top-rated free essay

Effective Communication Assignment 1

By chengtroy Oct 27, 2012 1042 Words
In the out-[Need a title?]of-class assignment “The Appeal of the Real: Why Reality Television is so Popular”, the author, an undergraduate in an academic writing class seeks to argue that reality television benefits both its participants and viewers more than it harms them. However, the academic writing is ineffective in conveying the arguments the author wishes to present. The essay presented by the author lacks characteristics of an Aristotelian[Truly Aristotle?] academic writing, The main source of noise comes from the fallacies and weak or irrelevant arguments presented as well as the linguistic expressions of the author. As the author defers from the norm of academic writing, the essay is hindered in its effectiveness to persuade its readers. The author poorly demonstrates his thesis by using arguments that are weak. In the essay, the author presents three popular reality television programs as arguments to support his thesis. The arguments, however, are undeveloped as the author over concentrates on describing the reality television programs. As a result, the arguments are hastily added and become weak or contains fallacies.[Since the whole paragraph is about fallacies, just say it contains fallacies or it becomes weak since it contains fallacies- -] In the second paragraph, the author states that “viewers enjoy sharing and celebrating the triumph of an unknown performer on his way to becoming a star.” This claim is a hasty generalisation of reality television viewers as a whole, and is weak in proving the benefits reaped by viewers from watching reality television programs. The author adds “To the losers, the truth hurts but only for a while; soon enough it heals. The show builds character.” As this argument is an opinion of the author that is neither substantiated nor explained, it is weak in supporting the author’s thesis. The noise in the arguments prevents it from convincing and persuading readers in favour of the author’s thesis. This lack of strong arguments is prevalent in the essay, resulting in a limitation in the essay’s effectiveness.     In support of his argument, many ideas raised by the author proved to be irrelevant to the thesis of the essay. The author uses popular reality television programs to illustrate its benefits on participants and viewers. By doing so, the author generalises the chosen reality television programs to be reflective of the entire reality television industry. However, certain benefits the author argues are program-specific. For The Amazing Race, the author raises one of the possible benefits for viewers as discovering various cultures in obscure vacation destinations. This benefit is specific to The Amazing Race, as viewers do not make the same discovery on other reality television programs such as American Idol, or Joe Millionaire. Similarly, participants in The Amazing Race do not “have their fifteen minutes of fame” and “spend some vacation time- all expenses paid- at a cool chateau in France”, as argued by the author as benefits attained by participants in the reality television program, Joe Millionaire. This generalisation is a source of noise to the author’s thesis, diminishing the strength of the persuasiveness of the essay.     The author shows an inability in expressing himself concisely in the context of academic writing. In the essay, the author uses numerous informal personal expressions, including the use of contracted forms. In paragraph one, the author uses the expression “The sky is not falling. This is television, not Carnegie Hall”. Such use of analogy makes the essay informal, against the norm of academic writing. It is also a poor analogy, considering the fact that the author is submitting the assignment in Singapore, thus the relation of television to Carnegie Hall in New York is not realised easily by local readers. [Let me know if you want to keep this point. If not we can remove it as well.][Ok, adopted.]The author uses expressions such as “self-proclaimed guardians” and “How different is finding someone to date and maybe developing a relationship with by appearing on a television show from answering an ad in the personal column of the newspaper?” By doing so, the author shows an inability to be objective about his arguments. As a result of the author’s personal opinions and strong emotions, the essay lacks distinction between fact and thought. With no distinction between personal opinion and the information the author wishes to convey, the argument for the thesis becomes less concise. Conversely, the use of contracted forms throughout the essay such as “don’t” and “it’s” also adds to the informal tone of the essay. Thus it is less effective in persuading the readers.     In an attempt to provide a balanced view of reality television, the author intentionally[I don’t like this word, though it may emphasis the ‘good’. Is it neutral? Is it personal?] raises alternative views by “literati” in paragraph five. However, such refutations do not convince readers that the author has taken opposing views into account when presenting his arguments. The author does not cite sources from which these statements by “literati” are from. In addition, the author does not inform why the view can be considered authoritative sources. The author goes on to cite Oliver James and Salman Rushdie, with the assumption that readers know who they are. Furthermore, the author states these opinions of individuals, but does not explain why their view can be overlooked in favour of the thesis of the essay. Therefore, the author draws the attention of readers to weak opinionated views of “literati”, then dismisses it by stating they “fail to understand or remember” that television is just entertainment for the masses. With weak refutations, the essay becomes a single-sided argument, ineffective in persuading the readers.     In conclusion, due to the noises arising from fallacies, weak or irrelevant arguments and informal linguistic expressions present in the arguments raised by the author, the information to be conveyed is hindered. In addition, contrary to the Aristotelian style of writing, the author fails to provide the logos, and lacks logical coherence is his arguments. As a result the author is unable to make a strong stand for his thesis, and the persuasiveness of the academic writing is marred. The academic writing of the author does not establish or prove his thesis, thus the essay is ineffective.

Cite This Document

Related Documents


    ... PRINCIPLES OF COMMUNICATION IN ADULT SOCIAL CARE SETTINGS 1 UNDERSTAND WHY EFFECTIVE COMMUNICATION IS IMPORTANT IN ADULT SOCIAL CARE SETTINGS 1.1 IDENTIFY THE DIFFERENT REASONS WHY PEOPLE COMMUNICATE People communicate for different reasons, to portray their feelings, emotions, pain, opinions etc., the communication should be professional (...

    Read More
  • Communication Technologies assignment 1

    ... Communication Technologies Assignment 1 This is a rudimentary diagram representing the basic network that is employed in the Boston College Rochford Campus. This section represents a room, or department within the campus, showing how the Nodes are all connected to a multi-port switch using straight-through cables (Used to...

    Read More
  • assignment 1

    ...560 BUSSINESS COMMUNICATION 12 AUGUST 2014 Lecturer Varun ASSESSMENT NO 1 Question 1(a) Explain the process theory in your own word. Ans.:- Process Theory :- The process theory mainly focus on the process of communication. Its main aim is to establish a communication successfully. Process theory is the activity of transfer of inf...

    Read More
  • Homework 1 Assignment 1

    ... 1 Define modulation? The process of putting information onto a high frequency carrier for transmission. 2 What is carrier frequency? Carrier frequency is used to designate the nominal frequency of a carrier wave and the center frequency of a frequency modulation signal. 3 Name two reasons modulation is used in communications? T...

    Read More
  • Effective Communication Paper

    ... Effective Communication Paper Brandi Greenfield CJA/304 Monty Mathis December 17, 2014 There are a lot of ways to effectively communicate no matter what situation you may be in. In this paper we will discuss the process of verbal and nonverbal communication and the components associated to each one of these. The diff...

    Read More
  • CO 2025 Communications Assignment 1

    ...Paul Burgess CO 2025 – Communications Mr. Ritzman Assignment 1 – Importance of Communication It is important to develop your communication skills every day so you are more professional in your job and in your daily life. You need to learn how to communicate with all sorts of people both young and old. Some of these people may not be ...

    Read More
  • Managerial Communications Assignment No 1

    ... Assignment no 1 – Managerial Communications Case study – How do you manage an off-site team? Submission date – 31st Jan 2015 Group Details – Vijaya Avatani 36439 Vidhi Pande 36479 Swati Sathe 36436 Case Analysis In our view, the case throws light on following issues – 1. Conflict between two employees - Allison & Penny [Ice...

    Read More
  • Introduction to Mass Communication Assignment

    ...the newspaper, very strong visual feeling to the readers. Secondly, nature of the activity. For this advertisement, IKEA only want to present an idea through this activity, they hope people to know this activity. At this page, they hope to have a strong effect of publicity. Effects of the messages on the target audience For this IKEA adverti...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.