Preview

Gentrification Argumentative Essay

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1187 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Gentrification Argumentative Essay
Many people call gentrification a myth because they argue that displacement is a fiction and will always happen and that it is a good thing for poor minorities. Many studies have examined whether this phenomenon affects or benefit communities. In order to understand this issue we need to define gentrification. The classic gentrification is usually defined as the process of neighborhoods changing that results in the displacement of lower income communities by the affluent populations. The issue of gentrification has historically included a strong racial component - lower income African American residents are replaced by higher income white residents. Beveridge, Halle, Telles, & Dufault (2013) identify an important issue of how it seems that …show more content…
Ms. Rivera questions, “how can they argue this building will bring people together? When the rich already want to be “especially” transported to the building because they don’t want to walk among a community that, according to them, is dirty and full of poor people.” She described this is the beginning of gentrification and the door to racism because “before no one wanted to live here, not even come here, and now the white people come to drink at the …show more content…
We must clarify the term gentrification is prejudice against or in favor of people belonging to a particular social class. It was never meant to benefit everyone in the community. In reality, it was always meant to make change the structure of class in a certain area by raising property value through mass renovation and development. Here it is where the racial injustice in New York City comes in: why are the areas largely populated by minorities the main targets for gentrification?Why gentrifiers do not plan to go, buy, and destroy a housing building in the mid city to build a Luxurious hotel? The plan of gentrification does not only support a system of white privilege, it also makes it more difficult for those living below the poverty line to start living above it, unless these residents are

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The author discusses the comparison between two low-income neighborhoods and what one neighborhood was able to accomplish. In Highpoint, Seattle Washington residents decided to take…

    • 338 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What drives gentrification? (2014). This article is based on a speech at a recent ISO forum in Brooklyn, New York addressing the roots of gentrification and it responded on how residents of big cities everywhere face the effects of gentrification, as long-time residents are pushed out of neighborhoods due to rising rents and housing costs and other changes. The author provided an objective analysis from the perspective of the working class of New York and of all other cities undergoing gentrification by examining what appears to be two contradictory outcomes of gentrification: the "improvement" of a neighborhood on the one hand and the displacement of its long-time residents on the other. Flores also analyzed the misconception between geographers David Levy whose theory explains gentrification as flowing from the consumer preferences of a new, youthful, white-collar middle class that wishes to change from a suburban to an urban lifestyle and Late Neil Smith counterposes Levy 's theory with a class perspective by contrasting the owners of capital intent on gentrifying and developing a neighborhood having a lot more "consumer’s choice" about which neighborhoods they want to devour, and the kind of housing and other facilities they produce for the rest of us to…

    • 1820 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gentrification, a silent and gradual process that can change a neighborhood completely has displaced a vast amount of people within different areas. What is gentrification exactly? The classic scenario of gentrification is when low working class neighborhoods are transformed into a more attractable and expensive place more suitable for middle class families; a drastic change in standard living. Gentrification has been occurring all throughout the world and has been spreading rapidly, leaving many people without a home. Gentrification has happened since ancient times; in Britain in the third century large villas were being replaced by small shops. Gentry a word derived from genterise an old French word that means “gentle birth.” From Manhattan’s Lower East Side now to Harlem, many places have and are undergoing gentrification. Gentrification has its positives and its negatives which are beneficial to both sides, the old and the new residents. Do the pros outweigh the cons, are the old lower class residents being purposely moved out of an area in order to make a more prosperous? According to several articles and perspectives it all depends in which eyes we view gentrification from either the old residents who feel that the cons and greater than the pros or the view of the homeowner and the government whose intentions are to better the area and make living conditions better. In my opinion gentrification is beneficial in the greater sense that it is helping many people and the neighborhood grow by creating new and better opportunities that were not offered before.…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gentrification In America

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Gentrification has always be a controversial subject in which it particularly deals with pushing out the blacks, and moving in the whites. Although many people believe this is how gentrification works, it is actually much more complex. In modern America, gentrification is more of an inconspicuous act in which the lower class is pushed out, rather than just a specific race. Although the majority of the lower class happen to be African Americans and latinos, it is focused upon the removal of the lower class, and rise of the middle and upper class. Gentrification is a constant cycle throughout cities especially in New York, towns such as Williamsburg, have been severely gentrified by middle class and upper class New Yorkers. While gentrification…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Slater reminds readers that poor neighborhoods were once thriving but when the white middle class left the city for the suburbs the neighborhoods became impoverished. She includes the fact that though gentrification does have its downsides, the newcomers often bring money and jobs to poverty stricken neighborhoods. The neighborhoods also improve once gentrified, the author uses an example of her own neighborhood. She explains how the neighborhood’s property value tripled and how better businesses moved into the neighborhood. In the article she urges readers to move into poor urban neighborhoods and gentrify. To conclude her article she includes testimonial-like stories of gentrifiers and their contributions to their…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In an article titled America’s Worst Housing Project is Being Gentrified by Mike Pearl via internet-based fringe media outlet Vice the author argues that gentrification’s benefits only extend to those who can afford the rent hikes that inevitably accompany redevelopment. As Pearl sees it, “history teaches us that when your dilapidated housing project gets revitalized, you do not get to stay unless you stop being very poor”. The City of Los Angeles currently maintains a required ratio of one subsidized housing unit for each that is rented at market value, however the prominent real estate blog Curbed LA questions this statement, asserting that “This isn't the first effort to tear down and fancify a crumbling housing project, but it is the first time such a large project has been undertaken without kicking all of the current residents out first”. With understandable skepticism many residents of Jordan Downs believe that the gentrification may drive the low income inhabitants out of the area with no alternative options for housing. This was the case in Chicago’s Cabrini Green district, in which 80% of low income residents were driven out by more affluent residents willing to pay high prices for the land. Jordan Downs native Juanita Sims, a four decade long resident of the projects, commented…

    • 1183 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Poverty in America

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Kubrin, Charles E.;Squires Gregory D. "Privileged Places: Race, Uneven Development and the Geography of Opportunity in Urban America. Urban Studies 2005 Routledge,Taylor and Francis Group. Washington D.C. 47-68…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Growing up in East Austin, one would be accustomed to seeing rundown neighborhoods inhabited mostly by African American and Hispanic working-class families. In the past few years though, the view has drastically changed. Now brightly colored two-story homes housing affluent Caucasian families occupy the once dilapidated areas. The previously desolated lots are now the future sites of lofts and condominiums. The recent changes in East Austin are a clear sign of gentrification. Gentrification is the extremely evident process of displacement. Revitalizing a derelict neighborhood favors the entire community, not just the ones with money. However, revitalization and gentrification are two different matters; gentrification favors one class over another. The gentrifying of East Austin is a precarious process that is reaping negative effects on the preexisting community. While the middle-class is being attracted to the working-class area, established residents are inescapably being squeezed out. Pumping new life into the fading heart of a community through gentrification may be beneficial to some, but at what cost? The recent interest in a once forgotten area is not benefiting the current residents; instead, it is displacing them and erasing the community identity.…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gentrification does not follow traditional urban growth theory, which predicts "the decline of inner city areas as monied classes move to the metropolitan fringe." The traditional economic model of real estate says that wealthy people can choose their housing from the total city market (Schwirian 96). Once these people decide to live in the suburbs, the lower social classes move into the old homes of the upper class, essentially handing housing down the socioeconomic ladder. Gentrification is actually a reversal of this process. For a variety of reasons, many inner city areas are becoming more attractive to the wealthy, and they are selecting their housing in those areas (Schwirian 96). The problem is that now when the wealthy take over poor homes and renovate them, the poor cannot afford the housing that the wealthy have abandoned. Many researchers have argued whether gentrification has truly created problems in cities. I will analyze…

    • 1865 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gentrification Essay

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages

    I believe that gentrification has more of a negative effect on the community in Columbus, Ohio because you can see that the current African American residents in the community are constantly getting housing violations for simple things like having a carved sign above their homes. One of the current resident believes that the violations are happening only because the new residents moving in on the same block. I also think that the only reason Columbus, Ohio is being gentrified is because of the location, architecture, and culture of the area. The newer residents are moving in because they think that it is a desirable location to live in.…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the city of New Orleans, the homeless population is at an all-time high. A cause of the homeless population may be because of gentrification. Gentrification is the process of rebuilding an area, bringing in the company of middle class or well-off people, most likely throwing the poorer residents out from rising rent prices. People lose their homes after gentrification and even their jobs. The only good thing about gentrification is that it makes the city look better and attracts wealthier people to that certain area. I think that gentrification should not be allowed in areas that residents cannot afford the rising rent prices.…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    For one, many scholars, such as Underkuffler, contend that “The right to the protection of individual property is widely considered to be a bedrock principle of American constitutional law, akin to the protection of freedom of speech, freedom of religion, due process of law, and other constitutional guarantees.” Cases of gentrification indicate that takings have negatively impacted low income and minority communities. Moreover, the particular makeup and character of those communities sometimes drastically change through the social and economic process of…

    • 1897 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Demolition of Cabrini Green

    • 2780 Words
    • 12 Pages

    In the article in the Chicago Tribune, Walter Burnett is faced with inner turmoil and conflicts on the issue of gentrification. He has a unique view on the issue, because he grew up in Cabrini yet not as a politician working for the local government. He talks to many of the residents of Cabrini Green who all have different views. Gentrification is suitable for a specific demographic mainly for parents. Parents would like their children to be able to live in a habitable area that is not faced with drugs and violence every hour. The parents are the ones that want to move in order to have a better life not for themselves but for their children.…

    • 2780 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    These examples are just a few of the innumerable positive outcomes of gentrification, and seem to benefit not only the middle-class investing in the neighborhood, but also those who originally inhabited it. Gentrification is a tool that society can take advantage of in order “to improve ourselves, our neighbors, and our city as a whole”.…

    • 402 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    claybourne park

    • 276 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The country as a whole has taking huge strides over the past 60 years when it comes to equality, race, and integration. Gentrification however, is still a major ongoing problem today that is faced across all areas of the United States. Many people are behind remolding projects to promote an overall better community. At the same time, this in turn hurts the poverty line, because they can no longer afford to live in a revamped community. It is a very difficult decision to take a stand on either side of the argument, but when you do, you need to make sure that you way in all the facts, that affects, both sides of the argument, before you take a bold stand on whether you are for or against it.…

    • 276 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays