Preview

Exploring the Idea of the Meaning of Art, as Being Dependent on the Maker's Intent

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1839 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Exploring the Idea of the Meaning of Art, as Being Dependent on the Maker's Intent
The meaning of a work of art/media//design is not fixed, whatever the intention of the maker. During the Renaissance the female nude became a popular subject for painters, said to glorify beauty, truth and love. However, history suggests that in a society unfamiliar with confrontation with female flesh, certain nudes were greeted with shock and disgust. In fact, some nude images may have even been created with pornographic intent. This essay will address the title 's statement using Titian 's 1538 Venus of Urbino, a painting which at various points throughout history has been dismissed as crass and pornographic, or celebrated as a seminal example of the Renaissance nude, incorporating a close reading of the piece as painting and cultural text. As Professor Rona Goffen states:

“It is not extravagantly hypothetical to imagine how much more direct an appeal such a picture must have made to the sexual responses of some sixteenth-century beholders."1 This painting proves that a piece of art is dependent on the context in which it is viewed, be it cultural, historical or even geographical. Its significance, function and 'meaning ' is constantly shifting. The true friction at this painting 's heart is in the contrasting definitions of art and pornography. This essay will address this friction, questioning whether it has any impact on the work 's overall importance.

Fig. 1 - Titian, The Venus of Urbino, 1538

1 Goffen, R. (1997) Titian 's Women. Yale: Yale University Press.

Before looking at its reception, it is vital to analyse the painting 's content. Based on Giorgione 's Sleeping Venus, a female nude clutches a bunch of roses, the symbol of Venus, but bears no other resemblance to the goddess. Reclining nudes are often portrayed with their eyes shut2, however Venus keeps her 's locked, unabashed and interacting with the viewer. A playful smile invites the viewer in, prompting speculation that the subject may not be the goddess, but a courtesan. If indeed



Bibliography: Dennis, K. (2009) A History of Seeing and Touching. Oxford: Berg Publishing Freedberg, D. (1989) The Power of Images: Studies in the History of Theory and Response. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Goffen, R. (1997) Titian 's Women. Yale: Yale University Press. ed. Goffen, R. (1997) Titian 's 'Venus of Urbino '. New York: Cambridge University Press. Scruton, R. (2009) Beauty. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Tinagli, P. (1997) Women in Italian Renaissance Art: Gender, Representation, Identity. Manchester: Manchester University Press. Twain, M. (1998) A Tramp Abroad. London: Penguin Classics. 12 Dennis, A History of Seeing and Touching

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The harsh lighting expels midtowns and shallow depth which emphasizes her nudity. The painting is supposedly modeled after Titans, Venus of Urbino, however, I consider it to be a mockery of Titans work. Titan presents a goddess while Manet presents a prostitute. Unlike Titan’s Venus, whose left hand entices the viewer and politely covers her genitals, Olympia’s left hand obstructs as if she was forcibly doing so. This is an interpretation of how she is not reliant on men. Manet also replaces the dog with a black cat which is another symbolization of prostitution. On another note, the size of this work is quite large for this sort of painting. Paintings at this stature should be portraying historical events, not what I see before me. In conclusion, this work should not be displayed in a gallery such as the…

    • 308 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    While the theories on the artist intent are of plenty, there is no mistaking that this piece provokes deeper contemplation on the depiction of beauty and the power of “ugly” imagery in this painting. One can argue that over vast time periods and amongst culture the defined interpretation of beauty has seen many profound depictions and interpretations displayed in infinite works of “beautiful” art. We must ask ourselves, can only works of “beauty” be aesthetically pleasing to the eye or can we find it in a variety of work through…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Looking at it from left to right, the viewer sees an older mustached man in a torn outfit that looks like he was a general, a naked woman sitting on a chair with floral print, and another naked woman looking to the side as if danger is approaching. All three have splatters of blood on them, contributing a grimy quality. The cuts of meat reminded me of the saying “I’m not a piece of meat” that is usually associated with feminism. The three people in the painting may feel as if they are considered as pieces of meat, simple objects, rather than unique and valued individuals. With folds of flesh compressing as their bodies lurch over, it is apparent that the bodies of the women are imperfect. They are naked, the unidealized and more realistic representation of the human body rather than nude, the idealized representation. What caught my attention was the way the woman in the middle started directly at the audience. This reminded me of the Luncheon on the Grass by Edouard Manet in 1860 where the female prostitute looks straight at the viewer. With a stern expression and hint at viewer involvement, the woman in Bermuda Lovers gazes intensely at the audience, perhaps it is a desperate cry for help, yet the onlookers, the viewers in the museum, do nothing but look back at her. In that way, the painting could be a commentary people’s lack of action toward wrongs and injustices. The…

    • 914 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Man’s view of man was changed due to the new style of art. In document A it compared two different paintings from two different time period to compare the different types of style art styles. In source one the painting “Madonna Enthroned Between two Angles”, by Duccio di Buoninsegna (Doc A), was done in a religious matter of what the church had wanted. The second source was the “Mona Lisa”, by Leonardo Da Vinci (Doc A), which showed a new type of art style which showed landscapes and three-dimensional figures. Art changed man’s view of man by showing new types of styles and artistic freedom.…

    • 495 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sandro Botticelli’s, The Birth of Venus, and Titian’s, Venus of Urbino are two paintings featuring the female nude, Venus as the main figure of the paintings. She is a classical representation of beauty and sensuality. Although these paintings have similar attributes such as the use of linear perspective, chiaroscuro, and their similar period style they have different hidden meanings. The Birth of Venus shows the story of how Venus came to be and portrays different gods and goddesses while in The Venus of Urbino, it is more of an allegory for marriage.…

    • 1102 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The essay is greatly grateful to the above mentioned historiography associated with discursive regulation of female sexuality in Found and contemporary moral paintings, Pre-Raphaelite typologies of women4, and the implications of the sensuality of Rossetti’s stunners. This essay seeks to understand how Rossetti’s broader work prescribed to and participated in the Victorian discursive regulation of sex; how desire operated within the paintings of his paintings, and how paintings work to frame and control female…

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The painting still receives much attention and is the base of discussion for many art lovers and historians (Mohan and Centeno, 2005). However, the very details that made the portrait so shocking nearly a century and a half ago are what now delight critics and casual viewers alike; the piece is truly remarkable in its contrasting hues and dramatic details. The lines are crisp and clean, the lighting is flattering yet dramatic, and the composition is pleasing to the eye. While these fundamental artistic components make a great contribution to the attractiveness of this painting, the subject herself deserves to be recognized as the most beautiful thing about the portrait. Gautreau’s physical beauty is often debated even today, mostly because her roman nose is considered too prominent to be classified as classically beautiful. The difference in opinion regarding Gautreau’s physical features is where most modern controversies end. It is the painting’s daring representation of Gautreau, rather, which is inarguably beautiful. The unorthodox pose, the revealing clothing, and the haughty expression were all revolutionary for the time they were presented. Sargent and Gautreau’s goal was not to challenge the societal norms of the time; in fact, their goal was the exact opposite. Inadvertently, however, the appreciation of Amelie Gautreau’s portrait one hundred and fifty years later is now a wonderful reminder of the power in breaking rules and refusing to fit into the definition of…

    • 1080 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Final Paper

    • 1446 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Art is one aspect of the past that has carried on for decades. Art in any form may it be poetry, novels, and playwright, sculpting as well as painting, has been an outlet for generations and continues to be an outlet and a means for expression. This paper will discuss “ The Mona Lisa” one of Da Vinci’s most famous paintings, as well as another great painting, Antonio Veneziano’s “Virgin and Child”(c. 1380). Both paintings focus on the human form and exhibit many variations of styles from lines, shading, color and possible meanings behind the work.…

    • 1446 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Once hung in a Medici villa, Sandro Botticelli’s The Birth of Venus, ca. 1485, is one of the most treasured artworks of the Renaissance. The composition is opened up more, compared to Botticelli’s Primavera, a similar styled painting done a few years prior. The central figure in this tempera painting is the goddess Venus (also known as Aphrodite in Greek mythology). She graces us with her presence by floating to the shore, pushed from the winds of gods (Zephyr accompanied by Chloris), on a seashell. A flower-clad woman, or Nymph, named Pomona reaches from the shore to cover Venus with a orange-coral floral cloak. With the gods in the left corner and Pomona on the right along with the trees and their leaves reaching towards Venus, they create…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    PartII The Middle Ages and Renaissance McGraw-Hill © 2006 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rig…

    • 1806 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Neoclassical Art Analysis

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This masterpiece was created by Jean Auguste Dominique Ingres in 1814 and is perfect example of Neoclassicism which was the revolt of the Rococo style of art. The artwork is placed in the Louvre Museum in Paris. This painting captures the image of an odalisque, which we refer to as a concubine. The painting depicts beautiful hues of blue, and a dark background and shadows which creates a seductive scenery while enhancing the curves and shapes of the model. With the contrast of light and dark colors, Ingres was able to achieve the illusion of depth. Ingres favored long sinuous lines which is show through the way he painted her elongated back. The volumes of the nude, bathed in an even light, are toned down in a space without depth (Louvre). I also like the details of his work, from the detailed headpiece, jewelry, feather duster and even the designs strategically placed on the curtains. Ingres was highly criticized for his art work and his paintings were unpopular due to others not understanding his…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The piece of Art, Smiling Girl, a Courtesan Holding an Obscene Image, painted by Gerrit van Honthorst in 1625 can be seen at the Saint Louis Art Museum. I was initially drawn to this image from across the gallery mostly due to the subject’s bright red dress with gold sleeves, it was one of the brightest colored images in the gallery. It is about three feet tall and two feet wide, it is an oil on canvas painting. As I approached the image, I was still intrigued as the image she is holding is of a naked man facing away, the subject in the painting seems to get enjoyment from this. To me this piece of art makes me curious, I want to know who this woman was and why she is holding that image. The artist seems to be communicating the importance of…

    • 1404 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    The nudity of Venus has a link to Eve in the Garden of Eden. This has led some commentators to speculate whether Venus is a personification of the Christian Church. It is a fact that in acient times that the title of the Virgin Mary was "stella maris": star of the sea. Perhaps Botticellis was only trying to make a statement but this statement caused chaos in the…

    • 1550 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Art 101 Chapter2

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The reaction of the public was that of not understanding what the artists were trying to convey. They did not understand that Marcel Duchamp’s Nude Descending a Staircase, was based on the concept of motion. In Michelangelo’s David he was making a political statement. In both works of art, part of what viewers found objectionable about them was that they (the public) did not understand what the works represented. In Michelangelo’s David, the public saw nudity. Other people saw politics and religion were being attacked. In Duchamps painting, the public I think, partially responded to the paintings name, and they did not understand that the painting was not actually of a nude person but was a “series of photographs by Etienne-Jules Marey, representing motion. The objects in the photographs were fully clothed. Etienne-Jules Marey’s photographs that went on to bring about the invention of the motion picture” (Sayre, p. 45, 2010). When I first looked at the painting of Nude Descending a Staircase, I did not see anything in it that gave me any idea of what the picture was about. On looking closer and reading the information about it, my opinion changed. I learned that his painting did have meaning, and that it had nothing to do with nude people. The motion pictures came from the work of Etienne-Jules Marey, and Duchamp saw the meaning and importance of his work.…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Censorship in Writing

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Throughout the essay the writer places emphasis on many of his personal opinions, while also implanting his critiques aimed toward the opposition who perceive a view of public nudity as inappropriate and unfit for the presence of the general public. He presents the quandary at hand, whether the sight of the nude statues should befall upon any passerby, who represent the general public be it adult or child, or be restricted to only those that wish to “taint” themselves in the statue’s presence. He is clearly seen describing his viewpoint of the statues which he labels as art, being a masterpiece radiating beauty.…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays