There are a number of differences and a few similarities between Jack and Ralph. First of all the main similarity is the fact that both boys are roughly the same age. Then furthermore, there is the fact that both pf them are boys. In addition their share the quality of leadership, or in other words both of them have the abilities to be a leader. Then on the other hand there are the numerous differences they in clued; different style of leadership, different believes, maturity, and the symbol that they represent. Jack and Ralph have a very different style of leading. Ralph has a democratic leadership and Jack is more of a dictator figure. Then furthermore, there is the difference of believes, Jack believes that the main objective on the island is to hunt and Ralph believes that it is to be saved. Then there is the maturity, Ralph is more mature that Jack. And the last difference in the symbols that these characters represent, Jack represents the bad side of human nature and Ralph represents the good side or democracy.
Question 2
Piggy represents intelligence and thinking. This idea is proven through out the whole book, until his death. Fist of all there is the fact that because of Piggy the boys were able to create the fire. The secondary, idea is the fact that Piggy acts very mature through out the book. He is even more mature than Ralph. Piggy comes up with ideas that not a single other boy had though of. For example there is the fact that Piggy though of the sundial. Furthermore there is the idea that Piggy constantly reminds Ralph of their objective to the island, and which is to be saved.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Piggy is one of the main characters in the book Lord of the Flies and despite his physical health and inability to swim, he is an important character that greatly affects Ralph and Jack's decisions due to his intelligence. Near the beginning of the book, you quickly learn that Piggy is a plump boy that has asthma and has been wearing specs since he was three. You can also tell that Piggy is a friendly person because…
- 450 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
For Ralph, his was new and still learning during the book. He wants to lead, while Jack, even though is not the leader, can come with an equal amount of respect, and can easily outdo Ralph. As Jack seems more malicious, most of the little…
- 774 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
He jumped in. “Piggy! Piggy!” ( Golding 11. ) Piggy and Simon from the book Lord of the Flies are both unique characters and easy to compare each other. Some of the main points that will be compared are Smart, Sensitive, and Outcasts. On the contrary some of the main points that will be contrasted between the characters are helpful against keeps to self, ways of death, and asthma and seizures.…
- 634 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The story's beginning does not clearly depict Piggy's intentions, as that of intellectualism. His glasses represent a symbol, initiating the fact that he's the scientific and logical aspect of civilization. In Chapter 1, Piggy finds the conch and guides Ralph on how to employ the conch to unite the survivors. "He blew from down there." (p16) Throughout the story, Piggy communicates his ideas through Ralph for the benefit of the group. An example would be during the assembly when Piggy grabs the conch and addresses the boys saying that a signal fire is vital for rescue. Ralph then agrees and implements Piggy's advice. When the fire spreads later on, burning parts of the island due to irresponsibility and the fact that the boys seem to resort to their savagery, Piggy uses reason to restore the importance of their situation and maintain stability by telling them it's important to…
- 666 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
There are various outlooks of a man in the novel ?Lord of the Flies.? Piggy and Ralph viewed man as being essentially good and that evil happens because something was wrong with people. Jack used power over others and believed that forces more powerful than him must be appeased through ceremony and sacrifice. Simon believed that both good and evil lay within each person. William Golding?s point of view is also represented by one of the characters.…
- 1041 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Piggy is a corpulent boy with glasses and gets picked on by the other boys on the island and is ignored. Piggy always getting picked on and getting his glasses ripped off his face causes him to think as an individual. Piggy is a wise boy and wants his voice to be heard by the other boys on the island so he uses the conch throughout the book so they would listen to him no matter what. “I got the conch, I got the conch,…
- 883 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The reinforcement of Piggy's nickname, which clearly humiliates him, also indicates that the boys have imported to the island the cruelty of human social life. Ralph's mockery of Piggy is the first instance of inequality on the island, and it foreshadows the gross inequities and injustices to come. We may also note here Piggy's background (as an orphan who lives with an aunt) and his poor diction ("can't catch me breath," "what's yer name?")-details that indicate that, unlike Ralph and Jack, Piggy is a child from a working-class background.…
- 3277 Words
- 14 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Piggy, along with being the brains of the island, is also a very complex and misunderstood boy. “Piggy is a much more complex character, than the simplistic interpretations so regularly adduced will allow”. (Reilly. online). This states that Piggy was an extremely complicated character, and is often overlooked by not only characters in the book, such as Jack and Ralph, but also by readers. He is also described as a brainiac by Golding himself, “Piggy, for all his ludicrous body, had brains”. (Golding 71). This emphasizes to the reader that Piggy’s brain is being discounted due to his stature, and this causes readers to discount his intelligence, however, it brings the reader’s attention to them being naive. This last quote also reinforces the concept that his body is causing his smarts to be overlooked “Piggy lacks the looks but has the know-how. The trouble is that he knows but cannot do and is relegated”. (Reilly. Online).…
- 1240 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
In the first few pages of the book we see that the boys are stranded on a uninhabited island. Thanks to Ralph’s conch, all the boys grouped up together. Once again as a group, they choose themselves a leader, which turned out to be Ralph, and once the formalities were over, who brings up the point that they’re stranded on an island with nobody’s knowing? Why none other than our loveable friend Piggy. “Who knows we’re here? Eh? Nobody knows where we are. Perhaps they knew where we were going to; perhaps not. But they don’t know where we are ‘cos we never got there.”(page 34) This shows Piggy’s more social side, because he expresses this idea to the entire group of boys, and showing the bond he has to civilization. We can see Piggy’s is a very civilized and sophisticated child, always remembering all the useful thing his auntie taught him. These two small yet very relative examples show the bond Piggy has to society.…
- 530 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Piggy and Ralph’s goal is to ultimately get off of the island, but Jack opposes that goal. Jack wants to hunt and have fun, both are not going to get the boys rescued. Early in the book, Ralph says,” The best thing we can do is to get ourselves rescued.” (53) and Piggy had the same intentions. All Jack wants to do is hunt, but hunting will not get the group saved and Piggy and Ralph know that. Ralph and Piggy seem to always be together. Meaning that they are physically always together and they think together too. The two boys also seem passionate about what they believe in. Unlike the other older kids, they stick with their first opinions on what to focus their energy on on the island. The other boys leave to go hunting with Jack and Piggy and Ralph stay with their beliefs instead of following the crowd. This means that they believe in what they are doing and that they should stick to what they think is right which shows great leadership because a leader should never follow a crowd.Piggy and Ralph also do not…
- 722 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Piggy does not have the same appearance as everyone else on the island. He is a fat nerdy kid with a high pitch voice with no authority. In the beginning of the novel the main character Ralph takes him as a joke. For example “They use to call me piggy.” Ralph shrieked with laughter, he jumped up “Piggy!” “Piggy!” (p.11). In the novel instead of calling him by his real name the author William Golding decides to have the kids on the island named him piggy. This shows in the novel that piggy is different and stands out to everyone else on the island.…
- 437 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
He comes up with countless ideas as to how to improve life on the island and the way to go about doing that. After the fire started by the hunters consumes most of the jungle, Piggy emphasizes that “The first thing we ought to have made was shelters down there by the beach” (45). In the beginning of the book, as Ralph finds the conch, it is Piggy that instructs Ralph in how to blow on the conch and make the sound that makes Ralph the “man with the megaphone” (7). More importantly is the role that Piggy plays as an adult voice on the island, a voice that the boys grow to resent. “‘Grownups know things,’ said Piggy. ‘They ain’t afraid of the dark. They’d meet and have tea and discuss. Then things ‘ud be all right” (94). It is this adult view of life and how he asserts his opinion that shapes the way Ralph ultimately begins to think and govern, and in a certain light, why he fails. Piggy believes that rules should be strictly followed, and this totalitarian view is shown when he tries to stress the power of the conch when speaking before Jack on Castle Rock. It is this effort to remain true to the ideals that the island was founded on, his ideals that were formed from intelligence and reason, that get him…
- 833 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Piggy is one of the main characters as well as one of the first characters we, the readers, meet. He is characterized by his glasses, asthma, and a level of decorum that direct decorum that any stereotypical Brit could envy. Within their community, he is seen as the voice of reason(see: direct). This makes his character particularly important as he is surrounded by other boys who would rather treat their crisis as a playground. However, this cynicism, on a deeper level, can be seen as a method of deflecting and a power play. On page 46, he looks upon the others with disdain as they rush up the mountain to start the fire. This separates him from the other boys, in case something goes wrong. And, of course, it does. Towards the end of chapter two, as the mountain is burning, Piggy scolds them for both not thinking, but also(and more importantly) not listening to him in the first place. These actions enable Piggy to pass the blame to everyone else and thus, allowing him to walk away with a free conscience even though their main hope for food just burnt and one of their own might be dead.…
- 244 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Ralph takes on the role as the adult on the island as there is none. He constantly thinks of survival, having fire, and building shelter because he is concerned about everyone's safety, “Been working for days now. And look!” (50). He’s been working on the shelters with the other boys, but then soon tire and leave him with Simon to finish the shelter. He tries to make sure a fire is always burning, constantly thinking ahead for warmth, cooking food and the possibility of rescue. Jack is a problem, he is becoming more and more barbaric, never thinking things through or supporting others, selfish and unworthy for chief, “He isn’t a proper chief” (126). Ralph would like for everyone on the island to be in one tribe so they can all help each other using all of their strengths, some are better at building shelter, others are better at hunting. Jack does not agree and resists that idea, stealing their food and making their lives even more difficult. Jack is making Ralph’s life unbearable, but Ralph perseveres to be a leader on the…
- 760 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
He remains in solidarity, rarely speaking and gaining trust of both Jack and Ralph, who fight for the position of a leader. Simon is never aroused into violence, and manages to remain the only boy who is truly, consistently good, partly because of his nature. He remains good because his human nature is not provoked into savagery; he is simply above all the others. As for Piggy, his intellect arouses in him, a want to be heard; to spread his new and innovative ideas, instead of concealing them like Simon. Piggy represents the rational side of society, which at times makes him cold and careless of everything, except for gaining acceptance. The two represent separate parts of the deteriorating morality amongst the other boys, Piggy and Simon possess the qualities that are disregarded in the tumult of survival; Piggy is rational and intellectual, while Simon is the purity and goodness in people.…
- 634 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays