Preview

Edmundson

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
742 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Edmundson
Francesca Tines
Professor Karim
English 120

Mark Edmundson “On the uses of a Liberal Education”

Mark Edmundson’s “On the uses of a Liberal Education” provides interesting points on why the liberal arts education is becoming part of consumer goods and how education is being advertised. Edmundson states different causes for this effect and comes up with consumer culture in society. He believes that the liberal art education is unsuccessful because Americans are attracted to consumption and entertainment. Education is becoming more about consumerism and not about students’ education because it is what they are expected not because they want they choose to higher their education. Edmundson’s view on what education means that the students are learning and improving their education and not just doing it for consumerism. Students, according to Edmundson, are not being their individual selves. He believes that society is making students’ part of “consumer culture” (280). Edmundson states, “that many of them have imbibed their sense of self consumer culture in general and from the tube in particular”(280). He stated that the student is influenced by the consumer culture and this happens because of television. Edmundson likes his students to be individual. In his article he talked about a specific student named, Joon Lee. Joon Lee is a student that he and his colleague talk about when they see each other. Edmundson said that what he like about Lee is he, “decided to follow his interests and let them make him into a singular and eccentric man” (280). This quote shows how Edmundson admired this man because he did not let consumer culture change his personality. He stated that consumerism makes people step away from individuality because they are “stifled from trying to achieve anything original” (281). Students wanting to fit in society do not allow them to learn and grow from their education. According to Edmundson the reason why students are not as passionate

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Rhetorical Analysis

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Today in America many people question whether or not college is truly worth the stress, time, and cost it throws on an individual. With these “burdens” comes alienation from the outside world with little fun and fulfilling experiences. Some people even say that many college students have zero creativity, and are proud of it. This idea of self-growth and freedom along with a diverting experience, while going through college, is something that Rick Perlstein himself has had the opportunity to do. Unfortunately, Perlstein experienced this in his days, and has come to realization that, “College as America used to understand it, is coming to an end” (Perlstein). With this article being published in the liberal magazine, New York Times, many people, mostly ones who have gone through college, completely disagreed with his opinion. One of those insulted people being Liz Addison. Addison’s claim argues that college is yes, much different, but in a positive way, especially in the community colleges. All together in her one sided- argument, she includes several rhetorical devices to persuade, inform, and emotionally prove her claim. These devices being ethos, and pathos, gives her a strong foundation and effective argument to the liberal audience she is writing her article to.…

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Graff explains that we only associate the educated lifestyle with texts and subjects. He argues that the education system assumes that its possible to “wax intellectual’s about plays and Shakespeare” but not about “cars, dating, and fashion...” He also explains that students still need to read intellectual readings, but on topics that interests them and not the education system. Graff supports his argument saying that students…

    • 259 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Simon Benlow’s article, “Have it Your Way: Consumerism Invades Education”, he expresses his condemnation towards the college where he teaches, as they are now referring to “students” as “customers”. His disapproval is clearly seen by his use of words like “deeply troubled” and “hostile” (139). He talks about the consumer mentality that lures the individual into a false sense that every want, wish, and desire will be met at his or her discretion by using marketing slogans such as “Have it your way” (139). Benlow fears that continuing with this mentality in education will create students that “will become increasingly blind to the difference between consumerist culture and college culture.” (142)…

    • 249 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In his book Why Teach?, Mark Edmundson has written an essay in which he approaches an argument about the paradoxical consumer culture surrounding education. The university professor takes a stance on the problems that he has both experienced in his own classroom and observed on campuses, and he assigns these problems—his claims—appropriate blames. Enough logic is used to make these “blames” more factual, and he often claims how things are and offers several reasons as to why. His essay, “Liberal Arts & Lite Entertainment,” originally written in 1997, begins with his own university before branching out to all those across the country, and it is followed by a deduction of student culture and professors. He gives hope to the idea of the acceptance and praising of “genius” (as opposed to the alienation students indorse so well) closer towards the end, narrowing his argument down to a more specific change…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Can a liberal arts education really make us better?” by Richard Kamber, he argues that even though a liberal arts education can make us better, it depends solely on that person’s definition of better. Now the question on everyone’s mind, “What are liberal arts?” A liberal arts education gives us a general review of humanities, arts, and sciences. Liberal arts are usually delivered in small classes, full of active participants, by “seasoned faculty.” They aim to develop our character and provide us with an immense amount of skills, which ultimately gives us more money. Though often looked down upon, liberal arts have helped shape many great people such as Socrates, Giordano Gentile, Galileo, and Martin Heidregger.…

    • 402 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Edmundson starts telling its readers why he dislikes class evaluations at the end of each course. Edmundson extends this to the idea that universities have adapted a market mentality (vendors and consumers). In other words, the universities will change things around just to satisfy their students (consumers). Moreover, professors usually have to make their own changes, so that they receive good evaluations and make students “comfortable”. Graff supports the idea that universities don’t care about education, but they just want to make the students’ life easier, with those “easy classes”. Edmundson talks about how his students usually say that it’s a fun and interesting class. However, these comments don’t make him happy, instead it gives him a self-dislike feeling. He wants to hear something different; “I want some of them to say that they’ve been changed by the course” says Edmundson (Edmundson…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his book, Why Teach? In Defense of a Real Education, Mark Edmunson includes an essay titled “Liberal Arts & Lite Entertainment in which he talks about numerous phenomena happening in American school systems. About halfway through the essay, while on a rant about colleges competing against one another for students, Edmundson adds that individual departments also contend for students, and more specifically how the humanities “now must struggle to attract students” (14). The professor offers a couple of effects that loosening up has had on the branch. First, he claims that grading is not tough and students are hardly allowed to fail.…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Nowadays, education is more and more common, most of the people who live in developed or developing country have a chance to go to school. However, the purpose of learning knowledge is changed, a lot of people who go to university because they are told that the degree is a guarantee of making good money. Since the purpose is making more money and due to the fact that liberal art majors are not directly relate to most jobs, a lot of people argue that Liberal art is a useless major, and people should take business or science major. They believe that taking liberal art majors is not beneficial to their career. In Edward Conard’s essay “We don’t need more humanities majors”, he basically mentions that humanities major…

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Education is not a product: mark, diploma, job, money -- in that order: it’s a process, a never-ending one. -Bel Kaufman-…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Simon Benlow begins this essay by telling us how the current faculty and staff at is school received a memo in regards to “National Customer Service Week.” He is extremely bothered by the assumption, in this case, that the “customer” the memo is referring to is actually their students. In addition, Benlow begins to tell us how he is concerned “about the slow and subtle infiltration of consumerism into education” (151) and how the consumer has almost replaced the student in higher education. Benlow wants to counter this assumption and offer a brief description of some of the differences between the “customer” and the “student.”…

    • 655 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Conway Precis

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Jeremiah Conway writes The liberal Arts and Contemporary Culture and is bothered about how liberal arts is being taken for granted. He feels that this is a problem and it needs to be addressed. He makes it known that children will lack becoming educated in the future because science and technology is hindering there learning. If this problem is not approached then liberal arts would be ignored. They will be at risk of living in this world without any regards of life. Conway used an example of a “fish” not knowing what water was. This informs readers that people take education and life for graduated (2010, 4). What children do not understand is that they have the opportunity to gain knowledge but cannot due to technology and money. It becomes hard for them understand that being educated in liberal arts is better than having a one-track mind. If they want to become a scientist they will only learn the scientific method and equations. Moreover, they may not know basic home economic skill because they do not have an understanding of other disciplines.…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He states that to find “who you are” is the only question and the only lesson in life (Jensen 41). Every person is unique, and we play our role in this society. So, discovering yourself is more important than any academic lesson. It seems that most of the schools are trying to shape students’ thoughts. They think students should learn how to gain benefits from the society. To be more specific, Derrick Jensen thinks that our current education system has destroyed our own habits and students can’t feel happy in school. We start to doubt ourselves and are afraid to follow our heart; for instance, we are more quiet in the classroom just because we are afraid to make mistakes if questioned. According to Jensen, “we could not live the ways we do unless we avoided the question, force others to avoid placing that question in front of us, and in fact attempted to destroy those who do.”(Jensen 42). To give my experience, the most sentences I heard in my school life is “you need to do well on your academic”, “you must graduate from a great university”, “if you don’t work hard, you will be a failure in the future”. I believe many students have faced similar situations. And finally, we can’t do anything we like, learn anything we want. We start to lose ourselves. To make the long story short, it is a hard part to be ourselves, but the thing is we can’t break the “hidden rules” in our school. Schools cut down…

    • 1371 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Liberal Education’s main purpose in not only to train someone for a specific position, but also to create or develop skills that can be utilized in any profession. However, I believe that the liberal arts are under pressure and in danger in today’s society. The threat that is overwhelming Liberal Education is cuts in programs and funding in private and public schools.…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Mark Edmundson’s essay, “On the Uses of a Liberal Education,” was published in Harper’s magazine in the fall of 1997. Edmundson begins the article by giving us a glimpse into his own experiences teaching. He speaks on how, he dreads evaluation day at the end of each term, he feels he is being reviewed more on his entertaining ability and less on if the student felt changed by his course. Near the end of the article, Edmundson states, “My overall point is this: It’s not that a left-wing professional coup has taken over the university. It’s that at American universities, left-liberal politics have collided with the ethos of consumerism. The consumer ethos is winning.” (pg. 48) This article is about how the younger generation has been raised with…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Derek Bok

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Combining the educational system will also allow students to become a well-rounded person; also, with the change in time, the students will not have to go back to school to acquire other skills. Bok states that the “vocational majors have an easier time than liberal arts graduates in finding an initial job in business and tend to advance faster and earn more money during their first 10 years of work” (38). However, he then argues that “after 10 years the pictures become more complicated” (Bok 40). He also states that “liberal art teachers do a better job in fostering skills such as communication skills, human relations, creativity, and “big-picture thinking” matter more” (Bok 40). In a world where students are more career oriented, no one can say that liberal education is not important because as Bok states, “companies seem destined to witness faster changes, more frequent career shifts, increasingly diverse workforces, and expanding global operations, all of which favor a broad liberal arts education” (40). This is an explanation that with time, technology is getting more advanced and both the vocational school skill as well as the liberal art skills are needed for students to become a more rounded…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays