top-rated free essay

Einstein report

By jodiford122 Jan 26, 2014 690 Words
Jodi Ford
Mr. Jordan
AP Language & Composition
20 January 2014
Response to Albert Einstein’s Letter to Phyllis Wright
When Albert Einstein, also known as the greatest scientist of the twentieth century, and a Nobel-prize winner, receives a letter from a sixth-grade girl named Phyllis Wright questioning if scientists pray, - and if so, what do they pray for - Einstein simultaneously uses various rhetoric methods such as SOAPS, ethos, logos, and pathos to respond to Wright’s question in the simplest form possible, and in doing so, Einstein created a rhetorically effective response. Einstein’s rhetorical purpose was to elaborate how scientists perceive scientific and religious elucidations.

Considering the fact that Einstein is a name known throughout the world and is one of the most legendary scientists known to man, Einstein establishes ethos right away. He has what you could call, “automatic ethos.” Most people wouldn’t dare to doubt a Nobel-prize winner. Having that in mind, Einstein has a strong amount of credibility to speak on behalf of science and religion through his perspective. Einstein also uses ordinary jargon that any average human could understand, causing people to think highly of him. “It must be admitted our actual knowledge of these laws is only imperfect and fragmentary.” By using words such as “our”, Einstein preserves his ethos by establishing himself as a common man, instead of the Nobel-prize winner. This helps his audience relate to his points.

Einstein then continues on to create his idea of logos, which he created by supplying a counterargument. “Scientific research is based on the idea that everything that takes place is determined by laws of nature, and therefore this holds for the actions of people.” By stating this, Einstein concedes to the controversy of scientists with no religious beliefs. However, while conceding with the scientists that believe in the laws of nature, Einstein was concurrently supporting his own statement by showing that he has given a reasonable amount of deliberation to this topic of science and religion.

Einstein is careful when using pathos to help state his point of view, because if you use too much pathos, it will make your entire purpose look more propagandistic. Einstein appeals to his religious viewers by explaining that there could be "a spirit vastly superior to that of man" relating to the affairs of science. Einstein then goes on to state that, "in this way the pursuit of science leads to a religious feeling of some sort, which is indeed quite different from the religiosity of someone more naive". This was Einstein’s clarification, that whether you agree with science or religion, they all involve faith and hope, they just involve different beliefs.

The overt subject of Einstein’s response regarding Phyllis Wright’s letter was whether or not scientists pray and what they pray for. The occasion is Einstein receiving a letter from a sixth-grader looking for clarification about science and religion. The audience is a more controversial topic. Some say the audience is obviously Phyllis Wright, since he is replying to her letter. However, other people have suggested that due to Einstein’s ethos and his etiquette structure of his response, Einstein knew his response would be seen not just by Phyllis Wright, but by people all over the world. Einstein’s purpose is intricate, you have to analyze the entire letter to understand what Einstein was trying to achieve in responding to Wright. On the surface, it may seem that Einstein’s purpose was to elaborate the nature of science and religion combined. Ultimately, it seems as though Einstein actually wanted to offer Wright a different perspective, due to Einstein’s failure to directly answer Wright’s question. After Einstein’s receipt of Phyllis Wright’s letter concerning the combination of nature and science, and the nature of faith, Einstein takes a more logical approach to the ideals of religion, prayer, and science while acknowledging the differences from a scientist’s point of view. Einstein creates a rhetorically effective response to Wright by giving examples of multiple different rhetoric methods to meet his rhetorical purpose of science and religion from a scientist’s perspective.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Recommendation Report

    ...A Written Report Presented to MR. MARK GIL GABE Department of Social Sciences and Humanities College of Education and Social Sciences Mindanao State University at Naawan Misamis Oriental In partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Course English 8 (Technical Writing) Elmer Alcano Progress Report ...

    Read More
  • Report Writing

    ...LONG REPORT FORMAT A typical lab report should include the following sections: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. Title Page Table of Contents List of Figures Abstract Introduction Apparatus Procedure Safety Results Recommendations and Conclusion Appendix References Follow the detailed instructions in the CHE writing guide. Make sure to in...

    Read More
  • How do I write a report

    ...How do I write a report? Report writing differs from essay writing because it has a different purpose. Reports are common communication tools as they assist in the decision-making process. Written for a particular purpose, they usually outline a problem, provide the relevant facts and ideas related to the situation, and then recommend a cour...

    Read More
  • short report

    ... Short Reports Style Guide for the development of short reports Short reports can be presented as: formal short reports or memorandums. Short reports are usually less formal and less complex in structure than long reports. Use a memorandum format when the report provides information, rather than analyses information. Clarify the...

    Read More
  • incident report

    ... STONEBRIDGE RESIDENTIAL CARE HOME ACCIDENT/INCIDENT REPORT FORM Date of Accident: 2nd may 2013 Date Reported: 2nd may 2013 Time of Accident: between 9:45am – 10am Time Reported: 10:30am Specific Location: the location of the accident happened in Stonebridge Residential Care Home, in the garden at the front of the care home...

    Read More
  • Format of Report

    ...Internship Final Report Format Overview The internship final report should be a formal document written in prose that summarizes the internship experience. First-person (e.g., I observed fluoroscopy…) style of writing is preferred over the third-person (Fluoroscopy was observed…) because the first-person voice is generally more succinct...

    Read More
  • Incident Reports, Logs, and Narrative Reports

    ... Incident Reports, Logs, and Narrative Reports Differences Introduction The use of incidents reports, logs and narrative-only reports is commonplace in a number of public and private sectors, including law enforcement and health care where they are used to codify different types of events for different purposes. Irrespective...

    Read More
  • Proposals and Report

    ...Communication Skills Part 12 Reports and Proposals Reports Reports are prepared after some task is given and it is completed. Report includes all the details of how the work was done and it is also a declaration that the work is done. A report can be as small as one sentence and it can be as big as several hundred pages. When a staff tel...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.