Ethical Reasoning

Good Essays
Topics: Ethics, Morality
Ethical Reasoning In ethical reasoning, the Trolley Problem is an excellent example of what most people find to be ethical and unethical. Unfortunately, there is really no right answer. However, the most common answers to the two Trolley Scenarios are: it is ethical to pull the lever, but it is unethical to push the very large person. In the scenario of having to pull the level and kill one person verses killing five people, most people’s reaction is to pull the level. This was also my reaction. The ethical reasoning behind this is based on the Teleological or Consequentialist principles, which focuses on the outcome or end result of a decision (Fritzsche, 2005). Whether a person acted in a morally right or wrong way depends solely upon the consequences of the act. In this scenario, more people benefited from the action because their lives were saved, thereby making it ethical based on the teleological or consequentialist principles. In the scenario of having to push the very large person and killing one person verses killing five people, most people’s reaction is that it is unethical to do such a thing. This was also my reaction. The ethical reasoning behind this is based on the Deontological or Nonconsequentialist principles, which consist of a set of rules – it can be generally classified as either rights or justice based (Fritzche, 2005). A person uses the set of rules to make ethical decisions based on logic and one’s duty. In this scenario, it is both unethical and illegal to knowingly and intentionally cause the death of an innocent person or any person for that matter, regardless of the situation. For some people, the two scenarios can be overwhelming, as well as confusing. In the first scenario, it is ethical to pull the lever and cause the death of one person opposed to doing nothing and causing the death of five people. Like the old saying, “the needs of the many outweigh the needs of one” (Meyer & Sowards, 1982). On the flip


References: Fritzsche, D. J. (2005). Business ethics: a global and managerial perspective (2nd ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill Companies. Meyer, N. (Writer/Director), Sowards, J. B. (Writer), Bennett, H., Phillips, W. F., & Sallin, R. (Producers). (1982). Star trek II: the wrath of khan [Motion picture]. United States: Paramount Pictures.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Ethical Reasoning

    • 6656 Words
    • 27 Pages

    Hyderabad (IMT,HYD), 2015 9 -6 1 0 -0 5 0 REV: DECEMBER 2, 2011 SANDRA J. SUCHER NIEN-HÊ HSIEH A Framework for Ethical Reasoning Introduction This note will present a practical framework for ethical reasoning, in other words, a set of questions to help you assess the ethical implications of a course of action. While many of us believe that we approach such assessments with all of our reasoning powers at the ready, we actually first come to moral judgments with instinct and emotion – a nearly instantaneous…

    • 6656 Words
    • 27 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Ethical Reasoning

    • 1862 Words
    • 8 Pages

    1. Introduction Moral reasoning is defined as “individual or collective practical reasoning about what, morally, one ought to do”. The theory introduces two moral principles: consequentialist principle, which determines an act’s morality by its consequences, and categorical principle, which assesses an act by looking at its certain duties and rights despite the outcomes. To some extent, these two principles seem to contradict each other, which may become obstacles for achieving reasonable actions…

    • 1862 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Ethical Reasoning

    • 2266 Words
    • 10 Pages

    This has led many to define justice in such a way that it includes the obligation to narrow the inequities between rich and poor. This has been done in a number of ways. One approach, like Nozick's, does not focus on equality of results, the actual distribution of society's goods, but on equality of opportunity. Unlike Nozick's, however, it recognizes that many are impeded in their ability to participate in the life of society and share in its benefits by factors that, while they may not be the result…

    • 2266 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    NS, INC. STRATEGIES FOR ETHICAL REASONING Release Date: March, 2012 Capsim Ethics Plug-in: Identifying the Options In hindsight, it is always easier to see how we might have done things differently. How can ethical reasoning help us identify what our options might be before we act and evaluate which of those options might be the most appropriate course of action? Like most academic disciplines, the study of ethics is charged with energetic debate. The ethical principles traditionally applied…

    • 2456 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    corporation often come across and have to deal with on the job ethical issues. “Ethics is a conception of right and wrong conduct. Ethical business behavior is demanded by business stakeholders, enhances business performance, complies with legal requirements, prevents or minimizes harm, and promotes personal morality” (Lawrence and Weber 2011). Ethic issues occur in all areas of business and at all levels of business management. I believe that ethical problems occur for certain reasons one being the selfishness…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Fair-mindedness is the human tendency to reason in a self-serving or self-deluded manner. UNDERSTANDING ETHICAL REASONING: Ethical principles are not a matter of subjective preference. All reasonable people are obligated to respect clear-cut ethical concepts and principles. To reason well through ethical issues, we must know how to apply ethical concepts and principles reasonably to those issues. Ethical concepts and principles should be distinguished from the norms and taboos of society and peer group…

    • 1677 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    and development of ethical theories; and also the systematic study of right and wrong, good and evil. These concepts and theories will then be applied to contemporary managerial dilemmas. Topic 1. Moral Reasoning and Ethical Theory LEARNING OUTCOMES By the end of this topic, you should be able to: 1. Explain the five factors involved in the formation of individual ethics; 2. Explain normative philosophy and ethical relativism; 3. Compare all the major ethical systems; and 4. Apply…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Critical Thinking and Ethical Reasoning Jennifer Browning ETH 316 April 2, 2015 Professor Peter Fortuna Critical thinking and ethical reasoning are not far on the scale of relevance to one another. In ethical reasoning we look at two scenarios: are we harming ourselves or someone else OR are we bettering ourselves or someone else? Humans tend to do what is best for themselves whether not they could be hurting someone else. They do not typically look at the big picture or the consequence…

    • 676 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Short Incidents for Ethical Reasoning Tiger Woods Thesis: In my opinion, corporate sponsors should apply their ethical standards to celebrity endorsers. Rule: Ethics is the study of good and evil, right and wrong, and just and unjust. The Disclosure Rule tests ethical decisions and behaviors by asking one to consider how you would feel if you had to explain the decision or action to a wider audience. (pg. 197/ pg. 243) Explanation: Ethical behavior requires many different aspects of behavior…

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Describe the situation at Lehman Brothers from an ethics perspective. What’s your opinion of what happened there? The ethical issue here was that Lehman’s executives exploited loopholes in the accounting standards to manipulate their balance sheet in order to mislead the investing public. Using “Repo 105”, Lehman was able to clear huge amount unprofitable assets off its balance sheet instead of selling at loss. Evidence pointed out that the chief executive, Richard Ruld, knew about the use of…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays