Preview

Examples Of Identity In Housekeeping

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2489 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Examples Of Identity In Housekeeping
The Exploration of a Transient Identity
Themes such as isolation and transience are vividly portrayed through the characters present in Marilynne Robinson’s novel Housekeeping. The novel follows the lives of sisters Ruth and Lucille Stone, whose father deserts their family too early for them to remember and whose mother commits suicide around six years later. The sister were neglected in their childhood, the family that surrounded them did not want to care for them and they became isolated from any support system beyond whatever adult could be persuaded to look after them. When Ruth and Lucille aunt Sylvie returns to Fingerbone, Idaho to look after the sisters, she presents an unfamiliar lifestyle that ultimately changes their relationship as well as their standards of living. Ruth’s transformation from a dependent sister to a transient separates her
…show more content…
While she and Sylvie are only dead in a metaphorical sense, they are still “dead to the ‘other world’ that Lucille and all the townspeople presumably still inhabit” (Toles 127). This appearance of death to the outside world causes Ruth to assert that she is, in fact, dead (Robinson 217). Death to the outside world, for Ruth, equates death to self. And through this death to her self, Ruth has eliminated the need for her physical body. Ruth’s mind has also become invisible to her body and purged the need for it. Towards the end of the novel she begins to give up eating and drinking. “What have I to do with these ceremonies of sustenance, of nurturing?” she inquires (Robinson 214). Her body has become an accessory to her mind, an accessory she no longer feels a need for. Caver also acknowledges this saying, “Not only has she lost voice and identity, but her very corporeality is uncertain” (130). Through this diminishing need for a body, Ruth has become consciously invisible not only to the outside world, but also to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    After a brief stint of trying to show the town that she is in fact, suitable to take care of Ruthie, Sylvie does what everyone else in the family does: decides to run away. Initially, they decide to burn down their house and fake their death; with no thought of how Lucille will feel. But, when that doesn’t work, Sylvie and Ruthie decide to go the one way no one will follow, “‘Cross the bridge’”(210). The mood when they cross the bridge is completely away from their thoughts. Not a single time does it mention them reminiscing on their lives or who they’ll miss. All that is cogitated by Ruthie is imagery of her surrounding such as, “We stepped on every other [railroad] tie, although that made our stride uncomfortably long, because stepping on every tie made it uncomfortably short”(211). This really shows that they believe running away from your problems is ok because not only does she not think about how she’s jilting her sister into thinking her dead but also has the audacity to think about how far apart her steps are.…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    My book Gathering Blue by Lois Lowry was about a girl named Kira who lives in community where things are very weird. Kira had just become an orphan recently when her mother died of the flu. Since her mother died of the flu they had to burn down Kira’s house. Kira came to the grounds where her house was, and started to rebuild when a large women comes in and tells her she doesn’t own this space any more because her mother is dead and with Kira’s messed up leg she is useless, so they are taking her house and are going to build a place for the children. Kira says that she owns the space and refuses to move.…

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Children of the Dust

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The book is split into three parts, the first detailing the life of Sarah, a young teenage girl who lives through the nuclear war with her family and what they must do to survive. It shows the struggles of a family trying to survive the nuclear fallout, how they must change how they live, the food they eat and the way they interact with each other. Sarah’s story brings to light how hard it would be to live in a world that had suffered a nuclear war and the horror that would be a constant in your life. It details how Sarah must overcome the awkward relationship with her stepmother to try and ensure her family’s survival. Sarah’s little sister, Catherine, has a very strong instinct to survive, she makes a cubby under the table, will only eat canned food and drink bottled water that had no chance of contamination. Catherine is the only family member to survive.…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Glass Castle by Jeannette Walls is a memoir relaying the young life of the author as she struggles to live through poverty with her family. As he gradually ages throughout the book, Jeannette has to face the hardships of a normal growing girl while also facing problems that go on behind closed doors. Walls gives the reader hard-to-read tales of growing up, acting as a parent figure to her younger siblings due to neglect, and trying to keep the family financially stable. At the same time, as she ages and becomes more mature, she tries to break free from her familial roots and move to New York. Once it seems like Jeannette and her siblings have their chance to get out and move to New York, their parents follow them there and decided to live on the streets without a home. Now Walls and her siblings, whom have all moved on, must…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The narrative is told from the perspective of Leroy Moffitt, a recent disabled truck driver. Although the injury leads him to sit home all day like a bored housewife, he pursues his hobby that is stereo typically feminine. He constructs craft objects from kits and sews needlepoint pillows, as a pleasurable interest. However, he dreams of building a log cabin for his wife from one of his craft kit models, which symbolically portrays their marriage. The cabin is an unrealistic idea, and the project does not interest Norma Jean. Despite the fact that nothing dissuades him, he won’t let go of the idea of the cabin in the face of strong opposition that he won’t give up on his marriage in the face of clear evidence that his wife already has. Leroy sooner or later realizes that his marriage is as hollow as the boxy interior of their log cabin. Apart from Leroy’s lack of realization that his wife wants to adapt to her surroundings, and progress with her life, he is still stuck in the past and continues to pester his wife of living in an old log cabin. However, as Leroy builds craft kits and smokes marijuana all day, Norma Jean supports her and her husband by working at a Rexall drugstore. She eventually goes from a weightlifting class to a night composition class, reconstructing her mind and body and doing her best to adapt to change. In the meantime, Leroy resisting to do the same, is happy to be home…

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    stories that made her childhood unique. This book is a memoir of the interesting and talented Jeannette Walls. The second chapter of the book begins with her, as a three year old, burning herself severely when making hotdogs for herself. I think that chapter just sets the tone of the story. Her crazy life was not so perfect even when she forced herself to believe it could be worse. How can it be worse when you have no money, a worn down home, and nothing to eat? Her family was constantly struggling with money and her father was an alcoholic. Jeannette’s mom was capable of working, but was just lazy. She and her siblings had to really survive on their own.…

    • 1751 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The image of home life in Why I live at the P.O, Eudora Welty depicts the damage to one’s feelings of self worth in response to the sense of belonging in a family. Sister, who is the narrator in Why I live at the P.O.,(Welty) is disturbed when her sister, Stella Rondo returns homes with an adopted child, Shirley-T, after separating from her husband (Welty). Sister has lived in her sister’s, Stella Rondo’s shadow her entire life. Over the years, resentment and jealously has manifested in Sister towards her sister Stella Rondo. The rest of the family is delighted to see Stella Rondo and the child. Sister makes the assumption that Shirley-T is the biological child of Stella and her husband (Welty). The story is told from Sisters twisted point of view seeking sympathy from her readers. As the story begins, she immediately builds her case against her family revealing past hurt, judgment, and jealousy which cause the family to have a communication break down throughout the entire story. In Why I live at the P.O., Eudora Welty uses diction,…

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In most families children look for guidance parents, in the memoir The Glass Castle written by Jeannette Walls, the opposite seems to hold true. Jeannette and her siblings were given virtually no rules to follow, or standards to be held to. They were often dirty, hungry, and left to fend for themselves by their self proclaimed “excitement addict” parents. Luckily Walls was able to turn potential tragedy to triumph by using her common sense when it mattered the most. Usually characters develop during the duration of a book, but Walls remains the same throughout.…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The physical struggles mentioned above also come together to form the large struggle of finaical insecurity. Walls expresses in the novel that she along with the rest of her family went without food for weeks because of the lack of funds. Jeannette describes a scence where in her elementary school bathroom she would pick out the leftover food that the other children would throw out. Jeannette shows her lack of understanding when her peers “tossed away all this perfectly good food; apples, hard-boiled eggs, packages of peanut-butter crackers, sliced pickles, half-pint cartons of milk, cheese sandwiches with just one bite taken out because the kid didn’t like the pimentos in the cheese” (173). She points out that sometimes there was more food in the trash then she could of eaten, this is when she begins to take some of the food to her brother to ensure that he was eating as well, but she does not take any home for her mother. With the state of the Walls’ finaicial insecurity comes the the undeniable fact that they were unable to pay rent. Therefore the Walls family moved quite often to avoid the bill collecters or as her father…

    • 1140 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    By examining the setting of the house, one can see that Perkins-Stetson wrote this story to demonstrate how the narrator feels when trapped and suffocated in a society that constrains and inflicts hardship on women and the sick. The narrator describes the house as a haunted house as they arrive, as it is a mansion that is set apart from the road, village, and society around it, giving off a feeling of isolation and abandonment. From the scratches and gouges on the floor, the bed being nailed to the floor, to the isolation from the world makes it a creepy haunted house where something is bound to go wrong. She describes the shady trees and bushes surrounding the house further enclosing it from the outside world and creating the image of a prison, where she is locked in. The fingernail markings on the floor and bite marks on the bed indicate…

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Distinctively Visual

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There is a sense of isolation in the description of the Drovers Wife, a sense that she and her family are cut off from the rest of the world also that the house they live in reflects this sparseness.…

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The old house saw the rearing of four brothers and their adopted sister. However, one of these days it, too, will give way and it will no longer be home to those who hold it in their fondest memories. But, of course, an empty house is no longer a home. It’s just the place or the house where home used to be. What remains are the lives of those who were touched by those dear ones who lived there.…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When Eleanor, a sensitive woman who spent the past ten years reluctantly caring for an ailing mother who banged on the wall all night long, arrives at Hill House, she hates it. Why doesn’t she just leave? Pride. Plus, she has nowhere else to go. “‘But I can’t leave,’ Eleanor said, laughing still because it was so perfectly impossible to explain… ‘The house wants me to stay,’ she told the…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jeannette Walls

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This story is about Jeannette Walls and how her family must travel and live in poverty. She had to live in rundown houses and sometimes didn’t have a house at all, at one point she had to live the wild desert and wrote about how she loved to sleep under the stars. Her dad throughout her life was an alcoholic and would disappear for days at a time and would come home and verbally abuse the wife and sometimes children.…

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Traditionally in the mid twentieth century, women held various duties that were crucial to keep their households intact. Most have sacrificed much of their freedom and independence to nourish their family. Women were accountable for food, cleaning, support, and other motherly resources. The novel revealed Susan's transformation from the beginning of the novel as a calm and tranquil mother into a strange and insane person. Matthew and her children depended on her to provide for their everyday necessities and without her the family will not function properly. The burden forced upon Susan caused her excessive desire for peace and serenity in the most remote place she can find. In "To Room Nineteen", Lessing describes how stress and anxiety linked to Susan's mental illness.…

    • 1718 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics