Free Will Versus Determinism

Topics: Free will, Critical thinking, Determinism Pages: 2 (462 words) Published: October 12, 2011
Argument and Logic
Vanessa Sumner
Nancy Wack
September 14, 2011

The excerpt I chose was “Free Will versus Determinism”, and I noticed from the beginning the piece was written with reasons to support the content. First, the presentation introduces two beliefs; the behavior of atoms is governed entirely by physical law, and humans have free will. Immediately after presenting these ideas and questioning the relations in the two, the excerpt explains the logical approach to why they do not necessarily favor one another. Any argument that is presented, or comparison of two aspects, needs facts and reasons to confirm why the person is trying to convince the reader or other person that the argument is supported. Referring to the two beliefs presented at the beginning of the excerpt, the piece supports the idea that the behavior of atoms is governed entirely by physical law and humans have free will do not have a congruent relationship. Atoms will do what they have to do because of physical law and its determination of what each atom will do in the given circumstances. This is fact which is presented clearly and holds accuracy. An interpretation of the example given would be is if an atom does Z in circumstance Q, then circumstance Q will result in the atom having to do Z. By physical law, one cannot predict, change, or control what atoms do and how they do what they do. Continuing on to the next segment of the excerpt, it explains that free will is what happens, but did not necessarily have to happen. Unlike atoms and how they are governed by physical law, free will is something that has to be invoked by a human. Choice is the root in free will and what a person chooses to do will have a result. In this second part I began to see the argument because it was the comparison to the first fact presented, and reasons are given for why the argument is being made. A quote is written into the conclusion that points out that humans have free will...

References: Moore-Bruder, (2008). Philospophy (7th ed.). : The McGraw-Hill Companies
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Free Will Determinism Essay
  • Essay about Free-Will and Determinism
  • Determinism and Free Will Essay
  • Free Will And determinism Essay
  • Free Will and Determinism Can Coexist Essay
  • Free will vs. Determinism Essay
  • Free Will vs Determinism Essay
  • Essay on Free Will vs. Determinism

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free