Since the government would not intervene with most of the economics of this time then that meant that the big businesses had the power to do anything they wanted no matter who it hurt, which was mostly the lower working classes. In Samuel Gompers Forum, "Letter on Labor in industrial Society", he tried to explain how the industries did not care for the lower classes by stating that, "Year by year man's liberties are trampled under foot at the bidding of corporations and trusts, rights are invaded and law perverted." Samuel went on to say, "You [a federal judge] may not know that the labor movement as represented by the trades unions, stands for right, for justice, for liberty," which meant that as the lower classes tried to fight back against the big businesses the government pushed them down to make sure the upper classes had no problems. Knowing all of this, it raises the question on how much of a laissez - faire government was America at that time?
The government would do nothing to help the lower class but whenever the upper class had a problem, the government would use dirty tricks of the law to get there will. In the Interstate Commerce Act of 1887 it says, "Section 4. That it shall be unlawful for any common carrier.....to charge or receive any greater compensation in the aggregate for the transportation of passengers.....for a shorter than for a longer distance over the same line..." Is this not making transportation easier for people AND goods? Would that not be making it easier for businesses to sell there goods to bigger markets? Is this not interference from the government?
While the upper class is profiting from all of these boosts from the government, the lower class is getting even farther away from being equal with the upper class. The lower class's conditions worsened because of the bad conditions the upper class gave them to work in. From a testimony of a Physician at the Committee of the Senate it was said that, "I should say it was of such a character as to need mending, so say the least. It needs some radical remedy." A professional physician said that these people who work in the factories every day are so beaten up from this work that there is on way to undo the effects of it. Yet, thanks to all their hard work, the elite business class have nice houses and great lives which the government helped make easier for them to do.
To best summarize the political out views of the two major parties of the time, the Populist Party Platform gives a great description of what the political mood was like, "Neither do they now promise us any substantial reform. They have agreed together to ignore, in the coming campaign, every issue but one. They propose to drown the outcries of a plundered people with the uproar of a sham battle over the tariff..." The Populist Party always defended the working class and pointed out how the other parties would not even try to debate over the real issues that are bothering America of that time period.
By ignoring big issues such to help the lower classes in the political world, it helped the big businesses have no interference in their world of making money. In fact, by ignoring the big issues, the government was really indirectly helping the economics of the Country.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The effect of big businesses on the economy was that the economy was said to have grown 400% during this time period, this seems like a huge rise but then again this would not have been that hard seeing as there was little to no government regulations. For example in document B the railroad businesses are portrayed to be kings and even controlled the government and the people as well. However, exploding the economy wasn't the only thing big business did for America, they transformed how the economy was run, America became a huge manufacturing country. Document C shows that this manufacturing was so huge because of mass production, however, mass production wasn't all good, even though document A showed that mass production lowered the cost of living. Mass production led to a specialization of labor, which led to a rather unskilled workforce and an unskilled workforce is easy to replace so job security was not very high. This was unfair to the workers who were treated as property rather than employees, an argument in Document G, workers who were injured or even executed on the job went un-noticed by these big businesses because they were considered "Wage Workers". These mass production techniques were demoralizing and in a way inhumane on the worker and because of this Labor Unions formed, notably one of the bigger ones was the Knights of Labor. Uriah Stephens originally started the Knights, but Terence Powderly soon took over, and their biggest victory was at the Union Pacific Railroad strike in 1884, this made workers treated better. Big businesses also often became monopolies and there was no one person better at this than John D. Rockefeller.…
- 1132 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
There has been a necessity in the twentieth century (due in part to the Great Depression and World War II) for big government. The legislation behind Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal called for the involvement of the federal government to create a highly bureaucratic social policy. The combination of Roosevelt's political assertiveness and society's willingness to allow such centralization that made big government possible. The laissez-faire mentality of the twenties was seen as the cause of the depression. The federal government and the ensuing reforms were seen as a way of insuring economic security. In the sixties President Johnson followed with a plan of social reform: "The Great Society". In contrast to the severe economic circumstances of the thirties, the sixties were consumed with social unrest. The predominantly white bourgeoisie saw such reforms as a financial threat. The civil rights act of 1964 was a distant promise to the underprivileged for a better way of living. The American people were not willing to give up some of their money so that the more unfortunate could a have a better way of living. The…
- 864 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In the early years of American history, most political leaders were reluctant to involve the federal government too heavily in the private sector, except in the area of transportation. In general, they accepted the concept of laissez-faire, a doctrine opposing government interference in the economy except to maintain law and order. This attitude started to change during the latter part of the 19th century, when small business, farm, and labor movements began asking the government to intercede on their behalf.…
- 500 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
To begin, government was more involved with business, in addition to a regulated industry in both the New Deal and Progressive Era. The New Deal produced a number of policies and programs that worked to change the life of Americans living in poverty, greatly influenced by the Progressive ideology. For example, in 1941, the Supreme Court overrules current decision from 1916 declaring child labor unconstitutional (http://xroads.virginia.edu/~ma01/davis/photography/reform/progressive_era.html). Roosevelt intended to pull families out of poverty by providing men with jobs, while Progressive ideals focussed on protecting women and children in poverty. Although the progressive movement didn’t occur in the heat of depression like the New Deal Era, Roosevelt’s reforms of protecting the impoverished, and bringing back the nation to a healthy unemployment level may have been greatly influenced by Progressive ideals. Additionally, The Progressive movement was seeking exploration of money for new adventures, simultaneously pushing the wealthy class beyond the lower class. These excesses ultimately crashed down upon United States society, leaving the New Deal to bring back prosperity. Roosevelt planned to do so by improving the country, while people were making money, building infrastructure like roads and…
- 1134 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The Gilded Age was a time of great industrial expansion for the nation. In the years following the Civil War, the idea of laissez-faire would become popular among many presidents. The Presidents from the end of the Civil War until the 1890s are often called “The Forgettable Presidents.” They took little action and politics and government was largely dominated by Congress. Many issues would arise during this period, including the practice of patronage, the abuses of the railroads, the rise of trusts and monopolies, and issues concerning currency and the money supply. Most of these issues would be addressed, but the solutions and legislation was very weak.…
- 843 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In the United States during the late 1800’s many industrial workers, both foreign and domestic, banned together to stand against wealthy elites to obtain better compensation for their strenuous work. In this time of rising conflict, many labor unions attempted to speak out and demand better reward. Many big name companies owned by rich businessmen were mistreating their workers and eventually groups like the “Knights of Labor”, “The Workingmen’s Party of Illinois” and “The Lehr and Wehr Verein” were assembled to unify the workers allowing them to resist oppression. Many of these big name companies dealt with the major manufacturing of goods such as lumber and steel, while many others were more focused on the construction of the railroads that transported these goods or the press that advertised them. Because businesses were privately owned and singularly managed, there was little to no government attempt at setting up guidelines on how business owners should administer their employees. Taking advantage of the lack of governmental regulations, these businessmen were able to obtain massive amounts of money and power and leave their workers overworked and underpaid.…
- 1429 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
During the Gilded Age and Progressive Era, there has been various changes within our economy policy. The transition from the Gilded Age to the Progressive Era has shown how much our government’s influence in economics has changed throughout those years. In the Gilded Age, there was a widespread belief in monopolies and taking companies out of business. Although, in the Progressive Era, the government believed in encouraging competition in businesses and attacking trusts in order to do so. On the contrary, these eras also have some of the same economic policies due to it not being changed drastically. In all, these changes have helped build our economic policy we use today.…
- 802 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The Gilded age refers to the time after the Civil War Restoration period. The Gilded Age derived its name from the many great fortunes that were created during this period. The United States experienced a population and economic boom that led to the creation of an incredibly wealthy upper class during this time. It also created the middle class and more immigration contributed to this population boom. The era lasted from 1877 - 1893, then the market crash of 1893 caused a severe depression throughout the entire country. The country struggled to understand the new economic positions, which formed many different…
- 102 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The American Government was not doing its best to ensure domestic tranquillity or to promote general welfare. Major Industrialists of the time were not kept in check, and the working class citizen paid for it big time. Company towns, the presence of monopolies, and an inactive government all contributed to this threat to American Democracy.…
- 791 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
After the Civil War, many businessmen endorsed the Laissez-Faire concept of government in order to promote industry. In this concept, government did not interfere with industry. But what came with this concept was unlimited freedom for businessmen and high prices for consumers. While many businessmen supported a Laissez-Faire concept of government between 1865 and 1900, the people did not benefit from it, which led government to violate this concept with their policies, but only to a moderate extent overall. They violated laissez-faire to a moderate extent by issuing Railroad Land Grants before 1870 and eliminating them after, to a great extent by Regulating Interstate Commerce with the Interstate Commerce Act in 1886, and only to a limited extent by attempting to control trust activities with the Sherman Antitrust Act in 1890, producing a moderate government involvement overall.…
- 1339 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
The Gilded Age was a period where great wealth and industrialization was presented to the world, but under the surface and away from the eyes of the public lay poverty, crime, racism, and corruption. However, through scrutiny and investigation by “muckrakers” (journalists), these problems became revealed in what was known as the Progressive Era. During this time, reformers worked towards fixing the underlying issues of 19th century society. One major problem of the time was corruption; votes were manipulated, money stolen, and monopolies established on political systems and governments. Many reformers focused on this topic, with different opinions and techniques, and two major ones were Lincoln Steffens and Hiram Johnson.…
- 1142 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Because the Great Depression occurred during the term of Hoover, the public saw him starting his presidency as a liberal and ending it as a conservative. With the end of the Progressive Age in 1910, big businesses were a major success because men like Hoover had kept government from superseding the economy . These laissez-faire policies seemed particularly tolerant to the public, compared to the public-purpose policies sustained by Teddy Roosevelt. The revolutionary idea of the assembly line allowed buisnessmen like Ford to prosper, and this mass-production in America led to mass consumption; mostly of automobiles and appliances. The success of this "all-American" production method led to political support and confidence towards the liberal policies. On the other hand, even before the Great Depression, Hoover was leaning towards conservative ways. Hoover 's speeches show that he was not ready to be considered a full supporter of laissez-faire. He made it clear that he was less eager to save the capitalistic circle, stating that "businesses must be conducted with glass pockets."…
- 869 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Many Americans believed that the granting of special privileges and charters to private businesses violated republican principles because the special privileges violated the equal rights of all citizens and restricted the sovereignty of the people to shape governmental affairs and national development. The critics believed that the privileges given to private enterprises were schemes of an evident Anti-Republic tendency. Also, the voting rights increased for white men and the emerging middle class helped the nature of…
- 1406 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The economy itself changed greatly in the post Civil War era. The Industrial Revolution led to a new kind of big business. Now men like Carnegie, Rockefeller, and Vanderbilt had huge monopolies and trusts, making it nearly impossible for the common man to get ahead. Many government officials were bribed to make policies favorable to big business. Also, the power of the Presidents was a joke at this time. The US went through a period of nearly useless presidents, who turned a blind eye to corruption and bribery within their cabinets, Congress, and the House of Representatives. With protective tariffs on imports, and monopolies in industry, the common person was left with no choice but to pay whatever the businessmen charged. The government did little to stop the monopolies, and the unfair decisions the Supreme Court made regarding them, such as using the Fourteenth Amendment to say that industries were people, and therefore had the same property rights as people. The economy flourished under the government’s lack of action, but the common people were left in the dust. As the rich got richer, the poor got poorer.…
- 403 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
When the Reconstruction Era ended with the infamous Compromise of 1877, a new era known as the Gilded Age emerged. This time period was plagued with corruption, industrialization of the the North and urbanization by farmers and blacks. The United States boomed with industry and new businesses, but at the same time, it led to a great deal of political corruption and scandals. People who were already rich became richer while the poor became poorer trying to work in dreadful conditions. During the late 19th century, the presidents of this period were subservient to big business, a third party could triumph over America’s two-party system if the government became corrupt and they received enough supporters, and I believe the influence of big business…
- 1025 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays