Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the purposive approach.

Topics: Law, Human rights, Legislature Pages: 2 (401 words) Published: November 27, 2014
Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the purposive approach. (10 marks)

There are many advantages to the purposive approach. Firstly, it gives effect to Parliaments intentions and avoids injustice, so the judges can avoid obvious absurdities and injustives so enables them to comply with Parliamentary sovreignity by doing what Parliament would have wanted; even though it's ignoring the clear meaning of the words Parliament used. For example, in Coltman V Bibby Tankers when they had to interpret the word 'equipment'. Secondly, it give flexibility and can fill in the gaps, so looks to the spirit of the law rather than to the letter, therefore leaning towards a potentially just approach. However words can be ommitted/added if the court were certain of the act, if it was draftsmen/parliaments mistake that the act was written wrong, or that the judges were sure of the substance of the provision Parliament would have made. For example in Inco Europe Ltd. v First Choice Distribution 2000 H of L.

Thirdly, it allows for new technology/developments, and also allows the judges to keep the legislation in line with modern thinking and new technological developments, for example in R (Quintaville) v Sec of State for Health 2002. The purposive approach also allows our judges to comply with the Human Rights Act 1998. Under s3 of this Act, judges must try to reach an interpretation that doesn't breach human rights. A literal interpretation might reach a result that breached human rights. Instead, provided a different interpretation doesn't go against the whole purpose of the legislation, the judges can interpret the Act more creativley (Ghaidan v Godin-Mendoza).

The last advantage is that the purposive approach is consistent with the European approach. So it allows the judges to fulfil our obligations under EU Law. (Bulmer v Bolinger)

There are also many disadvantages to the purposive approach. Firstly, it involves too much judicial law making as it allows them...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of a scientific approach to the study of society. Essay
  • Databse Approach Advantages and Disadvantages Essay
  • Discuss the relative advantages and disadvantages Essay
  • Discuss the Advantage and Disadvantage of Sfa Research Paper
  • Discuss the Advantages and Disadvantages of Partnerships Essay
  • Essay on Discuss the Advantages and Disadvantages of Advertisements.
  • Discuss the Advantages and Disadvantages of Working in a Group. Essay
  • Essay about Discuss the Advantages, Strengths, Disadvantages and Weaknesses of a Positivist Approach to Social Sciences

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free