Preview

Gilyard vs Rodriguez: How to Achieve High Academic Literacy

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1567 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Gilyard vs Rodriguez: How to Achieve High Academic Literacy
Gilyard vs Rodriguez: How to Achieve High Academic Literacy Higher levels of literacy can be achieved in many ways. Two factors which play a role in acquiring these levels are the attachments of students to their previous cultures and their previous languages, more specifically the dialect, that they speak. These factors tend to change one’s personal identity and play a huge role in how one reaches higher literacy levels. In our two readings, Hunger of Memory: The Education of Richard Rodriguez and Voices of the Self: A Study of Language Competence, we see Richard Rodriguez and Keith Gilyard respectively go through these changes at home and in their school settings. Gilyard has a point of view which geared more towards incorporating one’s culture into his academic life is the proper way to go out to attain higher literacy levels. On the other hand, Rodriguez has a view saying that one must to completely rid oneself of his culture background in order to succeed and receive higher literacy rates. One can prove from their writings that in order to achieve higher literacy rates and succeed in doing so Rodiriguez’s view of ridding oneself of his culture is the best way in order to attain these levels. Rodriguez and Gilyard, both being from minority families and settings, both needed to change their identities in their school settings to increase their academic levels. As Seo brings down in his work Crossing the boarders by Walking around, “The United States of the 21st century is possibly the most culturally and racially diverse country of any nation in history” (Seo 54). This is due to the increasing amount of immigrants coming into the United States over the past century and motivation to do well with the American dream. These changes were triggered and influenced in many different ways. Rodriguez saw how his older siblings were doing at school and looked up to them realizing that he needed to change in order to become more like them. We see this when

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    udwig Wittgenstein once said in his book Logico Tractatus Philosophicus ,“The limits of my language means the limits of my world.” This quotation means language has no limit, it’s something that can be translated into a wide variety. Both Amy Tan in the essay, “Mother Tongue” and Richard Rodriguez in the essay, “Aria: Memoir of a Bilingual Childhood” write about their struggle with their identities not only because of their race, but also the language there families speak. Amy Tan and Richard Rodriguez both struggled with there families language conflicting with the need to speak the language of society. While children they share similarities with their struggles, and they differ in their perception of the importance of maintaining their families…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Richard Rodriguez is an American journalist and essayist who often writes about his life and the obstacles he has faced during so. He has become widely known due to his popular book, The Hunger of Memory. In the excerpt that’s presented, Rodriguez talks about how his life has changed tremendously due to education, and he goes on to describe how he feels “assimilated.” Rodriguez comes from Mexican Origins and is the son of Mexican Immigrants and throughout the excerpt he has an internal fight due to the fact that he feels as if he is now a stranger to his once familiar culture. However, the one thing that has taken Rodriguez as far as he has come is his education.…

    • 172 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    ichard Rodriguez, in his essay "Aria: A Memoir of a Bilingual Childhood," wants reader to understand that bilingual education is not needed due to the fact that one can still keep their cultural identity. As he also brings about the point that intimacy is not about language you speak, but much rather about the people you are surrounded by. He points out the obstacles he faced as growing up a Hispanic American growing up in an American society. Many of those struggles he faced were in his early childhood as he battled to understand and learn english. As Rodriguez struggled to grasp the english language, he also found that he was losing the comfort he found in Spanish.…

    • 212 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Richard Rodriguez was born on July 31, 1944, in San Francisco, California, to Mexican immigrants Leopoldo and Victoria Moran Rodriguez, the third of their four children. When Rodriguez was still a young child, the family moved to Sacramento, California, to a small house in a comfortable white neighborhood. "Optimism and ambition led them to a house (our home) many blocks from the Mexican side of town.… It never occurred to my parents that they couldn't live wherever they chose," writes Rodriguez in Hunger of Memory: The Education of Richard Rodriguez, his well-received 1981 autobiography. This first book placed him in the national spotlight but brought scorn from many supporters of affirmative action and bilingual education.…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This seminar was about the Rehabilitating the "Wild Tongue" Philosophy at The University of Texas Rio Grande Valley. The speaker, Francisco Guajardo, divided his presentation into four major parts. Francisco starts off by giving a background information of his life. In the first few minutes of the presentation, I learned Francisco belonged to an immigrant family. His family migrated to the United States, in search for a better life. Francisco grew up in the city of Elsa, Texas beside his two brothers. Francisco first language was Spanish, but he later was introduced to the English language. While Francisco attended his first year of elementary school, his classroom became a test trial for bilingual instruction. Francisco states that rushing a Spanish speaking child into an English classroom will affect their language development.…

    • 270 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Memoir of a Bilingual Childhood” written by Richard Rodriguez and “And then I went to school” written by Joseph Suina, they illustrated us how people change. People change when they enter into a new culture because they start to think and act different. These changes can affect their identity, their way of think, and what they believe. The author’s lives before new cultures could be identify as…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He isolates himself by painting brown as an exclusive group: “You can’t know what I’m feeling unless you are me” (26). This distances Rodriguez from the reader and makes it difficult for the reader to empathize. Also, Rodriguez appears attention seeking, perhaps due to the lack of recognition of brown people, such as himself. He searches for pity by explaining the exclusivity of a white and black society: “brown was like the skinny or fat kids left over after the team captains chose sides,” (5). Rodriguez feels isolated from society, although he has created an inclusive group for brown people. Constantly seeking empathy, Rodriguez appears immature, and his appeals to pathos are…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    His essay, “Aria,” depicts the struggles a bilingual person will undergo as they attempt to both assimilate into the American culture, and attempt to simultaneously preserve their culture. The concepts that are emphasized within his essay include: the struggles of minorities in adjusting to the American culture and lifestyle, the revamp of certain educational aspects that are meant to benefit students, but in the long run, damage the students, and the struggle of preserving cultures, all of which are applicable in modern…

    • 1166 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    E.D. Hirsch Jr‘s “Preface to Cultural Literacy” stresses the importance of facing the dilemma of cultural illiteracy of mostly underprivileged children and everyone in our society (33). He urges the educational and literate community to comprehend the natural laws that deem it necessary for society’s underprivileged youth to “remain in the same social and educational condition as their parents” (33). Hirsch asserts, “Cultural literacy constitutes the only sure avenue of opportunity for disadvantaged children” (33). He calls on the educational and literate community to propose a change to the fifty year old “fragmented curriculum based on faulty educational theories” (33). Because Hirsch highlights the strengths and weaknesses in the pedagogic…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    English experts have tried to solve our ever declining literacy rates with different theories and years of research. Two of the front runners, Paulo Freire and E. D. Hirsch, have come up with two ideas that have caused agreement and contention between those who are trying to increase literacy rates. Freire gives us the idea that we need to expand on critical literacy and relate our words to our world and our world to our words. He wants students to have more freedom in their learning environment. On the other hand, Hirsch wants a more centralized curriculum to expand our country’s Cultural Literacy. While these two ideas might seem to be complete polar opposites of each other they actually have some similarities. Great ideas can be taken from both of these authors and applied to the reform of our education system desperately needs. There are parts that I agree and disagree with from both Hirsch and Freire, but I believe Freire makes more applicable points. While Hirsch makes the good point that cultural knowledge is required for literacy, I believe that Freire’s critical literacy and “word-world” association would provide a better foundation for pedagogical reform because it is more open for students with different learning abilities and incorporates both culture and personal experience into literacy.…

    • 1895 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Both articles reflect how the language an individual speak is linked with their identity. Anzaldúa and Tan’s article both displayed a strong aid for their claim that many languages one’s speaks has a major impact on the way they interact with the society. They both demonstrate the essence of language, using their own experiences. They both talked about how they grew up surrounded with limited…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gloria Anzaldua (“How To Tame a Wild Tongue”) and Richard Rodriguez (“Aria”) have written powerful, painful, and very personal stories about their attempts to fit into American society while being taught a language that is not of their ancestors. There are significant differences in the tone of the each reading and the feelings evoked. The methods used by each writer to describe specific points (Anzaldua, with force and anger; Rodriguez, with a resigned acceptance that only thinly veils his sadness throughout the transition), and their ability to describe situations in a way that leaves little room for doubt as to their feelings during each experience, make it both easy and difficult for the reader to identify with them. Although both authors…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Academic Literacy - paper

    • 3948 Words
    • 16 Pages

    The format of this source was in the style of a newspaper article which had clear bold headlines, but not a large enough size to attract your attention although the headlines did highlight the purpose of the article. The font was used continuously throughout the article and kept at a similar size. The audience was mainly aimed towards the public, with an informal tone used as no jargon was used and also no terminology used in order to make it harder to understand, therefore simpler language was used, which best fit the tone used with the audience it was aimed at. With the argument of the author being about the cuts being made in the sexual health services such as Family Planning (FPA) and Brook, the argument clearly stresses the concern at the higher statistics of young people with catching Sexual Transmitted Infections and pregnancy. The Article only contained one image which promoted contraception, showing what kind of services are offered in both Brook and FPA. The language used was in a sense of concern and anxiety with words like “vulnerable” (Williams, 2012) being used, which suggests that concern is being raised. With the lack of statistics and facts used I was not as convinced as I could have been , having said that the articles use of language made it easier to understand so the language used best fit the audience intended. The argument was convincing as it did make me realize the importance of the sexual health services, but as said before, if facts and statistics were included the argument would have been enhanced into an excellent argument.…

    • 3948 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this essay Barrientos argues that the language she speaks defines her identity and who she is as a person. As Barrientos was growing up, she realized being Latin-American was not what she wanted to be, she decided to didn’t want to speak Spanish, as Barrientos says, “To me, speaking Spanish translated into being poor.” She also said “It meant waiting tables and cleaning hotel rooms. It meant being poor.” She thought if she stayed away from Spanish stereotypes they would…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    It is strongly believed that the role of language in our life is taken for granted. Can you speak English? This question was the first question that asked me to answer that when I wanted to apply to the University of Birmingham. I could not answer this question properly because my English language was very weak and I believed that this is because of my school that could not learn to me foreign language. So I personally agree and I am firm to this statement " children should begin learn foreign language as soon as they start school". Here in this essay an attempt is made to state that communication and continuing education need to foreign languages.…

    • 395 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays