Top-Rated Free Essay

Discussion on Tanjong Rhu

Good Essays
Discussion on Tanjong Rhu
Theme: Traditional habits and ceremonies vs. modish patterns and behavior Tanjong Rhu is one of the famous ASEAN short stories wrote by Minfong Ho. This story is focusing on Singaporean Chinese life which contrasts in terms of traditional and modern. Tanjong Rhu is a port in Singapore where the writer sets as the place that the protagonist of the story spent his childhood in. The main theme of this story is the distinction between traditional habits and ceremonies and modish patterns and behavior. In the story, Chinese tradition as praying to the ancestor and the dead has been mentioned as an important element. From the description of the writer, we know that the protagonist, Mr. Li’s mother values the importance of this traditional practice. This can be proved by paragraph 5, line 1 to 8 at page 118 in the textbook. ““If something is to be done,” she said with the loud solemnity which she reserved for the altar room, “it must be done properly. If I am to visit your place of work, I must tell your father properly.” Carefully, she unlocked the top drawer of her mother-of-pear inlaid cabinet, where she kept all the paraphernalia for tending the altar: tiny porcelain wine cups, gold-leafed sheets of ceremonial money, candles and joss sticks and countless packets of incense.” As we read through the story, we know that father of the main character, Mr.Li has passed away long ago. The lines mentioned above shows that Grandma pays attention on praying to the ancestor and dead as she keeps all the necessary things for praying and arrange in the drawer. As a traditional thinker, she thinks that it is important to let Mr. Li’s father know what those livings do even though he has dead as she says “I must tell your father properly”. In Chinese traditions, praying to the ancestor and the dead is important to every family. This is a practice whereby Chinese believes that the ancestor and the dead will bless the living family. This tradition seems getting lost in modern Chinese family especially for those who are not Taoists or Buddhists. As in this story, Mr. Li and his wife, Helen seems not valuing this traditional practice. At the end of the story, Mr. Li cannot find the key of the drawer in which keeps all the praying stuff in it. This can be proved in page 127 paragraph 6 lines 4 to 6. “He tugged at the handle again, but the drawer remained shut. Then he realized that she always kept it locked. And he did not know where she kept the key.” This is shown that he never prays to the ancestor and the dead before and this is the reason that why he can’t find the key. Helen is also proved that not seeing the tradition as an important practice as she never helps Grandma in praying to the ancestor. Besides, the writer has also mentioned the funeral run by Mr. Li for his mother at the beginning of the story. In the story, Mr. Li described the funeral procession as long, chaotic and noisy. This can be proved in line 5 paragraph 2 pages 114. In fact, Chinese funeral procession is also one of the traditional practices which pass down from one generation to the next. During the funeral procession, the dead’s family will engage a monk to lead the blessing ceremony. The monk will chant scriptures regarding blessing and praying to the dead while the family members follow him and walk as in a circle a round and a round. In Chinese tradition of funeral procession, there should be someone who cry or mourn for the dead. This is to shows that the dead’s spirit is lonely and the sound of crying can attract the attention of deity and take the spirit away to nirvana. This is the reason why Mr. Li describes the funeral procession as chaotic and noisy. Normally, the funeral procession will take place three to five days. This is to let the dead’s relatives and friends to send off the dead. Besides, the dead’s family will hold vegetarian during the funeral procession. They will also burn some paper stuff for the dead as Chinese traditional believes that the dead spirit will use them after dead. After the coffin has been placed for the funeral procession for three or five days, the family will carry it to the cemetery. They will walk a distance while head of the family or the successor will carry the coffin or the dead’s picture. The hell banknote will be scattered too during the walk. The whole funeral procession is considered as a form to pray for the dead spirit so that the spirit can leave at ease. The complexity of the funeral procession makes Mr. Li thinks that it is long. In fact, many of the modern Chinese family do not think highly of the funeral procession. There are even many Chinese family does not hold a funeral procession for the dead or just for only one or two days. Modern thinker will think that it is not use for praying in the funeral procession as the one already dead. They will think that the dead will not hear or know what the livings are doing. Instead of the perfect funeral procession, modern thinker is probably thought that it is more important to take care of the dead before dead. We think that this is also one of the reason that why Mr. Li is not satisfy with the funeral procession held for his mother. As a modern generation, we think that Chinese traditions need to be passed down until future generation. Chinese traditions stand for 5000 years history and culture. Traditions stand for one ethnic. Without traditions, the ethnic will lose its significant. Therefore, modern generation should keep these traditions so that the ethnic can be remained and the traditions will not vanish.

References
Comber, L. (2005). Prizewinning ASEAN Fiction (pp. 113-128). Hong Kong: Times Edition – Marshall Cavendish.
Loh, M. (n.d.). Culture and Change: The Rise of the Singapore Short Story in English. In The Domain of Fiction.

References: Comber, L. (2005). Prizewinning ASEAN Fiction (pp. 113-128). Hong Kong: Times Edition – Marshall Cavendish. Loh, M. (n.d.). Culture and Change: The Rise of the Singapore Short Story in English. In The Domain of Fiction.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    tanjung rhu

    • 1342 Words
    • 9 Pages

     SET 1 1. Read the extract from the short story Tanjong Rhu. Then answer the questions. ‘Edward’, she said, crossing her legs, ‘come and join us?’ He refused, and was just turning away, when she noticed the binoculars he was holding, And asked what they were. ‘Oh, these,’ he said. ‘I bought theme today. For the children’. He could not think of anything better to say. (p.20) a) Who does the pronoun ‘us’ refer to? ……………………………………………………………………………………………………… b) Why do you think Edward…

    • 1342 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Learning in the Rhu

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages

    SPECIFIC: • To orient us to their own rules and regulation in the RHU • To encounter the unique attitudes of people and to enhance our ability to adjust and have a therapeutic relationship with them • To educate patients about their condition for them to be aware and learn how to prevent and manage the disease through health education LEARNING: As they say, “correct practice makes perfect”. Having my first RLE duty at RHU Iguig makes me feel nervous, excited, and anxious. I’ve enjoyed staying…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Discussion

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages

    icing on a cupcake the demonstrator will describe how to do so, allowing an auditory learner to learn. So both a visual and auditory learner can benefit from demonstrations. Now to group discussions and how both visual and auditory learners can use group discussions to help in there learning processes. Group discussions…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Discussion *

    • 293 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Discussion Board Question 7 THE CASE OF BRIAN B. AND THE MEDICAL FILE TEST Brian B. is taken into an exam room in the office of Dr. K. by the medical assistant, Amy. Amy gets into an animated discussion with Brian about their mutually favorite baseball team. As Amy leaves the exam room, she accidentally places Brian’s medical file on the counter. While Brian waits for Dr. K., he reads through his file folder. He is shocked to discover that his recent test for AIDS came back positive. Brian…

    • 293 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Discussion

    • 301 Words
    • 1 Page

    Please use as a basis for your discussion the following question: Do you think the events of this chapter (Chapter 2) are isolated instances of business malfeasance, or are they systemic throughout the business world? I don’t think events in Chapter 2 are isolated instances of business malfeasance. From the cases of Enron, Arthur Andersen and WorldCom, it’s easy to find some similarities. All of them focused on short-term revenue and ignored the long-term development and companies’ integrity…

    • 301 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    discussion

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Discussion In the model systems (solutions and paper), which samples browned the fastest and why? Which samples did not go brown and why? Why did the paper brown so rapidly compared to the solutions. What caused any significant differences between the model and real systems? In particular are there other ingredients in the cookie that could take part in the reactions or is the heating different in some way? Sample A and sample B are overlap after fry the paper. Sample B is more browning…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Discussion

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Review Test Submission: Learning the Language - Chapter 03 Menu Management Options * * * * Spring 2013:-0EE-Principles of Management (BUSN105-0EE-E1-201230) * Announcements * Start Here * Class Sessions * Discussions * Resources * My Grades * Instructor * Communication & Tools * Help Review Test Submission: Learning the Language - Chapter 03 Content User | Leonard E Moore | Course | Spring 2013:-0EE-Principles of Management |…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Discussion

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages

    English 1A: Discussion Topics John Berger’s “Ways of Seeing” Topic 1: Berger argues that there are barriers to vision, problems in the ways we see or don’t see original works of art, problems that can be located in and overcome by strategies of approach. For this topic, discuss what, as you read Berger, gets in the way when we look at paintings, and what it is that we might do to overcome the barriers to vision (and to history). Imagine that you are speaking to someone interested in art, but someone…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Discussion

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages

    "Information Technology" Please respond to the following: * Predict how technology will positively impact business over the next ten (10) years. Describe what specific changes or paradigm shifts you expect to see. * Within the same 10-year period, discuss the additional challenges and concerns you see arising from the implementation of new technologies. Technology in the next ten years in my opinion will change people’s lives everywhere. Production of trades will be at a faster pace. I…

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Discussion

    • 314 Words
    • 1 Page

    Discussion: The equation involved in this experiment is 2H2O2 ( 2H2O + O2 . The reaction between manganese dioxide and hydrogen peroxide also will produce water and oxygen as the equation 2H2O2 ( 2H2O + O2 . Manganese dioxide did not write in the equation it is because it act as catalyst in this reaction. The animal and plant organelle involved in this experiment is cell wall (plant), cell membrane (both animal and plant) and cytoplasm (animal and plant). Pulping the liver causes the total surface…

    • 314 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays