top-rated free essay

Gentelmen, Your Verdict

By GK1234 Mar 28, 2011 428 Words
The story Gentlemen, your Verdict is about whether or not it would be alright for a Captain to sacrifice some of his men to save a few. Although I do agree that his plan was justified, I believe that he should have chosen differently as to who should have lived. Lieutenant Captain Oram was justified in his actions because he made a good decision, he chose the men with families over the single men, and he acted as a strong leader for his men.

I believe that Captain Oram had to make a decision, and he had to make it fast, as the air in the submarine was being quickly depleted. This justified his actions because if he did not make a quick decision they all would have died from asphyxiation. It was his responsibility, as the commander of all the men, to make the decision of who should live and who should die. I feel that if other people were put into his position, they would likely make the same decision as the Captain.

He needed to decide who should live and who should die. This would have been a very difficult decision as he would have needed to think of what kind of person they were, and who depended upon them. Only a small number of men could be rescued, as there was not enough oxygen for them all to survive. It is for this reason that I think he chose the married men, because they had families which depended on them and would most likely be devastated upon their death.

As Captain, he needed to act as a strong leader who led his crew well. I believe he did. The proof of this is the fact that he remained very calm and developed a well justified plan. He ensured that his crew was calm, so that they would not panic. Another fact that proved he was a good leader is that he sacrificed himself, along with the others, instead of selfishly killing another man to keep himself alive.

Lieutenant Captain Oram made a rational, justified decision, and should not be held accountable for the killing of the rest of the men. I believe that he could have made a better decision on who should have lived. Instead of five married men, I believe that he should have saved three married men, and the two youngest unmarried men. This would allow the two unmarried men a chance to live out their lives. For these reasons, I believe that he should be announced as not guilty.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Gentlemen, Your Verdict

    ...Jas Gentlemen, Your Verdict Feb.13,11 There are twenty men trapped at the bottom of the sea in a submarine. Help will not arrive for a week. There is only enough oxygen left for about three days, but the oxygen will last five men for a week. What should the captain decide, and how? Five men were picked to live and the rest were k...

    Read More
  • Gentlemen, Your Verdict

    ...“Gentlemen, Your Verdict” Michael Bruce 1. From what perspective is the story told? (1 mark) This story is told in limited omniscient third person perspective. This is because the narrating voice enters the minds of most characters, excluding the radio telephone scenes. You can only hear Lieutenant Commander Oram’s voice, not the ch...

    Read More
  • The Verdict

    ...The Verdict Deborah Frick DeSales University The Legal Environment of Business AB 272 David B. Schwartz, Esquire February 5, 2012 “A lawyer, as a member of the legal profession, is a representative of clients, an officer of the legal system and a public citizen having special responsibility for the quality of justice.” (Preamble 1....

    Read More
  • the verdict

    ... Sociological Imagination Essay Galen College of Nursing Sociological Imagination Essay In 1959, sociologist, C. Wright Mills, had said that in order to think critically about the world around us, we need to use our sociological imagination in order to see the connections of our personal lives to the larger groups...

    Read More
  • Final Verdict

    ...1. 26th February finally saw the division of Andhra Pradesh, after a lot of deliberations and turmoil in the Parliament. With the advent of this new state, the states of the north east are experiencing unrest due to a raise in the tempo of their statehood demand. After the general elections, how would the situation play out and what is your t...

    Read More
  • Gentlemen, Your Verdict

    ...Colton Oct 17th Gentlemen, Your verdict In this story Gentlemen your verdict, the captain of a submarine, L-C Oram, is put in a difficult situation which results in him sacrificing 14 of his men including himself, to save 5 men with families waiting for them back home. Of course killing people is wrong, but if I, or anyone else, w...

    Read More
  • Gentlemen, Your Verdict

    ...Grade: 10/13 Gentlemen, your Verdict This is a story about decisions. The result of this decision was the death of fifteen crew members. A decision made by one person to end the lives of fifteen men to save five. What would you do if you were the lieutenant of a submarine and you had to decide the fate of your crew? I don't think that I could...

    Read More
  • Gentlemen Your Verdict Essay; Justified

    ... Martin Luther King Jr. once said, “the moral arc of the universe bends at the elbow of justice.” In the short story, “Gentlemen Your Verdict”, twenty men and their captain become trapped in their submarine after an explosion. Their captain, Captain Oram, then unjustly sacrifices fifteen of his men to save five others. He takes it upo...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.