Preview

Descarte's Argument For The Existence Of The Self?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1010 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Descarte's Argument For The Existence Of The Self?
Descartes famously a rationalist believed that true knowledge about the world comes from reason and without experience. Descartes initiated his claim about the self by doubting. He doubted everything, including his own existence, and that doubt itself is the only certainty. Accordingly, he assumed that his thoughts were the only thing not to be doubted. The answer to his existence was his cogito argument, “I think, therefore I am”; ‘cogito ergo sum’. This means that the existence of a thinking substance is necessary in order to do the thinking, and in order to think one must therefore exist. Descartes argues for the existence of the soul which does the thinking, as once you reflect on what it is to think, you can't make sense of the idea that …show more content…
Yet, the self has no impression corresponding to it. This is because the idea of the self must be persisting and constant, which contrasts to the non-persisting impressions by which all knowledge comes from. He writes, “I never catch myself at any time without a perception, and never can observe anything but the perception.” From this, he argues that the rationalist arguments, such as Descartes’, are wrong to speak of the soul, as their idea of the soul is mistaken for this very reason. Hume speaks of perception to explain his view-point. He says that when you perceive things from a perspective, your self is never part of the content. For example, we may have a perception of 'heat or cold, light or shade', but you can never actually perceive yourself. Therefore, bare perception is not possible in regard to the self as he states, "I never can catch myself at any time without perception." In other words, when you go looking for a perception what you will find is the thing that you perceive and not the thing doing the perceiving. Accordingly, 'you' are the thing that has the experiences and as a result cannot also be an object of those experiences, and so there is no impression corresponding to the self.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Descartes conclusion on premise 6 about God’s existence argues that the clear and distinct perceptions provide the foundation or basis for the truth of our beliefs and that is so because God, who is not a deceiver would not allow Descartes to be mistaken about that which he clearlyl and distinctly perceives. His notion of clear and distinct perceptions and their truth requires God’s existence.…

    • 65 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Cogito ergo Sum”( ….) . This conditional statement translates to “ I think, therefore, I am” and he presents that his ability to have consciences confirms his existence. After doubting God Descartes proves his existence in his Meditations on First Philosophy, he affirms the existence of God with an ontological view. This view suggests that the ability of one to think…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He states that one can understand the mind to exist separately from the body. The middle term of the argument, as noted in the major premise is the separate understanding of two things, and he presents the idea of mind and body as the minor term. Descartes devotes a larger share of the argument to defending the minor premise, perhaps because the idea of body and mind as separate substances is more controversial than a general notion of separate substances as distinct. He goes on to expound not only the idea that the mind and body are separate, but that the essence of the human being lies in its nature as a thinking thing. As thought is the essence of the human being, and the principle attribute of the mind is thought, the mind can therefore be seen as more fundamental to humans than the body. Descartes acknowledges that it is likely for a body to be joined to the mind, however he maintains that one can still conceive of both body and mind as separate substances. And as the essence of the body is extension rather than thought, it is fundamentally less relevant to a thinking…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The fact that Descartes is even considering the mere question of his own existence just proves that he indeed exists and that is certain. Further, he argues that we are essentially thinking things (res cogitans) that can know our minds clearly and distinctly. Descartes pitches a tent for himself firmly in the rationalist camp, as opposed to the empiricist camp. He constantly emphasizes that the clear and distinct perceptions of the intellect are the only sure means of securing knowledge, and ultimately concludes that the senses are not designed to give us knowledge at all, but are rather meant to help us move through the world in a very practical…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many people may argue that they know themselves very well and they do not need a ‘stranger’ to tell them who they truly are, what they are manifesting etc. However, Hume refutes this aspect. Can one truly “[distinguish] and [separate their feelings, actions or what so ever] from each other [or even consider to do the separations needed to identify their personality] and have no Deed of tiny thing to support their existence?” (Hume, 1). All that he wants to raise awareness to that: ‘is possible to exist separately from your actual oneself?’ Can someone step outside of their body or self and observe everything about their personality and all, then make their own judgement and walk back in the body; speaking of death or some out of body experience? According to Hume, “if we wou'd have the idea of self-pass for clear and intelligible, It must be someone impression, that gives rise to every real idea. But self or person is not any one impression, but that to which our several impressions and ideas are suppos'd to have a reference.” (1) If that was the case, many people who have remorse of some sort would have been able to stop themselves from committing their faults and make the necessary changes; especially when the outcome known is not favorable. It is just that “the mind is a ‘kind of theatre’ where several perceptions successively make their appearance; pass, re-pass, glide away, and mingle in an infinite variety of postures…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Is there a God? Is it true that there is one or many Supreme beings that created the universe within it including humans? There are atheist that say no, and theist that say yes. But who is truly right in their conclusions of God’s existence. Philosophers have debated the highly controversial issue, and many proofs have been claimed of God’s existence. However, for every good claim there is a counter to the claim as well.…

    • 5433 Words
    • 22 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    This is the first thing that Descartes knows to be true. He says, “What about thinking? Here I make my discovery: thought exists; it alone cannot be separated from me. I am; I exist- this is certain” (Descartes, 19). He goes on to say that his senses are deceptive and whatever he may understand from his senses may be false, therefore he cannot rely on them.…

    • 1772 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes constructs an argument for God’s existence on page 32-34 of his third meditation titled: Concerning God and He Exists. In this paper, I will summarize Descartes’s argument in my own words.…

    • 415 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Descartes also states that this argument isn’t strong enough to prove that God exists. Because he has been constantly revising his believes he says that at this point he can easily tell the difference between essence and existence. After he points that out he explains that he believes that God could be separated from the existence but not from his essence. Then he contradicts himself saying that not existing would be prove of him not being perfect thus he had to exist. After that Descartes starts lacking of confidence that God exists. He thinks that he is giving some attributions, being perfect; to a creature that he doesn’t even know if exists. He thinks that he is just matching two things that he knows to make something new, something that…

    • 193 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Micaela Ceraso PHIL 101 Professor Papa December 9th 2014 Topic 3: The Certainty that God Is After reading the two paragraphs written by scholars I have come to three different conclusions. The author of the first argument claims that God does in fact exist and he is also infinite. The author of the second argument claims that humans are not capable of comprehending the idea of infinite, therefore we cannot argue that God is infinite or that he exists at all. Finally, Descartes claims that by The Method of Doubt, God is the one idea that cannot be doubted. Therefore, the disputed question in these three arguments is the existence of God and the idea of infinite.…

    • 1259 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the Meditations, Descartes successfully establishes methodical doubt about math and all sensory information, however, his answer to the doubt cast by the Evil Demon ploy does not fully relieve the dilemma of skepticism that his intense application of doubt has brought forth. Ultimately, Descartes is unable to satisfactorily answer the Evil Demon doubt because his argument does not prove that God’s existence would not prevent the serious errors in judgment and perception caused by the Evil Demon doubt.…

    • 1266 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There have been many arguments and philosophical beliefs of the existence of god. For many centuries, there have been many attempts by many philosophers to prove the existence of God. Many philosophers’ arguments for the existence of God come in many different evidence like using science, personal experience, history and philosophy. Looking at the philosopher's point of view, I have come across two arguments that explain the existence of god which is the cosmological and ontological argument. As of today, even with all the development of sciences, we still do not have a clear answer if god exists or not but from my personal belief, he exists. He exists because how the idea of god could be created in our minds and that the event of something…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This could mean memories, thoughts and or beliefs. Hume also demonstrates an argument for the idea of God. I personally think his argument about God worked much better than Descartes’. He says that the idea of God can be determined by the impressions we have of “wise” and “good.” When referring to how we get from one idea to another, Hume explains how it corresponds.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hume on Personal Identity

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Hume 's view of what constitutes personal identity rests heavily upon his preceding theories concerning the nature of ideas and causation. The most important preceding ideas to take into account are the rejection of causality and necessary connection and his strict empiric stance on the basis of knowledge and the only two types of perception being ideas that are reliant on initial impressions. There will clearly be difficulty in defining and explaining 'the self ' when both the notions of causality and substance have been rejected, this results in Hume restricting himself in what he feels he can define as personal identity. Hume does not want to distinguish between the nature of personal identity and the nature of the identity we hold in single objects or ideas. Both are based in initial single impressions which the mind then assembles into a 'chimera ' of a more complex idea, constituting it 's identity. This for Hume is irrational, as there is no observable or conceivable necessary connection between past, present and future sense data, resulting in the self being strictly and thriftily described by Hume as 'a bundle of perceptions '.…

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    From the beginning of the third meditation, Descartes seeks to establish the existence of God using his initial concept of self awareness. Descartes argued that because he thought, then he lived. Thinking ability at this time was linked to being alive and thought that there must be a god who puts the thoughts in his mind. In his quest for indubitable truth, Descartes came up with the theory of ideas, which classified those things that he considered distinct and clear to be true. Descartes argued that the idea of god should be coming from within him since he cannot experience god himself directly or find any perfection in himself.…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays