Evaluate Singers and Descartes Arguments About Animals.

Topics: Soul, Animal rights, Mind Pages: 4 (1200 words) Published: October 25, 2007
In this essay I will evaluate the arguments by Descartes about animals which he uses in order to verify his arguments on the immortality of the soul. In turn I will evaluate the more contemporary arguments of Peter Singer put forward mainly in his book ‘Animal Liberation.'

The concept of animal sanctity branches as far back as one can imagine. In ancient times animals were considered to have intelligence and even a language all of their own. This was an early view on animals stemming from pre-agrarian living which is commonly seen to have little significance in today's debate. Somewhere along the way animals lost their position of sentience and this is reflected in the arguments of Descartes that will be discussed later. In Descartes arguments he carefully denies animals the kind of intelligence that is attributable in most cases to human beings. Around this time the historical debate over animal sanctity lost its supposition that animals may have a degree of intelligence over human beings.

The debate was now placed for the question whether animals, being with or without intelligence, deserve a degree of rights, and if so what degree of rights do they deserve? This question is what Peter Singer grapples with today, and which I will discuss in the second part of this essay.

Descartes begins his argument about the soul by comparing the human body to machines and animals. Here he says that machines and animals both have something in common, as animals and humans have something also in common. Animals and humans on the one hand have what he terms the ‘animal spirits' which control bodily organs, movements and involuntary actions. While animals and machines share that they may appear to be thinking but do not actually think. He writes that "if any such machines had the organs and outward shape of a monkey…we should have no means of knowing that they did not possess entirely the same nature as animals." 1. (1)

So one is left here to make ones own...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Descartes Essay
  • Descartes Dream Argument Essay
  • Essay about Wax Argument Descartes
  • Descartes' Arguments for the Existence of God Essay
  • Descartes' First Trademark Argument Essay
  • Descartes Essay
  • Descartes Argument of God Essay
  • Descartes Man vs Animal Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free