Topics: Leadership, Trade union, Gender Pages: 29 (9677 words) Published: March 26, 2013


ABSTRACT Organizations are realizing that, in order to adequately address human resource concerns, they must develop long-term as well as short term solutions to gender and leadership issues. This paper on the subject of Gender issues and Leadership Effectiveness attempts to appraise the issue of leadership effectiveness and gender in Nigeria union activities. It specifically looks at the current definitions of Gender, leadership and look at some common theories that relate to leadership effectiveness. It also highlighted resolutions of the 3rd NLC gender conference held in 2008. This paper will shows that there is virtually no empirical evidence that suggests that simply by being male, one has the corner on the —leadership market, especially when it concerns Union activities. And it is my hope that this paper leads to more indepth study on gender issues and leadership effectiveness in employment relations.

KEYWORDS: Effectiveness.






INTRODUCTION Women the world over share a common feature; they are marginalized in the sphere of public life. Although they account for roughly one half of every country‘s population, women are yet to be proportionately represented in public life anywhere


in the world Nwankwo (1996:1). Awareness of gender as a central feature of all aspects of everyday life and society has become more and more widespread. Every leader has a different style and a different approach to the job, but what about gender and leadership do men and women have different leadership styles? Gender and leadership is a subject that is concerned with two main questions: (1) what are the determinants of male/female differences in who assumes leadership positions and in leadership behaviour? and (2) How is leadership a gendered concept? The idea of ‗gender‘ was for the first time brought about in the 1970s by a group of feminists. The underlying factor was to use the notion of gender as a parameter for appreciating the fact that women do not relate to men in much the same way in all circumstances in every culture; and more importantly, that the position of women in society varies considerably. The concept of gender presupposes a social construct as against biological circumstance of men and women. Sometimes the phrase ―sexgender relations‖ is used; this reminds us that there is a link between biological differences between men and women and the social assumption about masculinity and feminity Rowbotham, (1992: 12). Allan Flanders defines industrial relations as a study of the institutions of job regulations. He argues that the only aspect of business enterprise with which industrial relations is concerned is the employment relation between the enterprise and its employees. Trade unions are associations that represent the collective interests of their employees- members in bargaining and negotiating with large employers. Trade unions generally seek to obtain higher wages, reduced working hours and improved working conditions for employees. In addition, trade unions seek to improve workplace safety and to obtain increased benefits, such as health insurance, pensions and disability insurance for employees. Unions also look to protect the employment security of their members, largely by negotiating to implement seniority rules and to eliminate ―at –will‖ employment contracts under which non-union employees traditionally have been subject to dismissal without cause. Appropriately social sciences research is reflecting this increasing concern with gender, especially in the field of work and organization. Sociologically gender is


basic to the foundation of every existing social order. It is constructed through situational and institutional processes. In other words, gender is...

References: Agee, T (1996); Marginalisation of women in Nigeria. The Extent, causes and solutions. In Oruwari, Y (ed), women, Development and Nigeria Environment. Ibadan Vantage publishers. pg 26. Ajayi, Y (1998); Creating a leadership culture that can Navigate change: Perspectives and Dimensions of change Management in Management and Communication Review Vol. 1 No. 1 Feb 1998. Akinboye, S (2004); Paradox of Gender Equality in Nigerian Politics. Lagos Concept Publication Limited. Pp.20, 29, 54, 190 Appleby, R.C (1994); Modern Business Administration. London ,ELBS Pitman publishing. Pg 190 Bass, B.M (1985); An introduction to theories and models of leadership. In R.M.Stogdill(ed.), Handbook of leadership. New York: free press. Pp 37-55. Becker, S.W, & Eagly, A.H (2004); The heroism of women and men. America Psychologist, 59, 163-178 Bohan , J.S (2002); Sex differences and/ in the self: Classic themes, feminist variations, ost modern challenges. Psychology of women quarterly, No 26, pp 74-88. Briskin, L. (2006); "Victimisation and Agency: The Social Construction of Union Women 's Leadership", Industrial Relations Journal, vol. 37, No 4, July 2006, 359-378. Clark, P.F. (2000); Building More Effective Unions (Ithaca, ILR Press). Pp168-186 Golgan F, & Ledwith S (2000); Diversity, Identities and Strategies of Women Trade Union Activists‖, Gender, Work and Organization, 7, 4, 242-257.
Eagly, A.H Wood & Johannesen -Schmidt, (2004); Social role theory of sex differences and Similarities: Implication for the partner preferences of women and men. In A.H Eagly, A.E Beall, & R.J Sternberg(eds). The Psychology of Gender. Pp 269-295, New York: Guilford. Eagly, A. and B. Johnson (1990); ―Gender and Leadership Style: A Meta Analysis‖, Psychological Bulletin vol. 108, No 2. Pp 233-256. Hannan, (2001); Gender mainstreaming strategy for promoting Gender Equality Women Watch. Office of the special Adviser on Gender issues and Advancement of women. Available at http: // watch/osagi/ pdf /factsheet. Hare-Mustin,R.T., & Marecek, J. (1990); On making a difference. In R.T. Hare-Mustin & J. Marecek (eds.), Making a difference: Psychology and the construction of gender. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Pp. 1-21
International Labour Office, (1996); World labour report. Geneva. Kanter, R.M (1977); Men and women in the corporation, New York: Basic Books. Nkwankwo, Nkechi (1996); Gender Equality in Nigerian Politics, Lagos, Deutchetz 1 Oakley (1972); Sex, Gender and society, London: Temple Smith. Obasanjo, O. (1989); Elements of development. African leadership forum; Women and society of a farm house dialogue. Abeokuta. AlF. 26 Olajumoke, C.M (1985); ―Nigerian Women and their participation in trade Union‖. Fashoyin et al, Eds (1985) Women in the Modern Sector Labour Force in Nigeria; Issues and prospect. Nigeria, University of Lagos. Omolara Folunsho (2009); The role of women in trade Unions and Nation building. Available at /the role of Women in trade union and nation building.pdf Otobo Dafe (1995); The Trade Union movement in Nigeria. Lagos: Malthouse press Ltd Parpart, J.L (1988) ;―Women, Work and Collective Labour Action in Africa‖, Roger Southal (Ed) Labour and Unions in Asia and Africa. London Macmillan Press Ltd. Rowbotham, Sheila (1992); Women In movement: Feminism and social Action New York: Rutledge, pg 12 Strickland, B.R (2000); Misassumptions, misadventures and the misuse of psychology. American Psychology, 55, 331-338 The Guardian (Nigeria) of Saturday, June 26, 1999: 17 women of substance This Day (1996); Newspaper August 18, 1996, pp.16. Ubeku, Abel (1983); Industrial Relations in Developing Counties: The case of Nigeria. London: Macmillan Press. Vickers, Jeanne. (1991); Women and the world Economic Crisis London: Zed Books Ltd. Yoder, J.D & Kahn, A.S (2003); Making gender comparisons more meaningful: A call for more attention to social context, Psychology of women quarterly vol.27. pp 281-290.
A Paradox in Public Attitudes (2008); Men or Women: Who‘s the Better Leader? August 25, 2008. Available at gender-leadership. Gender and leadership who has the better leadership style. Men or women? Available at and leadership. Gender and Leadership Nigeria women empowerment- Delta State Women Empowerment - Leadership Theories, Available at leadership-theories. Leadership Theories- Eight major Leadership Theories. Available at . Nigeria Labour congress 3rd National Gender Conference. Held at Hamdala Hotel, Kaduna on the 10th and 11th march 2008. Available at, detal php id. The unique characteristics of women by Linda Lowen, Available at http:// www.women /od/in theworkplaces/womenleaders. Qualities of women leader. The unique leadership chasracteristics of women. By Linda Lowen, guide. http://women /od/in the workplaces/a/women leaders.
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Gender and Leadership Essay
  • gender communication Essay
  • Gender Differences Essay
  • Gender Identity Essay
  • Essay on Gender and Leadership
  • Essay on Gender Discrimination
  • Sex, Gender and Culture
  • Gender Identity Paper

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free