Preview

essay “Does America Still Exist?” by Richard Rodriguez

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
468 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
essay “Does America Still Exist?” by Richard Rodriguez
Santiago Izquierdo

ENGL 150H- Essay #1

09/12/14

In the short essay "Does America Still Exist?" by Richard Rodriguez, the primary inquiry is found by plainly considering the title. This question is much deeper than what some might consider it to be. In order to even begin to consider this interrogation, Rodriguez must first define "America". In his opinion, the main cornerstone of this country is the unity and welcomeness in which it was created. After defeating the might British in order to become independent, the solidarity among the victors begot the American core. "We pledge allegiance to diversity. America was born Protestant and bred Puritan, and the notion of community we share is derived from a seventeenth-century faith". (Paragraph 7) America has been immensely diverse throughout its short time in history. This is where Rodriguez is puzzled. If this great nation is diverse and the American citizens have defined themselves as hospitable, then how come there are vast amounts racism and immigration headaches? Has the nation lost its true identity and finally given up on trying to assimilate "foreigners"?

This latter half of this dissertation is very similar to Guillermo Gómez-Peña's essay "Documented/ Undocumented". Gómez-Peña focuses on the different manner immigrants are viewed once they arrive in America and the evolution that an immigrant has in America. Rodriguez expands on this topic as he expresses the ways immigrant children are changed in schools and are "assimilated into gringo society". (Paragraph 12) This transformation is frowned upon the parents of these children since their offspring do not resemble the children that immigrated into America and they have lost the identity that traces back to their native land. Rodriguez also mentions how he feels that he became like his classmates(i.e. became Polish, Italian) while his classmates reciprocally assimilated a little into his Hispanic heritage. I can definitely relate to this assumption since in

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The analysis gives an account of the migratory reasons of immigrants to the United States. These individuals left for economic reasons that were also promoted not only by family members on the US side of the border but also because of popular culture. Many came to the United States in hopes of the American dream but as we see in Leo Chavez’s book, although this population integrates itself economically, culturally, and socially into the United States society, much of the time their legal status becomes a determining factor of how much or how fully they will incorporate themselves. We see that it is very hard for them to incorporate themselves and assimilate as their citizenship status hinders their ability to attain necessary resources. The issue then becomes generational as the opportunities of immigrants will be different then those of their children and their future generations in the United States. We see that initiatives like The Bracero Program had previously allowed immigration for labor purposes during World War II but as economic insecurity began to grow, the upward movement became an outlet for possible upward economic mobility. This transnational movement created a phenomenon that established networks for the immigrant community. This networks also made it harder for this community to consider re-establishment in their native countries as…

    • 1633 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Se Habla Espanola

    • 640 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Barrientos audiences are anyone who struggles with fitting in society just she do. When Barrientos expressed her disagreement of American society’s alleged of Latino being Mexican to her father, he sent her on a vacation to Mexico and after seeing how beautiful Mexico is, adjusted Barrientos negative understanding of Hispanics. “I found out that he was right, I loved the music, the art, and the architecture. “He’d planted a seed of pride, but it would take years for me to figure out how to nurture it” (85). Barrientos limitation of speaking Spanish hinders her bonding with her origin because Spanish aside from English was a way that Latinos connected. Barrientos was left questioning how she would fit in as Latino if she could not speak proper Spanish.…

    • 640 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Born in a Mexican immigrant family and moving to a city in California, Sacramento, Rodriguez had already known from the start that he’s “different” from the rest of the children in the area. He was hispanic. He felt the difference expressively at school and it was not just because of his physical appearance. The difference of is what isolated him the most. They differed socially. He felt a disconnect between Spanish, the language he used at home which offered comfort, versus English, the language used in the public world which to him was foreign. Rodriguez felt the separation from his English-speaking classmates, as he struggled to master this “public” language and hopefully gain acceptance. Since its founding days, U.S. had always been a melting pot of diverse ethnicities. Welcoming newcomers while insisting they learn and embrace its civic culture. It was suggested that those who come here in America should become Americans. Upon entering grade school, it was a massive culture shock for Rodriguez. He was put in an ESL class expected to learn English, to speak English, and communicate in English, but of course in a “English as a Secondary language” setting. It was a challenging transition, however, with practice, Rodriguez began to slowly adopt the English language giving him and his…

    • 1207 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Best Essays

    The year is 1776. In an act of defiance of the oppressive rule of the powerful nation of Great Britain, the political leaders of the British-American colonies sign into existence the United States of America. Even before this inception of the United States, North America had been seen as a place where one could move to start a new life and reap the full rewards for one’s work. These opportunities combined with the new United States government founded on the ideals of freedom and equity have attracted countless families from all over the world, making the United States truly a country of immigrants. Immigrants from European nations coming to America both assimilated and helped to shape the culture of the nation. Others, either immigrants or those forced to come to the United States, were marked with distinguishable differences from the European majority. The Africans and Asians are examples of some of these minorities, but, in my belief, one of the groups that has had the most unique struggle to become part of the ‘great melting pot’ of America is the Latino culture. For many different reasons Latin Americans have struggled to assimilate with the American culture for hundreds of years.…

    • 1291 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    As a son of Mexican American immigrants, Richard Rodriguez recounts the story of his childhood and his struggle to assimilate into American culture. In Aria: A memoir of a Bilingual Childhood, Rodriguez always felt like an outcast whenever he set foot outside of his house. As a young child, he exclusively spoke Spanish to members of his household and tried his best to learn and speak English in the real world. He “regarded Spanish as a private language. It was a ghetto language that deepened and strengthened [his] feeling of public separateness” (Rodriguez 505) because it identified him as a member of his family and it served as a link to his own Mexican heritage. By speaking Spanish, he communicates a certain level of intimacy with all of his relatives. However, as his narrative progresses, he finds himself slowly breaking away from that intimacy as he begins to speak more English, both by force and social pressure. Teachers scolded him if he spoke anything but English and his peers Americanized his name into Richard (rather than calling him Ricardo.) He began to feel like a traitor by mastering this “public language” when his relatives began treating him differently. His bilingual childhood was an enormous adversity that Rodriguez had to overcome.…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Suárez-Orozco, Marcelo and Mariela M. Páez. Latinos: Remaking America. Berkeley: University of California Press. 1997.…

    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    America’s national identity was complex during the 1800’s; nationalism was a powerful force, but a sectional force nonetheless. 19th century America was, what historian Robert Wiebe called “a society of island communities”.[i] The remarkable transformations that characterized the 19th century both unified and divided the Republic in its early years. Political upheaval, economic transformation, technological advances and social and religious reform led to both desired and unexpected changes. There was no single unifying force that brought the nation together. Instead, there existed a number of beliefs and movements that all Americans supported to some degree.…

    • 1664 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    For the Latinos coming to America, it’s something life changing as many people leave behind their love ones, normal environment, and a piece of themselves. A culture change happens as immigrants risk their lives to come to America. Mora points out the effects of Acculturation as low-income Latinos move into urban areas with harmful conditions that contribute to the risk to the Latinos health. Mora looks at a study done…

    • 288 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The story that I chose to write about was “One Big Happy Family,” by Anndee Hochman. The story is about a young woman whose family life seemed to be the American dream, for those of us looking in from the outside. Her family owned a house in the city like most of us and a house on the beach. The house on the beach was unique with its architecture anomalies, which made the house more a mix and match of parts than like her normal home in the city. The whole family, including relatives from afar, would gather there during the summer to spend time with each other. When in actuality behind her family’s unity, was a demand for conformity to her family’s way of life and thinking. The author finally realized that in order for her to find happiness she had to look within herself and learn to listen to her feelings. Once she learns this lesson, she will be able to break the bounds of her family’s conformity and find the peace of mind that she has always longed for. Several of the stories throughout this chapter discuss different myths of “One Big Happy Family,” however it all seems to come back to the individual, and what they believe in.…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When thinking about immigration, most individuals imagine all different types of ethnic groups traveling to a separate land away from their own. Most imagine America. Immigration, throughout history, has occurred within all types of ethnicities. When taking a closer look at the individuals living in America, it is apparent that everyone is not exactly like one another. Assimilation becomes a popular word used when discussing migration, and both positives and negatives come along with it. Two theorists that discuss the meaning of assimilation in their writings are Stephen Steinberg in his book, Ethnic Myth, and Milton Gordon in his book Assimilation in American Life. They discuss issues regarding assimilation and how they affect the nation as a whole. A novel written by Chang-Rae Lee titled, Native Speaker, gives specific examples as to how the assimilation process affects others and the migrants themselves, as also described in both Steinberg and Gordon’s books.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As far back as the 1800’s, America has been defined as a nation of immigrants, or a “melting pot”. During this century, millions of foreign-born people entered the ports of the United States, seeking work, political refuge, and religious freedom. Immigrants from Europe came in massive waves. As immigration rates increased, a group now known as nativists emerged, who, although of European stock, antagonized the newer Irish Catholic immigrants. Examining the opposition towards Irish immigrants furthers our understanding of nativists’ idea of their ‘American’ community by revealing what this sentiment was based on and why. As seen in political cartoons of the age, Irish Catholic immigrants were presented as and consequently viewed as threats to the national community based on the principle that America’s exceptionalism was founded on its powerful ideals set by the first European Protestants in the colonial period. This principle is essential to understand, as it has a continuing influence in American foreign policy to this day. The ideals held by the nativists were embellished with powerful titles such as “Protestantism”, “republicanism”, etc. but remained ambiguous. Historian Michael W. Hughey details this by explaining that “Americanism cannot be easily defined in terms of what it is, it has often been defined in terms of what it is not-i.e., with reference to those who are presumed to be its enemies”.1 In the mid-19th century, nativists were especially hostile to the Irish Catholic immigrants as they were viewed as fundamentally un-American, due to their their supposed allegiance to their home countries and the Roman Catholic church. Nativists believed immigrants would maintain views that would alter an already established ‘culture’, concerning facets such as the public education system, social morality,…

    • 1334 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the long run their chidden can have more opportunities than their parents previously did in living in Mexico alone. Overall these people formed different identities from one another but everyone shared a common quality they are all hybrids because of the mixture of both American and Mexican culture infused in their lives on a daily basis. I myself am a hybrid because I am both Mexican/American as well as the people mentioned in this dissertation. When I was younger my parents had me born in the United States, but I did my early education in Mexico city. After completing my early education I moved to the United States with my family to start my new life in the United States. My parents wanted me to be diverse and have many abilities unfortunately they weren't as lucky as me. They were born in Mexico and didn't at the time have the same intrinsic gifts bestowed to me by being born in the United States. At a early childhood I was exposed to a gamut of culture beliefs and…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Does America Still Exist?

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In Richard Rodriguez’s article, “Does America Still Exist?” my mind opened to another view on the topic of immigration in the United States. My beliefs had always been that if anyone is not an American citizen who were paying their taxes here, then you should not be allowed in our country. After reading this article and seeing the immigrant’s perspective, I learned that America is full of immigrants and that we are all here for the same reason, The American Dream. I loved the lines in paragraph seven, “We are gathered together-but as individuals, with separate pasts, distinct destinies. Our society is as paradoxical as a Puritan congregation: We stand together, alone.” (360) What that quote meant to me was that although we are all living in America (the country that pledges allegiance to the diversity), we still look for differences in everybody opposed to embracing their commonalities. For example, when people would ask the writer where he was from in order to decipher the darkness of his skin tone. Even though in this country everyone is allowed to get an education, to study other ethnicity’s of the world. To be allowed to pursue a job on whichever career I follow through, at the end, I am who for I am and not to be judged from my ethnicity. That has what America done for me.…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Novelist, poet, and essayist Ishmael Reed wrote an essay called “The Multinational Society”. The main idea of the essay is to explain all the different nationalities there are in America and the main claim he is trying to make is how we should be open minded to all of it and accept the change that it’s going to bring. The different nationalities and people are what make America America and the American people should accept that instead of trying to claim that one race or one belief is best and is what everyone should do.…

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    People Like Me

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In People like Us, David Brooks suggests that maybe America isn't as diverse as we all say it is. That maybe no one really cares about diversity as much as they claim to. He may be right. Have you ever been to a school cafeteria? People group together into different racial and social groups. It's more comfortable to be around people similar to us, and comfort is what America is all about.…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays