in evaluating public safety and in many other areas. Considering the average quality of life, the expected lifetime remaining, as well as the earning potential of a given person, 6 million is a reasonable number. In fact recently the EPA valued a human life at 7.4 million. They came up with this number when conducting a benefit-cost analysis of new environmental policies, the Agency used estimates of how much people are willing to pay for small reductions in their risks of dying from adverse health conditions that may be caused by environmental pollution.

5. Is money spent to regulate railroad safety being spent in the most efficient way to reduce risks of death and injury in society? Money is not spent in the most efficient way to regulate railroad safety and reduce risks of death and injury. It seems as though most of the funds are allocated to adding positive train control and not enough is spent on regulating the train crews and adding other safety measures to reduce human error. More of the funding could be dedicated to hiring supervisors to monitor engineers and perhaps hiring a larger staff of engineers so they would not have to work split shifts. I like the fact that all electronic devices have been banned from being used in the locomotive cabs. The proposal of adding a camera and a black box similar to the ones found in airplanes was a keen idea as well. The Rail Safety Improvement Act should include more cost efficient ways of making railroads safer instead of forcing a $10-14 billion safety addition that would make it hard for the railroad company’s implement. Once again, my proposal for a more efficient solution in making the railroads safer, is adding manpower in all areas of the company and stricter policies and procedures for the locomotive crew. More supervisors, managers and crewmembers will ensure everyone’s abiding by the stricter rules and regulations and there will be less human errors due to exhaustions from working too many hours.

6. Is the video recording in locomotive cabs an invasion of privacy? Should unions oppose it? I don’t think the video recording of locomotive cabs is an invasion of privacy and unions should not oppose to this obvious safety measure. The video recording will ensure that the engineer is not breaking any rules by using electronic devices, texting, or making calls while operating the locomotive. By having the cab monitored from a control center the engineer would feel further supervised and would be less likely to engage in distracting activity that could essentially lead to a human error. Actually, many forms of transportation now have a video monitoring device. For example LA Taxicabs have added cameras that monitor the driver and the passenger. This precautionary measure protects the driver from hostile passengers and ensures the driver does not do anything illegal. In reality we have already been deprived of our privacy in the age of video surveillance. Considering how we are constantly monitored in our daily lives, like at an ATM, a department store, or even at the office. Video recording inside a cab of a locomotive that carries passengers should not be a threat to the engineer operating the locomotive, it is just a safety measure put in place for the greater good.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • good

    ...“golden candlesticks” represents Parris’ own greed and by extension the corrupted power of the theocracy of Salem. There are continuous references to light and dark within Miller’s play and Hytner draws attention to this particularly when Parris stands in the pulpit announcing excommunication and then turns and smothers the candle light ...

    Read More
  • Good to Evil

    ...Good to Evil: The deterioration of an individual By: Sarah Warner Making bad decisions is a part of life. No one should ever choose to let bad choices rule their life because this can change an individual from good to evil. Various factors can influence an individual’s personality from good to evil. In the short story “Twins” by Eric ...

    Read More
  • Good and Evil

    ... Good and Evil-Casablanca Kimberly Gromack PHI2000 U03a1-Unit 3 Assignment Capella University October, 2013 There are many different viewpoints on what is right and wrong and ethically and morally correct. Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) and Jon Stuart Mill (1806-1873), both considered to be ...

    Read More
  • Good or Evil

    ...Are Humans Born Good or Are Humans Born Evil? Humans have been on Earth for about 100,000 to 200,000 years. We are part of the hominidae family. In other words, we are “modern man and extinct immediate ancestors of man.” We have brains and with them we are able to consider thoughts. With abstract brainwork, it allows us to categorize o...

    Read More
  • Good Evil

    ...Our understanding of the “good” has expanded beyond the lone-dreamer theory to embrace other activists, like King’s partner in Birmingham, the Rev. Fred Shuttlesworth. Yet the evil segregationist archetype is fixed in the popular mind as the villainous housewife of “The Help” or the cretinous mob of “Django Unchained” — nobody we...

    Read More
  • Good and Evil

    ...Evil and Good The obvious thing to say about evil is that it is the opposite of good. Some people may argue that there is a lot good in the world. Everyone does have evil in them and are very well capable of doing bad things. Although not everyone expresses their anger at the same level of intensity, everyone has most likely done more bad in th...

    Read More
  • Is Man born Good or Evil

    ...Is Man Born Good Or Evil? I do not think that man was born neither good nor evil, I believe that man are raised into there chosen behavior because of the society, environment, family, culture, or even the media, but I believe man has this natural instinct to be good or evil.I do believe that man is both good and evil. Man can do great, wonder...

    Read More
  • The Good and Evil Desire of Macbeth

    ...The Good and Evil Desire in Macbeth Desire in itself is a powerful force. In fact, almost every action we take, good or evil, is prompted by desire. Success and advancement is also something we all seem to want. It is something people spend hours, days, and years of their life either preparing for, or chasing after. It is a desire that we a...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.