Preview

Edward Said Summary

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
542 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Edward Said Summary
After the Palestinians were exiled of their country, the tradition had became a part of their identity. Meaning even the Palestinian people had left their country, the Palestinian culture is there to recognize of what defines the Palestinian people’s true identity. In addition, the Palestinian culture is also a symbol for the Palestinians as they formed a community based on their shared language. While the Palestinian people were living in other countries, the Palestinians have experienced the racial views from the people in different countries. In the essay, Said talks about when the Palestinians doesn’t have a state but instead they live in other countries,where the people has referred the Palestinians as a “legend”. After the Palestinians …show more content…
The “States” essay of Edward Said is an example of autoethnography, which it’s based on the “ Arts of the Contact Zone” of Pratt’s essay where the people have made representations of themselves that was perceived from the …show more content…
This concludes a homogeneity and heterogeneity community of Pratt’s essay in the “ Arts of the Contact Zone”, which she states when the people has a shared culture with each other are equal, and the other who doesn't have a shared culture are different. In other words, the culture/ dialect has created two forms of different communities between the Palestinians and the Jewish people in Israel. The Jewish people represents a homogeneous community as they referred themselves as the dominant dominant, while the Palestinians is a heterogeneous community, which defines them as the ‘ other”. Afterwards, the reason for the Palestinians has formed a community is actually based of their shared experience as well as the suffering of being exiled of their country. The goal of Edward Said was to regain the Palestinians’ self identity based on the representation of the photographs back in Israel as they were in exile of their former country. He also used some of the people from other different countries’ representations to the Palestinians to support his statement. The purpose of Said is using the countries’ accusations of the Palestinian people as thy referred them

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    In the novel “Jews in Post-Holocaust Germany, 1945-1953” By Jay Howard Geller, Geller tells the often-untold story of Jews after the Holocaust. Geller through this novel lays lot a historical outline of Jews after the Holocaust. His historical timeline not only shows the trouble and struggles of surviving victims of holocaust but also shows the climax of the creation of Palestine. Geller takes of advantage of numerous primary resources to support his historical timeline of Jews from 1945 to 1953. Along with being informative this book takes away the veil that was created after the holocaust. Geller takes this veil away and tells it how it is without cover up this vital and yet overlooked time period in German history. The creation of the state of Palestine was a long process and this is main thing expressed in Gellers Novel. Through the historical timeline, he lays out he starts out with the struggle and builds up chronologically to a positive ending.…

    • 1964 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In his "States" Edward Said writes about the "alienated" Palestinians. This story is an example of Pratt’s definition of a transcultural text. There are so many pieces that can be put together in States to Pratt’s ideas to form the transcultural text. The text from States can be used to help us better understand what a transcultural text is because it has new pieces of information, and it mostly relates to today’s world. I think that if we understand the story “States” as a transcultural text, we will be able to apply that to other stories which makes it easier to understand. Palestinians’ situation can mostly be understood through Pratt’s definition of contact zone. Said goes beyond what Pratt defines as a community. Pratt defines community as strongly utopian, but that is not what Said sees. The Palestinians do not have a “strongly utopian” community. And also, Pratt defines the marginal group and dominant group which I applied to “States.” Palestinians are in the marginal group because they are getting represented by Said who is in the dominant group. Mary Pratt would consider “States” a transcultural…

    • 1695 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Cultural pluralism is defined as a series of distinct but coexisting groups each preserving their tradition and culture but each loyal to a broader national unity. This was made apparent several times. One example was when Hatem went to kiss Naima goodbye, but she refused due to tradition of Ramada. This shows that Naima and any myself are part of America but preserve our own traditions. Naima’s culture is her Palestinian products, belief systems, values, morals, skills, literature and language. These were different from those of U.S. especially language and tradition. These two concepts notably created culture shock, the experiencing of disorientation and confusion one feels when confronted with a different culture. A prime example was shown when Naima searched for employment and was over looked due to a language barrier. Another was learning how to drive a car in…

    • 2309 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, as large amounts of zionists immigrated into Palestine, the native population became alarmed by their motives. This conflict led to fighting, that turned into escalating waves of violence. The group of Palestinians who were concerned about the Jew’s immigration formed a group called…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Paradise Now

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Set in Palestine, Paradise Now is a movie that tells the story of two Palestinian childhood friends Khaled and Said, who are recruited to carry out a terrorist mission in Tel Aviv, Israel. The two friends are to cross into Israel and blow themselves up, a plan the friends are to keep secret from their families and relatives. The movie is seen as an accurate portrayal of the real life situation of Palestine citizens who are not happy with the thirty-eight years that Israelites have occupied their land. Said is angered by the fact that the status of victims, what he believes belongs to them by right, is taken away from them by the Israelis. This assertion by Said seems to be the position taken by Palestine. Paradise Now speaks about the Palestine condemnation of violence and offers insight into those taking part in such inhumane acts. Paradise Now brings forth the issues in the Palestine-Israel war.…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The lifestyle between Intertestamental Palestinians and Roman daily life were quite contrasting. These two groups grew from distinct traditions, geographies, socio-economic conditions and religious beliefs. These distinctions came at odds with each other, demonstrated some harsh qualities on both sides and resulted in some influencing on the other. However, it was the might of the Romans that typically positioned their culture in the dominant position politically and economically.…

    • 969 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “I like the way a wise man build a story in an unconventional way.” This quote by Jim McKay is very striking, and if one was to be curious, continue reading. The way which an essay is structured makes a huge deal. In order to keep a reader invested and concentrated on the main point then the structure, or form, must be clear and organized. However, when writing the essay “States”, Edward Said takes a very unconventional approach to writing as he describes his life experiences after being exiled from his country as a Palestinian. His style of writing does not follow a specific pattern, nor does it follow anything that is conventional in a normal essay. Said uses this unique style of writing in hopes to show the characteristics of the life as a Palestinian. However, this style of writing is extremely difficult to follow. The essay jumps from place to place, which makes it hard for the reader to keep track of what is being talked about. Said believes that his use of unconventional writing is necessary in order to establish the “hybrid” style of Palestinian culture. Styles discussed will include things like the use of photos, lack of transitions, multiple genres, lack of and introduction and conclusion, and most importantly, no logical organization. Through the use of unconventional writing characteristics, Said takes the reader on a complicated journey to establish Palestinian “hybrid” way of life.…

    • 1887 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Lemon Tree Analysis

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The Israel-Palestinian conflict has been a major source of communal tension amongst Arabs and Jews in the last century. Disagreements over whom the land rightfully belongs to have erupted in violence, resulting in the deaths of thousands of civilians and fighters. This fierce fighting has led to public outcry for the two factions to come to a peaceful solution that will once again bring stability to the region. Sandy Tolan, author of The Lemon Tree: An Arab, A Jew, and the Heart of the Middle East presents the conflict through the true histories of two families, antithetical in nature, whose pasts ultimately lead them down a road of friendship. Despite a few exaggerations and assumptions, Tolan presents a well-researched, impartial history…

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In one of the readings, by Alexander, it says that before 1980, the Palestinians did not have control over what they would show in the cinema. However, they do have full control over their movie content now, and are able to show their point of views on the battle for the land that they and the Israelis fight for, assertively. Assad embarks to depict the suicide aircraft, Said and Khalid, as people confronting an inner battle. He starts his film with demonstrating them in the ordinariness of ordinary life. They are working for negligible wages as mechanics and are experiencing the schedules of everyday life. Before long the gathering of people discovers that the men have volunteered as saints, and are currently required for a mission. Their assignment is to go into Tel Aviv and explode two bombs while giving up their lives. At first this appears to be odd to the audience, as it didn't have all the signs of being the film was going. However, it turns out to be clear this was the goal of Assad, as he needed to delineate the suicide bombers as ordinary as could be allowed. As the film advances the gathering of people starts to comprehend why the men have volunteered for this destructive errand. Said and Khaled feel this is the main way that they can convey consideration and change to the Palestinians who live under the…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    When his father drives him to school for the first time, his names is spelled wrong on the name tag (78). When he is laughed at by his Jewish classmates, he “[shaves] his moustache,” “[buys] some pants in a Jewish store” and “[buys] a Walkman and some tapes in Hebrew” (86). However, his efforts to become Jewish always fail because he cannot escape the continuous ideological framing of the tautology: “once an Arab, always an Arab” (92). By desperately saying this sentence, Eyad reveals the bitterness of being a Palestinian citizen in the State of Israel. The ethnic identity is regarded as a genetic identity, inerasable and despised by Jews.…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Then after World War II and the Holocaust, there was a great push to do more to stop the genocidal efforts of Adolf Hitler to wipe out the Jewish people. There was this tragedy of the Jewish people, but many suggest that the way to deal with this was not to create a tragedy for the Palestinian people. Richard Falk goes on to say, “The UN decided to partition the former mandate that the British no longer wanted to administer and they gave, at the time, 55% of the historic territory to the insipient Jewish nation and 45% to the Palestinian nation. This seemed unfair and unacceptable at the time to the Palestinians and Arabs.”(“Global”) Yet again, it was another decision made by the European world that did not bother to consult the people who would be affected by the decision. The Palestinian and Arab people occupying the land were outraged. According to Office of the Historian, “The Palestinian Arabs refused to recognize this arrangement, which they…

    • 1378 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are many tools that one can use to maintain their identity, nationally and internationally. A nation or land is where people have established their life, their culture and their heart; sadly it has happened where people have been forced out of their homeland. Great opening sentences. Mary Louise Pratt, Kenji Yoshino and Edward Said all present very good methods of maintaining one's national identity in their essays. In Mary Louise Pratt's essay Arts of the Contact Zone she gives examples of people who are in a contact zone. Contact zones are where people are meeting other cultures, and they have to remember not to lose their own. (this was a run-on so I made it into two senteces)One of the Arts of the contact zone that describes what has happened with the Palestinians is Transculturation. Good. Transculturation is the combining of two different cultures. The Palestinians have been spread all over the world, and have had to take on the ways of their surroundings to fit into the norm while still keeping ways of their culture with them. In Kenji Yoshinos essay Covering the Hidden Assault on Our Civil Rights, Yoshino is trying to stop people from showing their false selves, also known as covering. "Everyone covers. To cover is to tone down a disfavored identity to fit into the mainstream." (Yoshino Preface) Edward Said's essay is a tool in itself; the essay's purpose is to show the world what happened to the Palestinians and to stop this from happening again. Great sentence structure and point! "Just as we once were taken from one "habitat" to a new one, we can be moved again". (Said 614) (move the sentence below that starts the next paragraph and make it the last sentence of this paragraph. This seems like your thesis statement, and the main point you are making in your paper)…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Palestine, or is it Israel? Either way, it is a highly contested land between two major Semitic groups: the Arabs, and the Hebrews. From the late 19th century, and throughout the 20th century it has been the focal point of Arab nationalism and Jewish Zionism. Today, it has become the Jewish state of Israel with occupied Palestinian Territories called the West Bank, which lies on the West side of the Jordan River, and the Gaza Strip, which borders Israel and Egypt. But, should the Palestinians deserve a state of their own? This essay will investigate the Palestinian side of the argument, their Biblical and Quranic ties to the land, the State of Palestine should have been created under Jordanian Egyptian as well as Israeli occupation of the land, and finally Israel’s poor relations with Palestine and colonial occupation of the land has led to the formation of many radical groups.…

    • 2176 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Promises Movie Analysis

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The movie “Promises” was about the religious conflict between the Palestinians and the Israelis. In this movie the talk to kids and follow them around to see what daily life was like for them. They also asked a lot of questions about their opinion on this conflict and in this essay you will learn what they said and what their opinions were. This conflict in this region has grown a lot throughout the years and many people are unhappy. The things that are causing this are borders, government, and religion. Many people don't know how much this is affecting both religions and what they have to do to follow their religion. Also all of these kids have very strong opinions about what they think…

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Modern History

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages

    6 million Jews, many Jewish immigrants’ were seeking Jewish Nationalism, when a return to their homeland manifested itself as the most practical solution. Since Babylonian times Jews have ceased to have unity to establish one nation, emphasising on how the reinstalment of Israel was obligatory, although seeming a plausible cause to why the Jews deserved to return home, countless Palestinians were killed and bound homeless so the Jews could be instituted within one nation. There are several different responses that exemplify the question of a Jewish homeland post world war II.…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays