Preview

Five Myths about Immigration - a summary of david cole's view.

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
929 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Five Myths about Immigration - a summary of david cole's view.
Author David Cole explains in "Five Myths about Immigration" that people are misinformed about immigrants in America and blame them for all the problems in the American society. Cole comments that the "Native Americans", which have nothing to do with what we call Native Americans today, were labeled as "Know-Nothings" because they simply did not know anything about immigrants and prejudged immigrants who came into the country. The author quotes one "Know-Nothing" for saying that "more than half the prisons and almshouses, more than half the police and the cost of administering criminal justice are for foreigners." In the 1860s, immigrants arrived from Ireland and Germany causing "anti-alien and anti-Catholic sentiments" to appear in states such as Massachusetts and New York. Cole takes this topic to heart because his ancestors were among the "dirt-poor Irish-Catholics" who moved to America in the 1960s but were fortunate because after fifteen years the prejudice faded away. Now, 140 years later, the author points out that a similar prejudice has returned with the exception that the focus has changed from "Irish Catholics and Germans" to "Latin Americans (most recently, Cubans), Haitians, and Arab-Americans." Cole explains how five commonly held beliefs regarding immigrants to the United States, are in reality "myths."

Cole's first misunderstanding "myth" is that "America is being overrun with immigrants." America is a "nation of immigrants", which has been true since Christopher Columbus landed in this country. Although most Americans believe that foreign-born people make up a large population of the United States, Cole notes that only eight percent of immigrants fall in this category. In fact, "between seventy and eighty percent" of those who immigrate each year are "refugees and immediate relatives of U.S. citizens." In addition, immigrants living in the United States only make up one percent of the country's population. "Most aliens do not cross the border

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Alan M. Kraut’s Silent Travelers: Germs, genes, and the “Immigrant menace” traced American’s efforts to cope with immigrants whose labor was needed, but foreignness was feared. Nearly every ethnic group that has migrated to the United States, Kraut wrote, was greeted by hostility. During America’s peak immigration period between 1890 and the 1920’s , Americans have blamed the Irish for bringing cholera, the Italians for bringing polio, the Chinese for carrying bubonic plague, the Jews for spreading tuberculosis, and the Haitians for bringing AIDS. Kraut describes the relationship among…

    • 2706 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Immigrants and their assimilation into America is a long standing occurrence, with initial experiences by the Pilgrims of the early 1600s to the first documentation of mass immigration with the arrival of Catholic and Jewish immigrants, from Italy and Russia during the colonial era in the late 1800s to early 1900s. With this influx at the time being labelled as “New Immigration”, “Nativists feared the new arrivals lacked the political, social, and occupational skills needed to successfully assimilate into American culture” (Wikipedia). These historical concerns continue to evolve in modern debate of the pros and cons of immigrant assimilation, the conflicting interests of Immigrant and Nation, and examination of the meaning of the term “assimilation’…

    • 220 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the late 19th century and early 20th century, immigration to the United States was wrought with challenges. The newly arriving aliens were met with racist native-borns who feared that they would threaten their way of life. This tension between these new groups facilitated the U.S. government’s anti-immigration laws, which also caused political outbursts from those who supported immigrants.…

    • 519 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The United States of America originally a nation of immigrants is rapidly becoming a nation of native born citizens. We have by now had an opportunity to produce the native-born individual someone we might label as an “American”. Today, the number of foreign-born persons in the United States is about 3,000,000 of the population, and about 5,000,000 of Americans are the children of immigrants. Due to the new Immigration Reform and Control Act the days of mass immigration are over, but the influence of the movement will never be eased. (Arun and Daniel p.1)…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    John F. Kennedy once exclaimed, “Every American who ever lived, with the exception of one group, was either an immigrant himself or a descendant of immigrants(A Nation Of Immigrants page 3)." John was known for his irish-catholic heritage, and he served as one of our most beloved presidents. John A. Treutlen was the first naturalized citizen governor. Treutlen’s parents were raised with British ideals. When Treutlen went off to America to make something of himself, his parents called him worthless (D). However, he rose above his heritage to bring great ideas to American policies. Treutlen wasn’t the only citizen considered worthless. In fact many immigrants feel like this when they come to America. They want to prove to their families (and themselves) that…

    • 1595 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    A group, known as the Rhode Island Coalition for Immigrants and Refugees, is hoping to counter the anti immigration sentiment developing a “speakers’ bureau” that “pairs up” immigrants and refugees with social workers. This unlikely duo may help with the spread of immigrants that have become anti immigrant. This goes to show how alarmingly selfish and hypocritical the human race can be. On the opposite side, helping flourish anti immigrants’ sentiments is a North Carolina group that “blames immigrants for the rise in the cases of rubella” which is a contagious viral infection. The immigrants are almost always used as scapegoats for problems they have little to do with. It is so easy to blame a problem on the newcomer because they do not know or even feel comfortable enough to defend themselves against the bully. Often being taken advantage of, does little to help with their progress. In a book review of Enrique’s journey from the Sunday Gazette, it is said that the main reason for opposing the immigration is because “it is crime” but the argument against that given by Nazario is simply “that one must understand the crimes…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Europe wasn’t prospering during the mid 1840s and the high population couldn’t strive with the crop failure, so they sought refugee. Hundreds of thousands of Europeans migrated to America, looking forward to the progress of America; however, native-borns didn’t welcome so easily. Again, superiority defaced America and a party that was against the immigrants were formed and called the Know-Nothings. The Know-Nothings made paintings and books showing how immigrants were drunken brutes (pg. 357) and putting down the Catholic religion. The Know-Nothing gained political power as a result of most of the country favoring nativism, but soon fell after splitting like the Whig…

    • 750 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Thomas Bailey Aldrich's poem, "The Unguarded Gates", he describes immigrants as "bringing with them unknown gods and rites". Aldrich's poem in its entirety displays the worry that US citizens had for immigrants bringing with them religions, ideals and values that were strange and sometimes unknown to them. Immigrants and anyone else who were perceived as "un-American" seemed to threaten the "old ways" that the citizens were trying so hard to preserve. They appreciated that this country was founded on these "old ways" and so they felt they had to preserve these ideals and set of values. Document F stated: "... many of these alien peoples are temperamentally and racially unfitted for easy assimilation." Americans read many newspaper articles with similar arguments like the one above, that these immigrants would not be able to accept the ways of American life and would only shelter themselves in their communities. For example, the South End of Hartford has been deemed "Little Italy" for almost two centuries now because when Italians immigrated to America they would…

    • 1014 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The United States has become known as a melting pot of many different cultures through immigration, but immigration has not always been looked upon in a lighthearted manner.In fact, during the years between 1880 and 1925, immigration created tensions and was frowned upon for multiple reasons. These included large influxes of immigrants getting opportunities before native born people could, the possibility of the government being spied on by people from axis powers. However, to every negative impact there is a positive, and although many people were opposed to massive immigration, others supported temporary immigration for several reasons.…

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kennedy once said in 1958, “Immigration policy should be generous; it should be fair; it should be flexible. With such a policy we can turn to the world, and to our own past, with clean hands and a clear conscience” (Kennedy 9). However, his plan has never been adopted. Even before John F. Kennedy’s time, America suffered from immigration issues. Xenophobia was exhibited towards Irish immigrants who suffered as they tried to adapt to the new society. But the immigrant matter became much more serious after 1863 when the Central Pacific railroad hired Chinese laborers, and the Union Pacific hired Irish laborers to construct the first transcontinental railroad. Then other ethnic groups started to immigrate to the United States. From 1910 to1920, 2 million Italians arrived. Every time a new ethnic group was introduced to the society, xenophobia was exhibited towards them by the original members of the society. The target has changed from Italians to Jews, Japanese, Germans, Mexicans, Russians, and Middle Easterners, but the phenomenon was similar with each category of people. For instance, one New York Times article shows how the society slowly accepts new arrivals. With the largest wave of immigration since the turn of the century raising New York City's foreign-born population to 28 percent, a poll done in 1993 found that most residents said there were too many immigrants in town and added that while most are law-abiding, they had made the city a worse place to live (McFadden). The article that was written to discuss the findings of the poll shows how xenophobia works. Oftentimes there are no good reasons to support xenophobia. Rather it is simply a hateful feeling towards those who are different from…

    • 989 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With the alleged increasing influx of immigrants the intensification of racism and nativism has taken a new shape and seeped into the media, as well as local, state, and federal policy. Particularly, the escalation of nativism is concentrated at Latinos, and has thus, created an issue of illegality. In addition, nativism, an adverse outlook on foreign individuals, has remained molded by dynamics that shift with historical occurrences and has influenced anti-immigrant sentiments (Higham, 2002, 3).…

    • 282 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Immigrants have been seeking salvation or just new opportunities in America for hundreds of years. Even Americans originally started off as immigrants. They came to settle in this New World to seek opportunities. These types of immigrants were white, strong, leaders and felt they were superior. In the mid nineteenth century, the “new” immigrants were also welcomed. According to President Grant, these “new” immigrants were the weak, broken, and crippled people who had nowhere else to go. Grant thought these “new” immigrants would ruin the tone of the American life into a more vulgarized tone now that these immigrants are filling up the jails and asylums (Document 4). They mostly came from Southern and Eastern parts of Europe and were poor, ignorant, and illiterate. They were needed for working power and employers liked to use them because they were able to give them cheaper wages. Soon there was an economic boom when machines came to replace the workers. Resentment soon arose since job offers were scarce and immigrants received the jobs over the Americans.…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    19th Century Immigrants

    • 365 Words
    • 2 Pages

    At the end of the nineteenth century, the population, especially in cities, began to surge. Technology began to advance, helping cities handle the increasing population. (pg. 701) Along with the population, cities grew “as horse-drawn streetcars and commuter railways let people live farther away from their downtown workplaces.” (pg. 701) America greatly prospered, resulting in many immigrants being attracted to it. Many newcomers from Europe arrived in America, causing the number of immigrants to raise “from just under 3 million annually in the 1870s… [to] 9 million annually in the first decade of the twentieth century.” (pg. 704) This new surge of immigrants was not well received by “nativists,’ racists who believed that Anglo-Saxon Americans…

    • 365 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    New Immigrants

    • 400 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Finally, the main difference and major contribution to Native-born fears was the willpower of the “New Immigrants” to preserve their culture regardless of the costs. Although the “Old Immigrants” also tried to keep their culture alive, they did this in a very minimalistic way in comparison to the restaurants, social clubs, and more that the “New Immigrants” created in an attempt to preserve their culture. This also was faced with opposition especially by antiforeign organizations such as the “American Protective Association” or APA who made every effort to prevent Roman Catholic from taking office and even suppressed the faith by depicting their nuns in “lustful fantasies.” Besides degrading the culture of the new individuals who had come to America, the Native-born also developed organized labor which emphasized the language barrier of the “New Immigrants” as a means to protect American workers and their jobs from the “inferior.” Organized Labor was not the only tactic to…

    • 400 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Labor Inequality

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages

    From the beginning of colonization to the formation of the new nation, immigrants came from all around Europe, a majority from countries like Germany and Ireland. While immigration was widely encouraged, it soon became apparent that the non-English immigrants were vastly outnumbering the amount of English settlers. Many English settlers even accused the non-English of intruding on their land and jobs, as one English settler said regarding the actions of a small group of non-English immigrants, the Mennonites, they “transported themselves into the Providence of Pennsylvania from Holland in British shipping, and purchased Lands at low rates towards the River Susquehanna.” Another concern of the English immigrants toward their other European neighbors was their lack of assimilation; “they generally adhere to their own customs.” While in their original arrival many were able to generally make money for themselves, the prejudice against non-English immigrants grew as time went on. As prejudices increased, it became very difficult for the immigrants to find employment in the colonies. This became a very apparent problem after the potato famine in Ireland, and companies began advertising for “non-Irish workers”. The disdain of non-English immigrants by the English goes deep enough for the English to request, “a general provision against all Foreigners.”…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays