Effective Management Control Systems

Topics: Management, Supply chain management, Logistics Pages: 25 (7480 words) Published: February 22, 2010
中国海尔集团推行独特而先进的 OEC 和市场链管理控制机制赢得市场竞争优势 美国南加州大学李文索会计学院 林文雄教授

中文摘要 在过去 20 年中,中国海尔集团从一个濒临破产的冰箱制造工厂转变成了一个 拥有多化产品的国际企业集团,并被列入《世界最具影响力的 100 个品牌》。海尔 拥有包括白色家电、黑色家电、米色家电在内的 96 大种类、15100 多个规格的产 品群,并出口产品到全球 160 多个国家和地区。同时,海尔现有工业园区 10 个、 海外工厂及制造基地 30 个、海外设计中心 8 个、营销网点 58800 个。据 2004 年市 场统计显示,海尔小冰箱、酒柜在美国市场已占据了第一的市场份额。在 2004 年 11 月的英国《金融时报》和普华永道联合评选的“全球最受尊敬的企业"中,海 尔蝉联中国最受欢迎企业第一名。 本论文叙述了海尔集团发展战略创新的三个阶段:名牌战略、多元化战略和国 际化战略,并指出海尔企业文化、制造技术、组织结构、管理控制机制、信息技术 和薪酬体制是如何配合其战略发展的三个阶段而相应改变的。 本文还对海尔 OEC 和市场链流程再造的管理控制机制进行了详细的阐述。最后作者指出海尔的五个改 进方向及海尔可向美国通用电气集团借鉴的五种管理方法。

Effective Management Control Systems Help China Haier Group Achieve Competitive Advantage Professor Thomas W. Lin, University of Southern California (Rough Draft; May 2005)

ABSTRACT During the past twenty years, China Haier Group went from a nearly bankrupt refrigerator factory to a diversified global company among the list of the world 100 most recognizable brands. This paper describes how Haier developed its three stages of business strategy and management control systems such as corporate culture, OEC management, and market chains based business process reengineering to achieve competitive advantage and success. It also identifies opportunities for improvement and lessons that Haier can learn from GE.

INTRODUCTION In 1984, Zhang Ruimin took over a nearly bankrupt refrigerator factory, Haier Group, in Qingdao, China, and in 2004, the company’s global sales hit $12 billion with a growth rate of 68% during the previous 20 years. Today Haier Group is recognized as a worldwide brand. On January 31, 2004, the firm ranked 95th after such household names as Coca-Cola, McDonald's, and Nokia, which were the top three on the World Brand Laboratory’s list of the 100 most recognizable brands. Haier was the only Chinese brand on the list. For a second consecutive year, Haier was honored as the “Most Respectful Enterprise in China” in the rankings of “Global Most Respectful Enterprises,” coevaluated by the Financial Times and PricewaterhouseCoopers in November, 2004. So how did they achieve their success? As one of China’s fastest-growing companies, Haier Group fits a 1999 Gallup survey profile for a successful company. Customer service, product quality, operating efficiency, innovation, and speed to market are among the top seven factors for success (Gallup Organization, 1999, p. 1). Haier excels in all these areas. Management control is the process by which managers influence other members of the organization to implement the organization’s strategies (Anthony and Govindarajan, 1998, p. 6). This paper describes how Haier developed its three stages of business strategy, and management control systems such as corporate culture, OEC management, and market chains based business process reengineering to achieve competitive advantage and success. It also identifies opportunities for improvement and lessons that Haier can learn from GE.

BUSINESS STRATEGY Haier CEO Zhang Ruimin and President Yang Mianmian say the firm developed three major strategies over three stages: brand building or recognition strategy, expansion or diversification strategy, and globalization strategy (See Figure 1). Called the famousbrand strategy, the first stage lasted from 1984 to 1991. During this period, it created and built Haier-brand products and set up a quality assurance system. In April 1985, CEO Zhang gathered all employees and battered the first poor quality refrigerator with a hammer, and then the employees responsible for these goods battered 76 defective refrigerators. The hammering event woke up the quality awareness of all employees and established the concepts of “defective products are wasters” and “excellent products are produced by talented employees.” The thinking shifted from volume being the priority to quality and brand recognition being the priorities.

Figure 1: Three Stages of the Strategy Development

Expansion or Diversification Dec. 1991 – Dec. 1998 (7 years) *From east to west...

References: Abu-Shalback. 2001. “Turning Up the Heat.” Appliance. June. Arndt. Michael. 2002. “Can Haier Freeze Pot Whirlpool and GE?” Business Week International, April 11. Anthony. Robert N. and Vijay Govindarajan. 1998. Management Control Systems. Ninth Edition. Irwin/McGraw-Hill, New York. Biers. Dan. 2001. “Taking the Fight to the Enemy: China’s Top Appliance Maker, Haier, Breaks into the U.S. Market Using a Combination of Quality, Price and Local Manufacturing.” Far Eastern Economic Review. March 29, pp. 52-55. Business Week. 1999. “Zhang Ruimin, CEO, Haier Group, China.” June 14, p. 87. Business Week. 2003. “Haier 's Aim: "Develop Our Brand Overseas" March 31. Khermouth. Gerry, Bruce Einhorn and Dexter Roberts. 2003. “Breaking Into the Name Game: China’s Manufacturers Are Building Their Brands to Go Global.” Business Week. April 7, 2003, p. 54. Financial Times and PricewaterhouseCoopers. 2004. “Global Most Respectful Enterprises.” Financial Times. November 2004. Flannery. Russell. 2001. “China Goes Global: The Ambitious Haier Leads an International Brand Push by Mainland Multinationals.” Forbes Global, August 6. Flannery. Russell, et al.. 2002. “Another Look: Haier and Higher.” Forbes Global, February 4. Forsythe. Michael. 2003. “Chinese Fridges Hot in U.S.” The Charlotte Observer. June 13. Gallup Organization. 1999. “CEO Strategies for Success.” USA Today, August 18, p. 1. Haier Group. 2002. Haier Weekly News, 2002 Combined Booklet. (in Chinese) Haier Group. 2003. Haier Weekly News, 2003 Combined Booklet. (in Chinese) Haier Group. 2004. Haier Weekly News, 2004 Combined Booklet. (in Chinese) Haier Group Website. 2004. http://www.haier.com Haier University. 2002. Haier OEC Management Brochure. (in Chinese) Jiang. Chingkuei. 2002. Haier’s Marketing Chains and Information Systems. China Economic Publisher. (in Chinese) Kotter. John and James Heskett. 1992. Corporate Culture and Performance. New York: Free Press. Lowe. Janet. 2001. Welch: An American Icon. New York: John Wiley & Sons. Lynch. David J. 2003. “CEO Pushes China’s Haier as Global Brand.” USA Today, January 2. McGregor. Douglas. 1960. The Human Side of Enterprise. New York: McGraw Hill. Madden, Normandy. 2003. “China 's power brands eye global expansion.” Advertising Age. Vol. 74, Iss. 2, pp. 12-13. Maslow. Abraham H. 1987. Motivation and Personality. 3rd ed., New York: Harper and Row. Paul. Anthony. 1999. “China’s Haier Power.” Fortune International. February 15. Porter. Michael E. 1985. Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance. New York: Free Press. Prasso. Sheri. 1999. “Chinese Fridges Made in South Carolina.” Business Week International, May 6. Prasso. Sheri. 1999. “We Want to Become a Global Company.” Business Week
International, June 14. Prasso. Sheri. 1999. “Zhang Ruimin, CEO, Haier Group, China.” Business Week International, June 14. Roberts. Dexter, et al. 2002. “Haier’s Tough Trip from China: The Mainland’s Top Appliance Maker Aims to Go Global.” Business Week International, April 1. Roberts. Dexter. 2002. “Baby Steps for a Chinese Giant.” Business Week International, July 17. Qingdao Haier Co., Ltd. Consolidated Financial Statements, 2000 – 2003. (In Chinese) Slater. Robert. 1999. Jack Welch and the GE Way. New York: McGraw Hill. Slater. Robert. 2000. The GE Way Fieldbook. New York: McGraw-Hill. Sprague. Jonathan. 2002. “Haier Reaches Higher.” Fortune International, September 16. Sprague. Jonathan. 2002. “China’s Manufacturing Beachhead.” Fortune International, October 28. Sull. Donald N., Alejandro Ruelas-Gossi, and Martin Escobari. 2003. “Innovating Around Obstacles.” Strategy & Innovation, November-December. Sun. Jian. 2002. The Management Models of Haier. Business Management Publishing Co. (In Chinese) Sun. Tzu. 2001. The Art of War: A New Translation. Boston: Shambhala. Taylor. Frederick W. 1947. The Principles of Scientific Management. New York: Norton. Ulrich. Dave, Steve Kerr, and Ron Ashkenas. 2002. The GE Work-Out. New York: McGraw-Hill. Welch. Jack and John A. Byrne. 2001. Jack: Straight from the Gut. New York: Warner Books. Wu. Yibing. 2003. “China’s Refrigerator Magnate.” McKinsey Quarterly. Number 3. Wysocki. Bernard, Jr. 2002. “Chinese Multinationals Aim to Be Just That.” Wall Street Journal, January 28. Yi, Jeannie J. and Shawn X. Ye. 2003. The Haier Way. Homa & Sekey Books, Dumony, New Jersey. Zeng. Ming and Peter J. Williamson. 2003. “The Hidden Dragons.” Harvard Business Review. October. Zhang. Ruimin. 1999. “Innovation Makes Haier Strong.” China Today. August 10-11.
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Effective and Efficient Project Management Essay
  • Management Decision and Control Systems Essay
  • Management Control System on Dell Research Paper
  • Essay about Inventory Management and Control System
  • Management System Essay
  • control Essay
  • Management Control System Practices of Amul Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free