Frost's "Mending Wall" vs. Floyd's "The Wall"

Topics: David Gilmour, Pink Floyd, Comfortably Numb Pages: 2 (831 words) Published: October 8, 1999
From Robert Frost's Mending Wall to Pink Floyd's Another Brick in the Wall, humankind erects and maintains real and symbolic barriers to protect and defend opposing stances, beliefs and territories. Although each "wall" is different they serve the same purpose and both Frost and Floyd oppose them. Robert Frost's Mending Wall is a very popular poem. This poem consists of two characters: the narrator and his neighbor. In this poem the two neighbors are mending a stone wall that separates their property. The wall mending has been a pastime of the neighbors for many years and occurs every spring. Over the winter the wall has fallen victim to both hunters and the frozen ground and, therefore, contains gaps that must be filled.In the poem the narrator questions the sense of even mending the wall . He concludes that neither of the farms contain animals, only trees, which would be enough of a boundary. There is no physical need for the wall, so why go through the trouble of fixing it every year for no apparent reason. Although the narrator is right the ignorant neighbor insists that they mend the wall by saying "Good fences make good neighbors."(Frost) The neighbor repeats this saying although he doesn't know why the wall is necessary nor does he know why it will make them better neighbors . Frost is criticizing the ignorance of the neighbor here. Mending Wall, although it doesn't appear it on the surface, almost parallels to a popular Pink Floyd song, Another Brick in the Wall. The speakers of the song are students and the poem is directed towards teachers. In this song, as in Mending Wall, a barrier is discussed, but this time it is a phsycological barrier instead of a physical one. This barrier has been put up by society and is being built up by the teachers. The students are calling out against this building up of the wall. As it is stated in the song: "All in all you're(teachers) just another brick in the wall."(Floyd) This barrier being put up is...

Cited: /b>
  • "Another Brick in the Wall (Part II)," (Pink Floyd, Columbia Records, 1979)
  • Frost, Robert. "Mending Wall." (7 June 1998)
  • Knap, Joe. "Mending Walls: Barriers in Communications." Lesson Plans. (7 June 1998).
    Continue Reading

    Please join StudyMode to read the full document

  • You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

    • Essay about Robert Frost's Mending Wall
    • Robert Frost's Mending Wall Essay
    • The Mending Wall Essay
    • The Mending Wall Research Paper
    • The Mending Wall Essay
    • Mending Wall Essay
    • Mending Wall Essay
    • Mending Wall Essay

    Become a StudyMode Member

    Sign Up - It's Free