Et Tubes vs Lma

Topics: Endotracheal tube, Laryngeal mask airway, Intubation Pages: 8 (2261 words) Published: May 10, 2006
1 Intro
Since adequate breathing is always a first goal in supportive care or crisis rescue, it is essential in health care to establish a patent passage from the patient's mouth to their lungs in order for the patient to survive. This airway ensures unobstructed breathing for basic support or cardio-pulmonary resuscitation (CPR). There are two devices that are most commonly used and each device has specific indications and contraindication. 2 Research question

This study was done to answer the following question: Are licensed practitioner's beliefs about airways (oral ET-tube and LMA) consistent with the current printed information and do they report using the airways in a similar manner? To answer this question, we first needed to know what practices the current published studies have suggested will have better out-comes and less side affects. We also needed to find out; are practitioners aware of the evidence-based practices that are currently published and have they had any continuing education about airway management? Does the location where the practitioner performs airway management impact their practices? Are their decisions based on departmental policy or do they decide on their own which device to use? Does the medical specialty in which they practice or the number of years in their field impact their practices or predetermine their knowledge of the devices. 3 Literature Review

The first device is an oral endotracheal Tube (oral ET-tube). It consists of a thin-walled tube with a balloon near the distal end that seals the airway and a connection on the proximal end, which enables connection to resuscitation devices. The tube is inserted past the patient's epiglottis, through the patient's vocal chords using a laryngoscope. The laryngoscope is an "L" shaped tool with a light source at the end that is used to lift and open the patient's epiglottis so that the practitioner can visualize the ET tube passing through the vocal chords into the trachea. The balloon is inflated to seal the airway and prevent aspiration of gastric contents.

The second device is a Laryngeal-Mask Airway (LMA). It is a thin-walled tube connected to an inflatable elliptical shaped device that is inserted into the laryngeal airway. The epiglottis is usually free floating within the mask and does not obstruct the airway. When inflated, the mask fills and seals the upper airway and pushes the tongue forward. The thin walled tube exits the patient's airway and allows connection to resuscitation devices.

Current practice involves using the oral ET-tube as the standard for airway care. The manufacturer's manual for the LMA device also recommends that the oral ET-tube be the first choice for airway management due to the potential risk of regurgitation and aspiration when using an LMA. But a southeastern US study found that previous reports of aspiration while using the LMS device were exaggerated and in some regions, the LMA has replaced some of the other devices for airway management. (1999, Martin) The LMA is reserved for airways that are anatomically difficult to insert an oral ET-tube. (2005, LMA North America, Inc) A study in Philadelphia reinforced the use of the LMA device in difficult airways after being successful in establishing an airway in 68% of patients who had previously experienced a failed intubation. (1998, Parmet)

The LMA device is also contraindicated in patients that have a fixed pulmonary compliance or require high pressures to ventilate due to the LMA devices poor ability to seal the airway in this situation. Indicators that this may be happening could be an assessment that effective ventilation is not happening and/or signs that the patient is having difficulty oxygenating. In these cases it is important assess and correct the problem quickly. (2005, LMA North America, Inc) The LMA airway is easier to use, requiring less training than the oral ET-tube. This may be important after two studies; one from Florida...

Cited: Sources
LMA North America, Inc. LMA airway instructional Manual. San Diego, Ca.: 2005
Parmet JL., The Laryngeal mask airway reliably provides rescue ventilation in cases of unanticipated difficult tracheal intubation along with difficult mask ventilation. Anesth Analg 1998 Sept; 87:661-665
Martin SE et al., Use of the laryngeal mask airway in air transport when intubation fails. J Trauma 1999 Aug; 47:352-357
Katz SH and Falk JL., Misplaced endotracheal tubes by paramedics in an urban emergency medical services system. Ann Emerg Med 2001 Jan; 37:32-37
Jones JH at al. Emergency physician-verified out0of-hospital intubation: Miss rates by paramedics. Acad Emerg Med 2004 June; 11:707-9
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • You Tube vs Boob Tube Essay
  • Is vs It Essay
  • Special Purpose Endotracheal Tubes Essay
  • Phlebotomy Tubes Essay
  • The Feeding Tube Essay
  • Essay on Feeding Tube
  • Feeding Tubes Essay
  • Tubes and Drains Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free