Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Gender Division of Labor

Good Essays
653 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Gender Division of Labor
Gendered Division of Labor as a Unified Systems Theory

Glenn’s race-gender analysis of labor provides a unique insight to social feminism. In Gender, Race, and the Organization of Reproductive Labor, she analyzes society’s form of social reproduction—this gendered division of labor. I believe that Glenn’s inquiry leans more towards Young’s approach of a unified systems theory as opposed to Hartmann’s dual systems theory. Dual systems theory highlights two distinct spheres: capitalism and patriarchy. This theory is a combination of Marist and radical feminism, which claims that both spheres reinforce and constantly interact with each other. A unified system theory, on the other hand, takes a more historical approach that evaluates the relations of power as a whole. This theory emphasizes the value of “invisible” work such as childcare, housework, and nursing (etc.). One of the key similarities between Glenn and Young, (I believe), is that they both argue against the assumption that women as a group are in the same situation and face the same conflicts. This is clearly not true. In Women and Revolution, Young states,
“Gender division of labor analysis allows us to do material analysis of the social relations of labor in gender specific terms without assuming that all women in general or all women in a particular society have a common and unified situation… Gender division of labor analysis, however, can avoid this false identification” (55).

Glenn continuously points out that women of different races, ethnicities, and classes face very different situations. While mostly all women are subordinated to men, they are so in different ways, and in many cases women of color are inferior to white women. “Black and Latina women were disproportionately employed as service workers in institutional settings to carry out lower level public reproductive labor, while cleaner white-collar supervisory, as well as lower professional positions, were filled by white women” (Glenn, 73). Through a unified systems theory approach, both writers take account for specific variations in different groups of women’s situations. One of the major differences between Hartmann’s dual systems theory approach and Glenn’s race-gender analysis is Hartmann’s more radical concept of patriarchy as a key factor in relation to the oppression of women in all societies. Hartmann believes that patriarchy has always existed in all societies and that it came before capitalist gender inequalities. Women’s oppression under patriarchy is fundamental for capitalism and human society. Hartmann pinpoints men as the enemy in many ways throughout her writing, and she agrees that men exploit women in both the public and private spheres of society:
“Men are dependent on one another to maintain their control over women. Men maintain this control by excluding women from access to some essential productive resources (in capitalist societies, for example, jobs that pay living wages) and by restricting women’s sexuality” (Hartmann, 322).
And:
“Instead of fighting for equal wages for men and women, male workers sought the family wage, wanting to retain their wives’ services at home” (Hartmann, 325).

Glenn, however, does not argue that women’s oppression is rooted in patriarchy, because this oppression is not a universal female experience applicable to all women. While Glenn notes women’s oppression on a global scale, her conclusion does not opt for a global or universal solution. Rather, she proposes a rethinking strategy of the different interests of various classes and races of women. Moreover, Glenn accepts the fact that the improvement of the oppression of minority women may in turn cause a loss of status for higher ranked white women. Similarly, Young recognizes the need for improvement of third world women saying, “…we know now more than ever that the reproductive rights of poor and Third World women are more seriously threatened than those of other women” (Young, 63). In the ways mentioned above, it is clear that both Young and Glenn have similar viewpoints of social feminism through a unified systems theory.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    It is no secret that for centuries, women have faced years and years of discrimination, inferiority to men, and being viewed as less than human by society. Women have had to fight for their right to vote amongst other legal rights, and for their independence from their husbands. “When American women began to enter the labor force in the nineteenth century, the relatively few jobs open to them were highly segregated by gender” (Spain 1992: 14). The first women’s labor union began to form by the end of the 1930’s. Women’s activism began to increase, leading to a new reform in paid work and the rise in feminism in the midst of a new labor movement (Gregory 2003: 25). By the 1940’s, the transition of the housewife to that of a working woman began to trend. Women began to venture out of the home in search of employment and educational opportunities to help provide for their families, since their…

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Over the past hundred years, women’s participation in the workforce has grown significantly. Today’s women are getting college degrees which was not common before the mid-twentieth century. More of them than ever are taking jobs that were originally run by men. Many women are going into medicine, engineering, and law which was nearly impossible fifty years ago. Their ability to get into these fields allows them to pursue careers they could never before. However, there is a major gender pay gap. Men are still to this day paid way more than women. Although men have a large impact on our nation’s workforce, women perform job tasks just as effectively, therefore they are completely worthy…

    • 1615 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    History

    • 1158 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Upon noting this difference Brownson introduces the working class of females describing them as industrious and hard working, Brownson does not overlook the fact that the female workers are paid poorly for their labor. “And yet there is a man who employs them to make shirts, trousers, etc., and grows rich on their…

    • 1158 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “In 2015, only half of the world’s working-age women are in the labor force, compared to 77 percent of working-age men,” (MAKERS). Everyday, women face unequal circumstances and situations within the workplace. The average woman’s wage is significantly lower than their male colleagues. This would also mean that men have more job opportunities than women. All these disadvantages women face negatively affect their careers. The government has tried to decrease the inequality by creating laws, but they are never harshly enforced. Improvements for women are needed in the workplace because they will increase women’s career rights and the quality in the workplace overall.…

    • 1728 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Among police occupations, gender disparity has existed for centuries even though progress has been shown throughout past decades. Valiant efforts from women on all accounts have proven progress towards the goal. The fight and battle from women exemplify an end to gender disparity among police officers as statistics show headway into the equalization of the work force. From the beginning of the first sworn woman officer to 13% population of women among the force show progress through history. Media plays a massive role in the perception of women in the force due their representation. Changing attitudes of the male counterparts have been proven to help incorporate women into the field. In all, gender disparity exists through all work forces…

    • 150 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In what ways does language-in structure, content, and daily usage reflect and help constitute sexual inequality?…

    • 1176 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this short piece, “Our Daughters, Ourselves” by Stevie Cameron the many feats that woman have overcome in recent years are highlighted, as are the many setbacks. This piece is basically a summation of a daughters life from an over-cautious parents point of view. Although this is a short piece of writing, it does indeed touch on some of the sexual differences that still exist in our society today such as male-dominated post-secondary fields like engineering and how equally qualified woman don’t usually receive the same level of jobs as men with similar academic credentials. The piece is told from the perspective of what I can assume is a mother that went through the same sexual differences in her era and is only hoping that her daughter does not have to go through the same hardships, only to find that society still isn’t equal no matter how much progress we have made. Cameron supports her whole piece of work at the end by mentioning the tragic events of the Montreal Massacre and how all of their lives parents have been telling their daughters that they can do whatever they want and have equal opportunity only to have their dreams burned down by a sexist male who could blamed woman for his failures. I found this article interesting as I found a correlation between the reading and many topics that I learn about in my Human Resources courses such as creating equality in the workplace and equal opportunity for both sexes.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Feminism is a collection of movements and beliefs aimed at defining and defending women’s rights within society and politics aiming for all round equality. A big issue that arises within women rights is inequality in the household. The division of labour in the home is how fairly the jobs are shared between the partners in the household.…

    • 948 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the contextual resource, “Women’s Work: Gender and the Division of Labor” the reader gets a full related insight into the deeper meaning of what it meant to be divided by jobs and…

    • 1909 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Evelyn Glenn argues that race and gender shaped the development of both citizenship and labor in the United States. She explains that citizenship created boundaries of inclusion and exclusion in the sociopolitical order while labor privileged the economic order and determined which groups had access to autonomy, standards of living, and access to goods and services. White masculinity was the norm that maintained these spaces of exclusion and oppression. The shifting requirements of citizenship were influenced by the shifts in labor organization. Anglo men produced commodities outside of the home while women maintained social reproduction in the domestic sphere. As new class formations and conflicts emerged, the increase of a need for wage labor…

    • 189 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women In Canada

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages

    One of the many ways that labour markets can be segmented is by gender. Gender segmentation can be two types: Horizontal segregation, where men and women do different jobs in different occupations, industries or sectors. For example, in a small town the men were minors? And women were waitresses; and vertical segregation, where there is a division of task, status, responsibility within an organization, with men having greater authority and better pay. For example, women face subtle barriers to advancements – the boss is a guy and woman is his…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    However, African Americans were slotted into unskilled and service labor. Though this was not unexpected, it did narrow the opportunities provided to such a large group of people. Typically, the “range of job opportunities for black women was more narrow than for men. Black women were excluded from small manufacturing plants that hired white women [...] They were confined primarily to domestic labor in private homes as cooks, maids, and child-nurses” (Hunter 278). Nevertheless, African American women were insistent on working by their own terms. Though they had little to no choice in what they did for a living, black women would use “the marginal leverage they could exercise in the face of conflict between employers to enhance their wages and to improve the conditions of work” (Hunter 280). In other words, black women challenged class inequality by standing up to their employers when they believed they were being overworked or…

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In both Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck and Ain’t I A Woman by Sojourner Truth, the authors use literary devices to show how women are often objectified in society. Sojourner Truth not only speaks to the objectivity of women, but especially women of color. Both authors show that women are thought to be weak. Dating back earlier than the Great Depression, you can see that women, especially those of color, were often seen as second class citizens.…

    • 416 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Gender Pay Myth

    • 392 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The author contends that even if women worked in the same jobs as men they would earn less. Further, women of color earn even less than white and Asian women. They also have less access to paid sick and family leave and flexible work schedules.…

    • 392 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Feminization of Labour

    • 1556 Words
    • 7 Pages

    With the increase in female employment rate in developing countries, new opportunities are available in high flexibility labour markets. Feminisation of labour force has taken place with the expansion of export-oriented manufacturing sector in many industrializing countries, which leads to the creation of new opportunities for wage employment for women (Mahmud). As a result of this, women are now capable of being a source of income to support the family. Besides that, opening up industrial and former enterprises in the South gives some sort of freedom and improves the status of the poor working women (Rahman). This comes from earning wages, being able to make decisions, having a greater voice in the community and enjoying greater mobility (Rahman). Female labour is also said to be more suited to the more flexible and informal new modes of production which allows female employees to fulfill their responsibilities at home and also the workplace. Nonetheless, the downside of this flexibility of labour is that female employees would typically be taking on jobs that are part-time,…

    • 1556 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics