top-rated free essay

Fighting for American Manhood, by Kristin Hoganson

By vince1000 Oct 16, 2012 534 Words
Précis 1
Fighting for American Manhood

Kristin Hoganson has a very interesting idea, which she defends very well with a lot of evidence. Hoganson argues that gender politics played a major role in forcing American into the Spanish American and Philippine wars. She makes many great points throughout her book, Fighting for American Manhood, which perfectly back up her main argument.

Hoganson believes that the majority of America felt a need to be masculine. They could not back down from a fight. America, as a whole, was too proud of a nation. These views that the public, and many politicians, expressed led to McKinley declaring war and fighting back for the Maine explosion. McKinley wanted to avoid going to war but the Jingoes were too large a group and eventually McKinley had no choice. They argued that allowing the Maine explosion to happen without punishment would make a joke out of America. We had to fight to show our authority. America needed to show that it was an honorable nation that would not back down, that it would come together and take action. People did not just say that America needs to show off its manhood, they were even attacking McKinley’s manhood. Hoganson’s best evidence for her argument is in the political cartoons that she includes throughout the book. They show the views of the people at the time. An example would be the one where Uncle Sam is holding McKinley up and telling him all he needs is a backbone. All of these cartoons help back up Hoganson’s thesis. These were drawn by people who experienced first hand what America was going through. As for the Philippine –American war, Hoganson shows very well how manliness came into play. First of all, our war with the Spanish is what originally got us involved with the Philippines. Hoganson argues that Americans viewed the Philippine people as unmanly. This allowed them to say it was right for the United States to control them. Americans said they were “lacking the manly character seen as necessary for self-government” (Hoganson, 134). In they eyes of most Americans, they were only savages. Hoganson also say that we viewed them as children. We had to the manly and paternal thing, which was to care for them until they matured. Hoganson shows how many used the same child argument but flipped towards America. They said that if we cannot care for another nation, then we are immature and child like. We had to show our dominance by becoming more imperialistic. America “had grown strong, it was ready to take on the manly role of governing dependents” (Hoganson, 157). When putting all this together, Hoganson wants to show just how important a role manhood has had in our history.

Kristen Hoganson does a good job of providing plenty of evidence to support her claims. However, one fault is that she does not really explore the other side of her claim. She should explain counter arguments and try to refute them. Her use of political cartoons was the best aspect of the book. Overall, her book was persuading and convincing and opened my eyes to an idea I never thought of before.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Fighting for Ameican Manhood

    ...controversial subject that always attracts attention. After the Spanish-American War, many men were seen as heroes, some even put into important positions in our nations’ government. Men like McKinley and Roosevelt, for example, used such praise and recognition to reinforce their positions of President and, later on, Vice President, respective...

    Read More
  • African-Americans Fighting for Equality

    ...African-Americans Fighting for Equality Michelle Moore HIS204: American History Since 1865 July 29, 2012 African-Americans Fighting for Equality African-Americans have been fighting for equality and freedom every since they were taken from Africa as slaves. They were stolen from their families and separated only to be servants to others ...

    Read More
  • African Americans: Fighting for Their Rights

    ...African Americans: Fighting For Their Rights During the mid 1950s to late 1960s African Americans started responding to the oppressive treatment shown to them by the majority of white people in the country. They responded to the segregation of blacks and whites during that time and the double standards the African Americans were held to. Afric...

    Read More
  • manhood

    ... Manhood It is said one cannot understand or empathize with someone else unless "you walk a mile in their moccasins." John Howard Griffin did just that, darkened his skin and took a walk into the Deep South to see how it would feel to be a member of a despised minority during 1959, ...

    Read More
  • fighting

    ...someone will give to you. You don't have the depth of conviction. You don't have an emotional sonorousness. You don't have commitment to tasks that would take more than a lifetime to commit. 2:55I was reminded of a common response through history of how you build a solid Adam II, how you build a depth of character. Through history, peopl...

    Read More
  • American Encounters Final

    ...Daisy Paridon 24 October 2014 Group B: Question 2 Before the American Revolution, men monopolized the political and government realms while women were denied this right. Furthermore, in the existing social hierarchy women were viewed as subordinate to men and not considered independent legal individuals. As women grew tired of their inferior ...

    Read More
  • american funerals

    ...when they involve the death of a loved one. Over the years, there has grown a common and yet distinct American custom when it comes to how funerals are perceived and conducted (James 348). However, most Americans still hold unto the traditional funerals as opposed to modern ones. Unfortunately, the American funeral customs put a lot of more emp...

    Read More
  • American Revolution

    ...the war. For military actions, see American Revolutionary War. For other uses, see American Revolution (disambiguation). In this article, inhabitants of the Thirteen Colonies who supported the American Revolution are primarily referred to as "Americans" or "Patriots," and sometimes as "Whigs," "Rebels" or "Revolutionaries." Colonists who suppor...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.