Preview

Globalisation Can Have a Negative Impact on Developing Countries

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
352 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Globalisation Can Have a Negative Impact on Developing Countries
MULTINATIONALS

Indonesia’s natural resources are among the most bonteous and abused. In 2004, the sediment in Buyat Bay, the equatorial bay where an American corporation, Newmont Mining, had been depositing mine waste for several years, was polluted with high levels of arsenic and mercury. The villagers have complained of a rashes, lumps, breathing difficulties and dizzies. Report’s Newmont that no contamination of the fish or the water was happened.

In 2004, Newmont Minahasa Raya (NMR) began closing down its operations in North Sulawesi, leaving local communities in Buyat Bay and Ratatatok with a dubious legacy. NMR use a submarine tailings disposal (STD) system which a method of waste due to its harmful environmental and health impacts. From 1996 until its closure, NMR dumped more than four million tons of mine waste into the bay. Forum the Environment (WALHI) found that NMR’s tailings contained four times the government-allowed level of cyanide and high levels of mercury, cadmium, and arsenic. But the WAHLI report’s recommendation that the tailings disposal system be evaluated and redesigned was ignore by both NMR and Indonesian government.

The Manado district court declared NMR and its president-director, innocent of the charge they polluted and damaged the environment in Buyat Bay. The verdict was greeted with jubilation by audience. Outside the courthouse, hundreds of demonstrators shouted protests against the court’s decision.

According to Friends of Earth International, the judgment ignored compelling evidence presented by the government-convened Joint Investigative Team, finding the mine waste had caused extensive environmental damage. Newmont had used the destructive practice of ocean disposal of mine waste in Buyat Bay. In Newmont’s home country, the United States, this destructive practice is effectively banned under the Clean Water Act. They claim that the mine waste Newmont contaminated the seabed with arsenic at conterntrations 10 to 20

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    A developer called Riverside Bayview Homes (respondent) owned 80 acres of land in Michigan, and intended to dredge and fill wetlands that existed on its property, in order to build homes. Under the provisions of the Clean Water Act, the Army Corps of Engineers (petitioner on behalf of the U.S.) felt that RBH should not be permitted to do so and filed suit in Federal District Court, seeking an immediate injunction in order to prevent the continuation of this project. The COE felt that the land owned by RBH was subject to jurisdiction under the Clean Water Act because of its adjacency to navigable water, and therefore (under section 404(a) of the CWA) required a permit in order to be dredged and filled. Under the Clean Water Act, a freshwater…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The fly fishing outfitter did not have any legal recourses that were discussed in lecture. The fertilizer plant did not violate the Clean Water Act section 402 because the plant obtained a permit prior to discharging the pollutant. Also, the EPA and the state approved all discharge action reported. Additionally, common law claims are inadequate because pollution caused by industrial activity is considered a negative externality. The producer and consumer of the product are not directly responsible by the impact. The cost of the externality does not take into the consideration of the cost of the goods. Likewise, it is difficult to quantify impact and distribute the responsibility equally. Legally, the polluter has no criminal liability due…

    • 146 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    W. R. Reilly Case

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Ladies and Gentleman of the jury, W.R. Grace and Beatrice foods have polluted the aquifer located under East Woburn. There is no question of this, as testimony from workers such as Al Love show that they have spilled, poured and dumped TCE, or Trichloroethylene. Mr. Reilly testified that he should have known what was happening on the 15 acres of property he leased out to the Whitney barrel company. By dumping TCE and other chemicals onto the ground, these companies introduced these harmful substances into the environment, particularly the aquifer underneath. These chemicals are not industrial revolution chemicals; they are modern, harmful chemicals that have adverse health affects.…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ballona Water Arguement

    • 221 Words
    • 1 Page

    People who live close to Ballona creek are accusing Industries for the contamination of the water. The thing that they would never think of was that it was the asphalt pit. When there is heavy rain, the asphalt pit would over flow and then it runs down into the sewer system, leaking into the creek and draining into the ocean. The Page Museum and Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County have paid local water controllers $15,000 dollars for discharging contaminated water into the storm drains in 2006. And in 2002, the Page Museum paid $3,000 to a coastal cleaning project to resolve a storm water release violation. This source is credible because it was written by Jasson Song and Tony Barboza. Their arguments are solid and clear. They cover…

    • 221 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Civil Action Analysis

    • 849 Words
    • 4 Pages

    More than a tragic story of sorrow, death and family turmoil, Harr's narrative tells the story of how a lawyer and grief stricken families pieced together the pieces of a very complex puzzle to determine the cause and effect that such water contamination had on their personal injury matters. By depicting the work that epidemiologists, geologists, medical experts, civil engineers and public health specialists did over the course of the case, Harr instrumentally lays out the multifaceted sides of Anderson v Cryovac.…

    • 849 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sydney Tar Ponds

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The Sydney Tar Ponds are the most toxic hazardous waste site in North America, located in Cape Breton. These tar ponds were caused essentially from a century of steel making, polluting it with high levels of PCB, mercury, lead and polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons. This was first discovered in 1980 by the Department of Fisheries and Oceans in Sydney Harbor, which resulted in a period of events and frustrations for both the government and residents. In1982 lobster fisheries were all closed down due to contamination, this made residents mad because this was many peoples main source of work and it was a very popular food in the area. In 1998 residents began to complain of toxic ooze seeping into their cellars; this eventually led to the promise of Premier John Hamm that he would stop government subsidies to the Sysco Plant. The Sysco plant was then closed. Residents are still mad; the public health officers test 237 people for lead and arsenic exposure, 45 were reported and two children were found to have high levels of lead and arsenic in their urine. Also Health Canada proves that there is 17 more deaths a year due to the Tar Ponds. The government has taken many steps to try and get rid of these tar ponds along with the help of JAG (Joint Action Group). In August, 2001, DTPW set up the Sydney Tar Ponds Agency (STPA) to coordinate and help lead the project. They have debated burying the ponds, washing them out and burning them. In 2004 a 10-year, $400 million dollar deal to clean up the Tar Ponds. In 2007 the final plan is announced by the government, to bury the Tar Ponds. This is estimated to take up to 8 years; the Tar Ponds are still being…

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Mcwane Incident

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages

    They had been violating the clean air act and clean water act. Companies are required to ensure proper disposal of waste. McWane was illegally discharging pollution into Village Creek and the Delaware River. They were taking the easy way to get rid of waste because their holding tanks kept becoming too full for the amount they were producing. Instead of waiting for the cleaning process and stopping production they continued to pollute the environment. McWane industries violated the clean air act by releasing heavy levels of pollution into the air. They were aware of the illegal activities they were participating in but continued to do so. McWane only cared and decided to change once they got caught. It is outrageous to me that they got away with these violations for as long as they did. In my opinion their needs to be stricter enforcement against companies like McWane…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Durning mentions people selfishly abuse goods, which in turn hurts the environment. “The consumer society’s exploitation of resources threatens to exhaust, poison, or unalterably disfigure forests, soils, water, and air” (200). People are responsible for the harm that is caused to the environment. Pollution is one of the effects of consumption. Earthjustice says cement kilns are infecting our air, water, and food with mercury. Cement kilns release mercury into the environment through the cement-making process. Mercury is released in the air then goes to the water, which then infects the fish, which makes it unsafe for people to eat. In order to control mercury pollution, E.J. wants the Environmental Protection Agency to set mercury standards for cement kilns. E.J. Wrote a report called, “Cementing a Toxic Legacy?” about how the EPA has failed to control mercury pollution from cement kilns. E.J. prepared this report “to release the results of the EPA’s data summary to the public, to highlight the health and environmental threats posed by specific kilns that appear to have especially high mercury emission levels, to expose what appears to be gross under- reporting of mercury emissions from cement kilns, and to call upon EPA to act swiftly to set appropriate standards for this toxic pollutant” (“Cementing a…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The residents were being harmed and were unaware while there was knowledge of this toxic pollutant by others (PG & E) and yet nothing was being done. Yes, the company continued to benefit from their processes while people in this residence were getting sick with respiratory problems that could possibly be linked to this pollutant (chromium 6). Not only were the residents being harmed, but there was harm to the environment. The evidence was revealed through much investigative work by the legal team and news sources. Just a few to mention: 1)In 1987 the company advised the State of California of the detection of Chromium 6 levels in ground water when a routine environment survey was done, but yet the company failed to identify the dangerous type of chromium when communicating to the residents about the findings. Also, on a different side of this revelation, according to the plaintiffs trail brief, the contamination was known as early as…

    • 1864 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Accompining the genocide of California's natives was an unprecedented destruction of california's enviroment. Forests were clear cut. The area around Lake Tahoe, now know for its beautiful forest growth was completely leveled, only recently recovering [SOURCE]. The gold miners dug up 12 billion tons of earth, excuvating river beds with giant dredges and river banks with high pressure water cannons[SOURCE]. Blasting away California's hillsides for pure greed, entire rivers became clogged with the crumbled hillsides and flooded the Sacramento valley. Whole hillsides and mountains were turned into tailings and debris that were dumped into the rivers and lakes of California. These tailings were called slickens, leading to the phrase of the day which said “slickens is too thick to drink and too thin plow” [SOURCE]. Mining operations employing these hydrolic methods destroyed the precious and untouched natural resources of California, flooded towns and inundated farmland with the tailings. While this particular method of mining was outlawed, the damage can still be felt and seen to this day. In addition miners used mercury and quicksilver to extract gold from the ore, dumping over 7,600 tons of the toxic metals into California's fresh waterways. Mercury is a deadly toxin which dramatically affects the kidney, brain and the nervous system and will lead to death. Just a teaspoon of mercury dumped into a…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Environmental law is the important part of government regulation and it deals with pollution or contamination problems. In our case contamination is found within the walls of the factory that was owned by W.R. Grace & Co. Company was using hazardous substances and it has legal duty of care for waste: they had to be disposed or recovered (Business Gateway, 2009). But company failed to do that and all waste was poured out into the water. Unfortunately those burdensome substances negatively affected health of large number of people including workers of the factory, their families and neighbors who lived in the Woburn, Massachusetts. “Ingestion” occurred as people were drinking this polluted water and they were using it for cooking. That region was characterized by large number of illnesses and sick people. Unfortunately contaminated water became the reason of death of children, who died from leukemia. According to general obligation law to environmental contamination caused by businesses, company must pay compensation if its manufacturing processes resulted in contamination and this pollution in its turn caused the personal injury or property damage. (Nelson, 2006) But in our case exposure of hazardous substances in the water resulted in deaths of children and there was no amount of money that can revive and return them to their parents. But someone had to take responsibility of it. The parents sued company as it was legally liable for pollution and plaintiffs tried to prove that defendants knew their operations would cause pollution.…

    • 1529 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In this article “Localizing Globalization” by Chris Mooney, he states that study by the University of California of Davis warned that chemical MTBE may cause cancer in humans but the person who produces the MBTE his name is Methanex, he sued that federal government of United State for 97 million. According to him, California’s is removing his property so that is why he sued them. In addition to that because of NAFTA he has the right to sue them but many people in federal government in California was worried because if he wins the case then many other people will also sue them and that is what happen after he wins his case another US company sued.…

    • 227 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Methylmercury In America

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Recently, in the news, many Americans around the nation are not consuming as much fish and shellfish cause numerous coal-burning plants and iron mines are depositing methylmercury, a highly toxic form of mercury which builds up in fish, shellfish, and animals that eat fish. Accordingly, mercury is a naturally occurring element found in air, water, and soil. However, factories, mines, and large coal-burning plants deposit large amounts of methylmercury in the atmosphere and water, which is absorbed into small fish and shellfish and affects the food chain dramatically as mercury levels rise quickly higher in the food chain. This affects the human population caused when human eat seafood, especially king mackerel, marlin, orange roughy, shark, swordfish, tilefish, ahi, bigeye tuna or shellfish they can consume higher levels of mercury which has higher effects on young children and pregnant women. Unfortunately, these fish are some of the more popular fish to eat cooked or as sushi.…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Law 531 Week 2

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Recently, Alumina has been accused of repeatedly contaminating the waters of Lake Dira by a local woman named Kelly Bates. Ms. Bates is claiming that her 10 year old daughters’ consumption of the contaminated water is a proximate cause of her daughter leukemia. She also alleged, to the newspaper, that her daughter ailment may be as old as Alumina’s first instance of environmental violation. To preserve their image as an organization, Alumina quickly conducted independent test to ensure they…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the movie Erin Brockovich, played by Julia Roberts, is assigned to do some research on pro-bono case her employer Ed Masry is handling for the small town of Hinkley (located in San Bernardino Valley. Residents of this small town located outside the Pacific Gas & Electric plant are suspecting that a chemical, especially hexavalent chromium (Chromium 6), is causing the people in this town to be ill. Many people had chronic, unexplained illnesses, and early death; many of them were children. In addition, almost everyone in Hinkley was either currently or previously employed in the nearby PG&E plant. I need to mention that PG&E paid all medical expenses of anyone who became ill in the Hinckley vicinity. Ms. Brockovich consulted with an expert on chemicals at UCLA, and thereafter examined many old records at the Regional Water Board. During this research she discovered that a cleanup and abatement order to PG&E was issued, it required the company to remove hexavalent chromium because it was contaminating the groundwater in that area. So she took it upon herself to obtain some water samples and after the Professor at UCLA examined the papers as well as the water samples he concluded that the levels of chromium in the water supply were indeed responsible for the illnesses, and cancers the town folks were experiencing. Eventually it was determined that…

    • 1306 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays