Preview

Did Brutus Love Portia

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
566 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Did Brutus Love Portia
Need a claim In ancient Rome, marriage was less about love, and more about the need for a pretty possession to call a wife. However, Brutus’s relationship with his wife, Portia, was not like this. Brutus truly loved his wife as an equal. The first example of this is that when Portia asks Brutus to tell her what is bothering him. In Act II, scene i, lines 313-318, Brutus tells Portia that after he sees who is at the door he’ll tell her all his secrets, everything that’s bothering him. Then, later in the text, in Act II, scene iv, lines 9 and 14, Portia speaks of how hard it is for women to keep secrets, and asks Lucius to pay attention to how Caesar acts and which men are close to him. This shows that Brutus told her his secrets, told her what he and the conspiracy planned to do on the morning of March 15th. By telling Portia this, Brutus proves that he truly loves her and thinks of her as an equal, as if Brutus didn’t love Portia, he would have just not told her anything about what was bothering her and dismissed her questions altogether. He would not have allowed her to persuade him into exposing his secrets to her. The second …show more content…
This can be proven in Act II, scene i, lines 246-255 when Portia speaks of the past night at dinner when Brutus was bothered about something, yet gave Portia dirty looks and waved her away when she asked him what the matter was. However, it is believed that Brutus only did this to protect her. Brutus kept what was bothering him from Portia because he did not want her to be involved in any way with what he and the conspiracy were planning to do to Caesar. He didn’t want any of the blame for their actions to fall onto Portia. This proves that Brutus truly loves Portia as he wants to keep her safe and protect her from the brutally awful murder that the conspiracy was planning to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    12. What reasons does Portia give to insist that Brutus reveal his feelings to her?…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Although not being able to take part in political careers directly since the public offices as well as public voting were only opened to males, many Roman women were of special importance in the political world. It was no coincidence that Caesar's aunt Julia married Marius. Caesar himself married Sulla's granddaughter Pompeia, and Pompey married Caesar's daughter Julia, etc.. Examples of marriages like that were innumerable in Roman society, and if we make a deeper research, it won't be surprising that the aristocratic families were all connecting to each other in the relationship of marriage. Ironically, verbal or written contracts were easy to be broken, while alliances through marriages seemed to be much more solid. I'm not going to discuss that if this kind of marriage was an offence of true love and disrespect of women feelings. I just want to point out that political marriage worked quite well in the Roman society. For example, Caesar married his…

    • 1310 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Brutus uses their passion to his advantage, and convinces the conspirators that their own will power would be what compelled them to complete their task, not an oath. Another piece of evidence used to illustrate this, is when Brutus is defending the reasons behind his actions at Caesar’s funeral and he says, “ As / Caesar loved me, I weep for him; as he was fortunate, / I rejoice at it…” (JC.III.ii.24-26). By using the two words ‘loved’ and ‘weep’, Brutus is not only making himself seem vulnerable to the townspeople, but he is also showing that the death of Caesar was not necessarily what he wanted, and that the death of who was once his dear friend, upset him deeply. By doing this, people begin to feel sorry for Brutus, and they are not nearly as outraged as they are before he was given the opportunity to explain…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Portia feels as if she is Brutus’s “harlot” [prostitute] and not his wife. She believes that as a married couple they should not keep secrets from each other. “Within the bond of marriage, tell me, Brutus, Is it accepted I should know no secrets? That appertains to you? To keep with you at meals, comfort your bed, and talk to you sometimes?” (II.ii.275-276, 302-307). During the time of Julius Caesar women have an utterly different view compared to men in the society. They are just there to take care of their husbands, look after kids, clean the house, and do chores while the men are out fighting battles. Women are not taken seriously just because of their sex. Generally speaking, women are just powerless figures. Portia reasons Brutus should treat her with more respect and to treat her as a wife. Since Brutus does not tell her what is happening with his life she feels that he is solely excluding her from his life. Portia contemplates they…

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Portia does not fear Brutus. When Portia comes to Brutus in the night, he tells her “It is not for your health thus to commit Your weak condition to the raw, cold morning.” Act II, scene i, lines 244-245. Saying as a woman you should not be out in the weather for you will get sick. However, instead of her response being that of a possession would have responded, she simply replied “Not for yours neither.” Act II, scene i, line 245. Meaning, Brutus can get just as sick as she could. Portia says these words confidently knowing that Brutus won’t scold her for expressing her own opinions.…

    • 108 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Trust In Julius Caesar

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages

    She immensely shows this when she bluntly tells Brutus, “Within the bond of marriage… / Is it expected that I know no secrets / That pertain to you”(II.I.331-3330)? She questions why within their marriage there is no trust and questions the purpose of their “vows of love”. All the emotion Portia expresses at this point in the scene is pouring out of her as she is in a position where, because of the loss of communication, she is not informed and not understanding of the…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    work file

    • 857 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Brutus was only a friend a good friend in the beginning of the story. Brutus only pretended to be he's friend because he wanted to find out everything about Caesar's knowledge as becoming emperor of Rome. Brutus would put words in Caesar's mouth. Brutus was lying to Rome and he's people. Throughout the whole scene Brutus treated Caesar like if Caesar had every back stabbed Brutus. After Caesar's death, Brutus had no emotional feelings until the ghost of Caesar appeared. Convincing himself that he was the best for Rome.…

    • 857 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Julius Caesar Thesis

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Brutus is tricked into the conspiracy by Cassius. Brutus never had any true motives behind killing Caesar. He just did it for fear he "would" become ambitious. After his death Antony even states, "This was the noblest Roman of them all. All the conspirators, save only he, /Did that they did in envy of great Caesar..." (5.5.68-70). On the other hand, Brutus hid his true feelings behind a mask. In his heart, Brutus knew that everyone was not out for the same purpose as him. In reality, Brutus didn't want to hurt Caesar, but he felt it was only necessary. He even says, " Let not our looks put on our purposes, But bear it as our Roman actors do" (2.1.224-225). Even in his speech at Caesar's funeral, Brutus continued to appear as if he thought the murder was more of a sacrifice for Rome. When asked whether or not the conspiracy should take an oath of loyalty Brutus says there is no need and remarks with, " O, then by day where wilt thou find a cavern dark enough/ To mask thy monstrous visage? Seek none conspiracy;/ Hide it in smiles and affability" (2.1.79-81). He appears to everyone has confident on his decision, but in reality, he longs for a place to hide his true…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This is the best example to show that Brutus is not to be trusted. After all, Brutus reasoned “Not that I loved Caesar less, but I loved Rome more.” This shows that Brutus will not hesitate to remove anyone who he thinks is a threat to Rome’s democracy, or maybe more accurately, a threat to his own set of values.…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To begin, there is Portia. In Act II Portia sees that Brutus is struggling with something so she approaches him about it. “Within the bond of marriage, tell me, Brutus, Is it expected I should know no secrets That appertain to you?” Act 2 Scene 1 lines…

    • 623 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Brutus truly loved Portia as an equal to himself, if he did not, then he would not of told her not to kneel, or be worried about making sure she did not get sick. Even though there was a small argument, so to say, all marriages have those. Once again, Portia was not worried about what she said like most women during this time were. Brutus treated her fairly and loved her as an equal or else she would not of been so open to…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Write Your Argument

    • 2857 Words
    • 8 Pages

    king. Brutus believed that one man should not rule the country. He feared that if Caesar became…

    • 2857 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Brutus: A Tragic Hero By Chad Gingery In the play Julius Caesar, by William Shakespeare, Brutus is a tragic hero for he was easily manipulated, naive and patriotic. Brutus believed that the Romans wanted him as the leader to assassinate Caesar, because of the forged notes that were sent to him by Cassius. The note explained how to assassinate Caesar by Speaking, Striking and Redressing. This note by Cassius caused Brutus to be manipulated into joining the conspirators, one of many flaws that leads to the downfall of Brutus and the assassination of Caesar. Brutus' trusting attitude toward Antony is an example of one of his flaws. Brutus allowed Antony to give a funeral speech for Julius Caesar and to be sure not to speak negatively about the conspiracy. This resulted in Antony leading a mob against the conspirators, Revenge!, About!, Seek!, Burn!, Fire!, Kill!, Slay!, Let not a traitor live.!(3.2.216). From this powerful speech and Brutus' naïveté, Antony became his nemesis, an event that would ultimately lead to Brutus' downfall. Brutus had an overabundance of love for his country which blinded him to the truth. Brutus had said in one of his soliloquies, If then that a friend demand why Brutus rose against Caesar, this is my answer: Not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more. Brutus had honored Caesar but Brutus felt that Caesar was too ambitious. Brutus also felt that Caesar made the Romans as slaves. Brutus was a patriotic man who did not see past his patriotism, to see the exploitation of his comrades. Brutus was noble in how he was benevolent towards his fellow man, but this nobility was a negative component that led to his inevitable loss of nobility. Brutus had many errors in his plans in Julius Caesar; one of those errors was an exorbitant amount of love for Rome. Tragedy is when a person is deprived of something loved. Brutus had been deprived of his nobility. Brutus was a tragic hero because of his trusting, obedient personality and his…

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Marcus Brutus’ plight is ultimately a decision to save a republic that involves sacrificing its soon-to-be dictatorial leader, with the conspiracy taking into consideration the pros and the cons of such an act. Often times the better choice is the more difficult one, especially when it involves the murder of a man beloved by all. As such, Brutus is the tragic hero of the play Julius Caesar. His tragic flaw is his easily trusting nature, and his conflicting emotions and nobleness make him one of the most renowned tragic heroes of all time.…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Julius Caesar Composition

    • 600 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Has someone close to you, a best friend, or a wingman ever betrayed you? That is what the play “Tragedy of Julius Caesar”, by William Shakespeare is all about. In the play Julius Caesar is the new ruler of Rome. Cassius, who is conspirator, does not want him to be ruler. So Cassius skillfully convinces Brutus that he would be a better ruler of Rome than Caesar. Cassius convinces Brutus by telling stories about Caesars personality flaws that make him a weak ruler and Brutus a better one.…

    • 600 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays