Ethical Dilemma

When faced with an ethical dilemma, it is often difficult to determine the best course of action. First, one must determine whether the dilemma is “right versus right” or “right versus wrong.” Right versus right dilemmas “are genuine dilemmas precisely because each side is firmly rooted in one of our basic, core values” (Kidder, R., 2009). On the other hand, Right versus wrong dilemmas set one apart from another, leaving no room for a resolution and can consist of lying, cheating, stealing, etc.
In regards to the ethical dilemma between Mr. Stevens and his Nurse Practitioner Sophia, I believe this is a “right versus right” dilemma. The primary dilemma is Mr. Stevens is in denial that he is depressed and refuses to speak with a mental health professional. Sophia sees that Mr. Stevens is showing the signs that he is indeed depressed. Mr. Stevens does not want to burden his family and is more withdrawn,
Stevens. In my opinion, Sophia has a few options. She can first speak with Mr. Stevens regarding her concerns and potentially provide him with education about depression, with the following resources: a support group, introduce the idea of speaking with his family members, or even providing him with medication to help with his depression. If this does not work, she could then involve Mr. Stevens’ cardiologist and primary care physician, and speak with them regarding Mr. Stevens current situation, her concerns, and what the next step should be.
In conclusion, I believe that the “right versus right” dilemma paradigm fits this ethical dilemma. I feel as though Sophia is focused on the two paradigms presented above of a practice-based model, truth versus loyalty and justice versus mercy. Sophia is looking out for Mr. Stevens best interest and I believe that by using a practice based model a resolution can be made that would benefit Mr.