Discuss research related to failure to form attachment

Good Essays
Discuss research related to failure to form attachment 12 Marks
AO1 = /6 AO2 = /6
Curtis et al. studied the case of Genie, a girl who was left in isolation until being found at the age of 13, and being beaten when she made noise. When she was found she could barely walk, and could not talk. Researchers and doctors managed to tech her minimal vocabulary; however she could never string a sentence together and did not fully recover. Perhaps this was due to early emotional privation or the late stage she was discovered at was far past Bowlby’s suggested critical period for making healthy attachments.
Although Genie’s case study provides valuable supporting evidence for theories such as Bowlby’s, the circumstances are unique and extremely rare, making it hard to generalise the conclusions across a population. Also we don’t know whether genie was mentally disabled from birth or her disability is a result of her isolation and abuse. In addition to this, many of the tests ran on Genie were repeated to observe any progress which was shown, however these tests may have been testing how familiar she was with them rather than her understanding of what is involved in them, this renders any data from these tests invalid and unrepresentative.
Hodges and Tizard studied children who’d been institutionalised at an early age (before given the chance to form attachments) and were then either adopted or taken back by their parents. At the age of 16, those who went to live with their parents didn’t bond with them well; however the adopted children had strong secure attachments with their foster families- not supporting the maternal deprivation hypothesis given by Bowlby. Although, all children experienced problems with peers and would seek attention from adults, supporting the hypothesis, and showing signs of disinhibited attachments.
A weakness of this research is the assumption made by the researchers that the children had failed to form attachments. The lack of control in

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Discuss research into failure to form attachments The real term for failure to form attachments is privation; this means someone is unable to form any attachments to anyone. One case study on severe privation is the study on Genie (reported by Curtis 1977). This case study is about a young girl who had a really bad upbringing and as a result was forever unable to form attachments. Genie was found at the age of 13, for near enough her whole life she was kept tied to a potty chair, she had been…

    • 460 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Privation is the failure to form attachment. It occurs when a child has no opportunity to form a relationship with a parental figure, or when such relationship is distorted, due to their treatment. It is different to deprivation, which occurs when an established relationship is severed. It is understood that privation can produce social, emotional, and intellectual problems for children; however, how inevitable such problems become as a results of privation and the extent to which can be reserved…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    ‘Discuss research into the effects of failing to form attachment (privation)’ There are situations in life which people get themselves into that can cause problems in forming attachments. If a person is in hospital or attends day care then this can lead to disruption in attachment however there are other situations that can lead to privation, which is when children fail to form any attachments at all. If a person is in hospital for a very long time, being abused, being neglected, children being…

    • 1010 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Disruption of attachment is where an attachment has been formed between an infant and their primary care giver, but some kind of physical or emotional separation has occurred to disrupt its development during the sensitive period. Research investigating the effects of disruption to attachment has showed psychologists that infants forming attachments with a primary caregiver is essential for healthy social, physical and cognitive development. Such disruption could occur as a result of the infant being…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Discuss research into different type of attachment (12 marks) Mary Ainsworth conducted two naturalistic observations, one in the rural community of Kampala in Uganda which lasted for two years and the other in the urban city of Baltimore which had lasted for one year. The aim of this observation was to look at a mother and infant interaction. In both study she used the same number of participants, which were 26 mothers and their infants. Using the strange situation she found three different types…

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    with great honor that I speak before you at this momentous event. Tonight, we are celebrating the accomplishments of the past and the infinite possibilities of the future. And so, naturally, I’d like to begin with a story about failure. Or more exactly, driving-related failure. I didn’t take driver’s ed till I was 16, because I procrastinated as usual. But despite the fact that I took driver’s ed later, I passed the class with flying colors. Seeing this, I decided I was prepared to take the driver’s…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Scholars have long debated whether war is a form of diplomacy, or rather a failure of diplomacy. While scholars such as Clausewitz would argue that war is a policy maker and that the conduct of war should be subordinated to its political goals, other scholars such as Fearon may also suggest that war is a failure of diplomacy and that entities intervene as a last resort. While both points of view are interesting, the definition of “war” and “diplomacy”, the purposes within war and diplomacy, peaceful…

    • 2688 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Literary Forms in Philippine Literature by: Christine F. Godinez-Ortega The diversity and richness of Philippine literature evolved side by side with the country's history. This can best be appreciated in the context of the country's pre-colonial cultural traditions and the socio-political histories of its colonial and contemporary traditions. The average Filipino's unfamiliarity with his indigenous literature was largely due to what has been impressed upon him: that…

    • 2486 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Attachment is usually a word that we use to describe a feeling of connection that we have towards either an individual or an object. Similarly, childhood attachment occurs as an enduring, emotional closeness develops between children and their families. Attachment is essential because it allows children to prepare for the independence that they will need to develop to succeed as adults; it also helps pave the emotional and psychological grounds for children to be able to enter parenthood one day…

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Discuss Bowlby’s work on attachment. Refer to the work of at least one other researcher in your answer. (12 marks) Attachment theory was developed in the 1950’s by psychoanalyst John Bowlby, who defined attachment as a ‘lasting psychological connectedness between human beings’. Whilst working with James Robertson in 1952, he observed that children experienced intense distress when separated from their mothers and if fed by other caregivers, the child’s anxiety did not diminish. This led to his theories…

    • 1228 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays