Position Paper 2
I have been considering this assignment before the class began. I believe in this day and age that we, as clinicians, must remain open minded and versatile. Therefore, I do not believe that one has to take a single "position" for the "descriptive approach" or the "dynamic approach." I think one has to be flexible and use every tool in their arsenal to help the clients for a better continuum of care. Although my intuition leads me to believe that there is, ultimately, only one reality -- infinite and eternal -- experience leads me to believe that there are as many views or viewpoints of that reality as there are conscious people. Each of us has a different genetic heritage, different health histories, different cultural backgrounds, different upbringings, unique individual experiences... and so on. It is a surprise to me that we agree about the world as much as we do! Even more: Our views of reality change over the years and even from moment to moment as our situations and moods change. The development of individual minds suggests to me that, perhaps, there are a few ideas we can point to -- multifaceted ideas that gravitate to each other, because they share some logical connectedness that goes beyond individual variation. There are "clusters" or "categories" that are connected to some degree into the "objective" and the "subjective." This is where the psychological (dynamic or descriptive) approach utilized with clients needs to be flexible and versatile. The first category is autistic and authoritarian and these are "subjective" views. The autistic: I don't believe that anyone is ever completely involved in this perspective, but it is best seen in infants, autistic children, and severely psychotic adults. On the other hand, we all slip into this Position Paper 3
perspective from time to time, most obviously when we are dreaming, but also when we engage in instinctive, automatic, or defensive behavior. A person taking the...
References: Gabbard, G. (1994). Psychodynamic Psychiatry in Clinical Practice. Psychiatric Press.
Please join StudyMode to read the full document