top-rated free essay

Food Peddlers: Stop Them for Our Children's Sake

By nurfara61 Sep 09, 2013 1242 Words
FOOD PEDDLERS: Stop them for our children's sake

DO you know exactly what your children are eating while they are at school? Most parents are careful of their children's diet, at home and at school. Many children bring home-cooked meals to school while some buy them at the school canteen, which is monitored by the school authorities and the Health Ministry. School canteens have a menu and price list, and under a directive from the Education Ministry, sale of junk food is prohibited. However, schoolchildren can still get access to some unhealthy food in the school compound itself. At a primary school in Seremban, pupils hand blue, green and red notes through the school fence to buy junk food from two food peddlers, who operate from their car boots, selling food from 50 cent and even up to RM10. They also sell plastic toys.

These food peddlers carry on their business despite a signage prohibiting them from doing so. The peddlers enjoy brisk business, with children jostling and shoving each other as though the items are distributed for free. I noticed a pupil who handed two RM10 notes for two boxes of toys worth RM8.90, and he did not get back his change. That was profit on top of profit for the peddlers, but a loss for the parents and the child. Of course, some of us may ask how the pupil gets that much money. But that is not the point here. The issue is why are these unlicensed peddlers are allowed to do business at a prohibited place? Most of the foods sold are from China and are not nutritious. Either they are high in sugar or have artificial flavouring, which can be detrimental to children's health. Are we just going to stand and watch the children, who may be our very own or our neighbors’ children, eat food that can harm their health? We talk so much about robberies and snatch thefts, and how heavy punishment should be imposed on the offenders. What about the children, who are protected at home and at school, but lose their money and health to unscrupulous food peddlers? This may be also happening in other schools in the country.

The Education and Health ministries' joint effort in introducing and controlling healthy food in schools for the benefit of the students is being ruined by these food peddlers who place profit as their priority. I was told about this by a senior assistant of the primary school that every effort had been made to get rid of these food peddlers, including educating the children, reporting to the Education Department, complaining to the Seremban Town Council and putting up the signage, but nothing has worked. These are unlicensed peddlers and they are contributors to serious health and obesity problems among children. The authorities must act against these offenders before something bad happens.

Highlight from the article

Conclusion:That was profit on top of profit for the peddlers, but a loss for the parents and the child. Premise 1:The peddlers enjoy brisk business, with children jostling and shoving each other as though the items are distributed for free. Premise 2 :These food peddlers carry on their business despite a signage prohibiting them from doing so. Premise 3:At a primary school in Seremban, pupils hand blue, green and red notes through the school fence to buy junk food from two food peddlers, who operate from their car boots, selling food from 50 cent and even up to RM10.

Paraphrase
Conclusion:That was profit on top of profit for the street vendors, but a loss for the parents and the child. Premise1:The street vendors enjoy the quick business, with children hustling and shoving each other as though the items are distributed for free Premise 2:these food vendors carry on their business against a signage restrict them from doing so. Premise 3:At a primary school in Seremban, pupils have some money, RM1, RM5 and RM10 through the school fence to buy junk food from two food vendors, who operate their car boots, selling food from 50 cent and event up to RM10. A critical analysis of an argument

The analysis is on fallacies in an argument is based on a letter to editor which appeared in the New Straits Times dated August 29, 2013 entitled “FOOD PEDDLERS: Stop them for our children's sake”. The letter described a writer response on the peddlers who are selling their food at the prohibited place to the children which is not good. The writer seems to be completely against the peddlers throughout this article.

The first type of fallacy that has make this argument is weak is hasty generalization. It occurs when somebody make a broad general claim based on insufficient evidence. There is evidence of hasty generalization as the writer gives the impression that the writer claimed in the following statement; “Most of the foods sold are from China and are not nutritious”. There is no proof as referring to the food sold from China is not nutritious like the writer opinion. There also no specific study that has been cited to support his claim. The writer does not cite the s from China that is not nutritious.

In addition, the writer’s argument is also biased, that is one sided, because he has painted a completely negative picture about food peddlers. This is because no where in his arguments does he admit or acknowledge that food peddlers can sometimes give a benefits which it The food industry says that they are educational, because they enable parents and kids to discuss choices in the marketplace.

Next, there is also fallacy of appeal to fear. The writer is trying to gain the reader to agree his point by instilling fear like the following statement,” Are we just going to stand and watch the children, who may be our very own or our neighbors’ children, eat food that can harm their health?”. What she is implying is that all the peddlers are selling the innutritious food to the children and if the parents did not take any action, it may harm their children health. In this way the writer is trying to convince the reader that Malaysian people should make it an offence to against the peddlers with this statement.

The argument in this article is also weak because the writer is trying to gain support for her views by using the emotive language to persuade the readers in order to accept his opinion. Emotive words are ones which appeal to our emotive words to create an emotional response from the reader and to make readers feel like they can connect with what they are reading. This can be seen in the following example: such unscrupulous, detrimental, ruined, not nutritious, are contributors to serious health and obesity. These words are so colored or biased and in this way he is hoping to convince the reader to agree with him. There is more emotive language that sounded reasoning in order to influence the reader to accept his argument.

The last fallacy in this article is the fallacy of slippery slope. The writer says that “these are unlicensed peddlers and they are contributors to serious health and obesity problems among children.” This sort of reasoning is fallacious because there is no reason to believe that one event must inevitably follow from another without an argument for such a claim.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Our Food Is Our Choice

    ...Our Food is our Choice Genetically modified foods or GMOs (genetically modified organisms) resulted from “genetic engineering where scientists alter the genes of plant and animal DNAs for the desired specific traits” (Ackerman). In this case, GMOs have changes in their genomes and we cannot certainly tell how these changes can affect the c...

    Read More
  • Food

    ...Food in Your Life Topic Review Complete topic review. Put the answers in a different color. List the 4 key behaviors for wellness. 1. Positive food choices 2. Physically active 3. Managing stress 4. Alcohol/drug free Explain the role of science in food. Science tells you what nutrients do in your body and how nutrients work t...

    Read More
  • Foods

    ...Foods to avoid: We asked Food Scientists a simple question: “What foods do you avoid? Experts from different areas of specialty explain why they won’t eat these eight foods. Food scientists are shedding light on items loaded with toxins and chemicals–and simple swaps for a cleaner diet and supersized health. Experts from different a...

    Read More
  • Food and our Youth

    ...their products to children? Should consumers be active in changing this?” Food and our Youth Have you ever opened up a box a cereal, ate a little bit, then you couldn’t stop eating it? This is caused by a natural reaction called the “Bliss Point”. It causes us to crave foods with sugar. With this discovery by Monell, many companies t...

    Read More
  • GMOS In Our Food

    ... Renea Henry WRIT 121 31, January 2014 First Draft Essay 1 GMOs in Our Food I never paid much attention to all the controversy going viral about GMOs until I started reading articles about this. America has brought forth the attention of eating healthy and staying fit in order to live a longer, healthier life. However, in or...

    Read More
  • our food needs

    ... Our Food Needs From: Melyssa Olmstead For Mrs. MacDonald HFN-201-2 Tuesday, September, 2013 Bear Creek Secondary School Physical Benefits of Eating ...

    Read More
  • tHEMS

    ...People”). Not all people have the same ability to turn down food whenever they want. That causes people to be overeaters, thus, making them overweight. However, not only can some people be genetically predisposed to overeat, but most Americans have a different mindset in their eating choices. Most of them think that just because a yogu...

    Read More
  • Unethical Marketing of Children's Lunchbox Foods

    ...Unethical Marketing of Children's Lunchbox Foods Brilliantly marketed highly salty foods are being deliberately targeted for our children's lunchboxes. According to Consensus Action on Salt and Health (CASH)1 the promotion of extremely high salt foods targeted at school lunchboxes is an unethical marketing practice. Four out of five items surve...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.