Preview

George Saunders’ “The New Mecca”: The Gap between Reality and Conceptuality

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1269 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
George Saunders’ “The New Mecca”: The Gap between Reality and Conceptuality
Tasfia Kamal 11/21/13
Professor Walker Communication Skills George Saunders’ “The New Mecca”: The Gap between Reality and Conceptuality “The New Mecca” is an essay in which author George Saunders engraves different experiences he had throughout his Dubai trip. In the beginning he tells the readers that everything they are going to assume about Dubai is going to be wrong unless they see Dubai by themselves first. He admits falling in love with everything he perceived in Dubai even the hotels. As he continued talking about Dubai, he introduced the reader with the history of Dubai. He informs that few years ago there was only sand. Dubai has improved a lot in a very short amount of time. He gets amazed at the beauty of Dubai; however, he gets surprised twice the amount of that because of the difference between the reality of Dubai and what people think about Dubai. The author mentions numerous examples where he meets lower class working people and sees them suffering. However, he realizes that those lower class working people don’t apprehend that. They think they are lucky enough to stay in Dubai. The author finds this gap between what these people think is happening and what’s happening in reality which makes him feel helpless and miserable. He expresses the urge of helping them in his essay; still ends up not doing it because according to him it’s not his job to fix it. The author starts his essay with what people think Dubai is. As he moves forward he talks about what the reality is behind all these misapprehensions. By the end of the essay he concedes that everyone has been victimized by this fallacy. The main focus of this essay is the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Sybolism in Araby

    • 2407 Words
    • 10 Pages

    James Joyce 's short story "Araby" is filled with symbolic images of religion, materialism and paralysis. The story opens and closes with a strong sense of symbolism that is continually alluded to throughout the story. As seen in the body, the images are shaped by the narrator 's experience of the Church and the stagnation of Dublin. The protagonist is fiercely determined to invest in someone within this Church the holiness he feels should be the natural state of all within it, but a succession of disillusioning experiences awakens him to see that his determination is in vain. At the climax of the story, when he realizes that his dreams of holiness and love are inconsistent with the actual world, his anger and anguish are directed, not toward the Church, but toward himself as "a creature driven by vanity" (p33). By analyzing "Araby 's" potent use of symbolism and the inherent meanings divulged through this method of discourse, we are able to see how the symbols are actualized to provide the reader with insight and depth into a story, whilst also encapsulating the narrator 's experience. It is this experience that drives the narrative 's momentum forward to the epiphany.…

    • 2407 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Medina and his family left the house one day, driving into the city. “Once over the East River, my first impression was of riding down into a canyon, much of its shadowy and forbidding where the sky, steel gray at the time, was a straight path like the street we were on” (Medina 72). His experience is becoming more gray and growing to the point where it is not what he expected to happen when he come over and how different people made this country sound. When they pulled to the school he thought it looked like a jail. When he was walking through the halls he saw a teacher grab the girl and hit her. “I, however, stared, frozen by violence in a place previous experience had deluded me into thinking ought to be quiet and genteel and orderly(Medina 73). With the action of the teacher hitting the girl it changed his whole perspective of what this new country is…

    • 528 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Thomas L. Friedman’s Beirut to Jerusalem graciously dons its readers with a comprehensive overview of the conflicts of the middle east with a focalization of Israel and Lebanon. From a first hand experience, Friedman deftly navigates the politics, religion, and local stories during a ten year time span (1979-1988). This time span covers much of the Arab-Israeli conflict and the civil war of Lebanon. Friedman spends his first five years living in Beirut, and the next five years living in Jerusalem. He takes from these times a multitude of personal and local short stories to give a comprehensive overview of the life of a common man. From these stories he weaves a unique equilibrium of violence, nefariousness, and heart. Friedman manages to maintain the novels’ material equally pertaining to Beirut and Jerusalem in an attempt to show two sides of the story. Friedman’s favoritism for human life and disdain of senseless brutality, government, and corruption is what gives this novel its vibe. Thomas L. Friedman’s Beirut to Jerusalem uses a opinionated historical biography to…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the article, i read about the Arkansas Mosque. Hisham, a Palestinian who grew up just outside of Damascus in Syria came to the US to join and reach his parents and older brother. He grew up in Arkansas in a rotting and corrupt house. HIs family had a hard time, his father was collecting cans while he was washing dishes. BUt then he and his brother opened a used car business and called it the A and h auto sales. They now live in a pleasant and enjoyable house that they can afford. Abraham was a poor student in high school that lived in the wealthy side of town. He often felt like an outsider and a stranger to the kids in his town. Abraham would always get into fights and always did poorly in school. One night he and his friend Craig got…

    • 165 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Alan realizes that these people do not know him so he is basically a blank canvas, he can be a new person here and it will not affect his life back home. But when Alan arrives at the King Abdullah Economic City, he already starts to feel out of place and useless. A part in him being out of place is that the culture in Saudi Arabia is drastically different then in the U.S. Eggers points out the differences in culture by writing “He had been among burqas before, but to see these shadows moving through the playground, following the children—it gave Alan a chill. Was it not something from a nightmare, to be chased by a flowing figure in black, hands outstretched?” (30).…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Abdul Husain, in particular, is a guiding light in such a dark time and corrupt community. Even though corruption is rampart and it would be so much easier to just follow suit, Abdul sticks to his beliefs and lives his life with his morals intact. He does not have an easy life, and it doesn’t keep him out of trouble, but at least he has a reason to be proud. This is a very heart-wrenching look at a community forced to be a slum and the horrors that they have to deal with every day. However, there is a strong theme of staying true to a moral path no matter what the rest of the world does. It might not always be the easy path, but it is the most respected…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the monologue, ‘The Reluctant Fundamentalist’, written by Mohsin Hamid, the protagonist is Changez, a Pakistani moves to America to pursue his Princeton degree, traces his journey of his adaption to American society, including his college life, his job at Underwood Samson, and his connection to an American girl. The assertion that “I was, in four and a half years, never an American; I was immediately a New Yorker” is not a valid point because he begins with defining himself as an American at the start. Whereas after the devastating effects of 9/11, and in consequence how Muslims were treated, Changez see’s the seeds of resentment on the surface, and becomes more patriotic towards Lahore. Likewise, his egocentricity starts to resonate as the monologue progresses; as he yearns for this due to the culmination of his ongoing search for power.…

    • 1633 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Set against the backdrop of the gradual rise of the Taliban, the novel follows the life of it’s the narrator, Amir, who faces a personal crisis when he witnesses an act of violence done to his loyal friend and servant, Hassan, which he fails to prevent. The guilt of his inaction overwhelms Amir and he eventually forces Hassan and his father Ali to cease their servitude, much to the dismay of…

    • 1618 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    During the 1960’s of American history violent acts were aimed at African Americans in the name of racism and segregation. In a case such as this one, many would seek refuge from the government, but to little surprise, cries for refuge went unanswered. Making matters worse was the fact that the Government allowed segregation to continue due to legal documents in many southern states. Acceptable forms of oppression were separated into four categories: racial segregation; voter suppression, in southern states; denial of economic opportunity; private acts of violence aimed at African Americans. At this time, many civil rights laws were advocated and many African Americans adopted a combined strategy of direct action with nonviolent resistance, known as civil disobedience. There were some positive actions throughout this time. In the early 1960’s, Brown vs. Board of Education made segregation legally impermissible; Rosa Parks and the Montgomery Bus Boycott the local ordinance segregating African-Americans and whites on public buses was lifted; Desegregation Little Rock; and The Civil Rights Act of 1957. However, many cities were still very segregated; Birmingham, Alabama was one of the most segregated cities in the United States.…

    • 1549 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mohsin Hamid’s first-person novel “The Reluctant Fundamentalist” details the fictional story of a young Pakistani man is chasing corporate success on Wall Street, and suddenly finds himself embroiled in a conflict between his American dream and the unrelenting tug of his ties to his homeland. After being inducted into the corporate world of America when beginning work at Underwood Sampson, the novels protagonist, Changez becomes disenchanted with, or unable to identify with Pakistan, whereas after the event of 9/11, Changez slowly became more critical of America and its actions and treatment of him and other Muslims, eventually causing him to develop a strong allegiance with his fellow Muslims in Pakistan and its neighbouring countries; Changez feels a sense of displacement in both America and Pakistan, as a result of America’s changing perception of him before and after 9/11.…

    • 940 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This was an eye opening documentary that identifies the symbolism of Mecca, experience, and meaning of Hajj. The camera follows three individuals from different countries on their spiritual journey to Hajj, located in Mecca. All three went to Mecca to participate in Hajj, an extremely large group of people gather for a quest of redemption as Islamic pilgrims. The people involved in this documentary are very serious about their faith; they go to great lengths to make this spiritual journey. The documentary expresses that the ones that make it to Hajj are changed spiritually forever.…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In his novel, The Kite Runner, Khaled Hosseini depicts his homeland Afghanistan as a host to many different cultures and classes, such as Pashtun and Hazara, Sunni and Shiite, with this dichotomy of beliefs and attributes being powerful enough to shape diverse, sometimes negative relationships amongst the characters of the novel and their behavior to each other, as well as establish that individual’s identity. Each person interprets the impact of the role of belief and social status differently, while all living in the same setting, adding to their complexity and depth as a character in the novel with many different figures tied together by the same geographical and cultural conditions.…

    • 1654 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    A. Attention Getter- Who has ever been to New York City? Who has ever been to Las Vegas? Who has ever been to Miami? Who has ever seen pictures of these places? What if I told you there was another place just like all these places on the other side of the world. Does anyone know of the city of Dubai? It is exactly like New York City, Las Vegas and Miami in one. Dubai’s city is amazing.…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The biggest war that any country can engage in is that of development. Although it is a long and costly war, the number of soldiers increases instead of decreasing. So let’s take part in the war of development together, and let our victims be poverty, ignorance, and backwardness. — Sheik Mohammed Bin Rashid Al Maktoum, Crown Prince of Dubai1 Dubailand, designed to be the world’s largest amusement park, was rising out of a stretch of desert near Arabian Gulf. As envisioned, the complex would cover three times the surface of Manhattan, or 45,900 acres, and nearly 5% of Dubai, a tiny emirate on the Arabian Gulf with population of one million. In addition to the park, Dubai had other ambitious development projects underway—all marvels of engineering—including three vast artificial resort islands shaped like palm trees, with one surrounded by smaller islands arranged to form the graceful lettering in an iconic Arabic poem,2 and a man-made archipelago of 300 private islands four kilometers from shore arranged in an elliptical Mollweide Projection of the world.a Part of a plan to draw 15 million tourists to Dubai by 2010, the $5 billion amusement park was expected to dwarf all entertainment, leisure, and tourism centers of the world. The completed complex would contain six themed “worlds,” each with numerous separate amusements, and a large shopping center. In addition to rides and shopping, the complex would house the largest zoo in the Middle East, an artificial rain forest, several five-star hotels, concert halls, art galleries, and sport arenas. Dubailand’s target audience would be families of all nationalities from disparate corners of the world, who would come to the region for extended vacations and return to experience additional theme worlds. The key to Dubailand’s success lay in attracting the right mix of investors and in managing shortcomings endemic to the region such as…

    • 9638 Words
    • 39 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In James Joyce’s short story Araby he is successful in creating an intense narrative. He does this in such a way that he enables the reader to feel what it is actually like to live in Dublin at the turn of the century when the Catholic Church had an enormous amount of authority over Dubliner’s. The reader is able to feel the narrators exhausting struggle to escape this influence of the Catholic Church by replacing it with a materialistic driven love for a girl.…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays