top-rated free essay

Democracy Is Meaningless

By arpitagupta740 Sep 14, 2013 588 Words
All Men are Liars:
Is Democracy Meaningless?
1
by Gerry Mackie
St. John's College
University of Oxford
Oxford OX1 3JP
United Kingdom
gerry.mackie@sjc.ox.ac.uk
April 18, 1997
Forthcoming in Jon Elster, ed.,
Deliberative Democracy
2
I. Introdu
ction.
One current of thought within the rational choice
approach to the study of politics asserts that democratic voting and democratic discussion are each, generally, inaccurate and meaningless. 2
I
will call an emphasis on these descriptive assertions
against democracy "the
Rochester current," because its exemplar, the late William Riker, was long a professor of political science at the University of Rochester, and his work on social choice and democracy influenced many of his students and colleagues th

ere.
3
The Rochester current is heir to a tradition of skepticism against the possibility of democratic politics, most respectably expressed earlier in this century by the economists Pareto and Schumpeter.

In America the skeptical view of democracy is
often accompanied by
a family of arguments to the effect that "most public sector programs . . . are inappropriate, or are carried on at an inappropriate level, or are executed in an inappropriate manner."
4
The normative recommendation that is supposed
to
follow from these descriptive assertions is that we are best protected from the absurdities of democracy by liberal institutions that, to the maximum extent feasible, shunt decisions from the incoherent democratic forum to the coherent economic market, an

d that fragment political power so that
ambitious elites circulate and contest in perpetual futility; in other words, that the U.S. Constitution, especially as it was interpreted before the New Deal to prevent political interference in the economy, is one of the best of all

possible political arrangements.
5
The descriptive assertions against
democracy and that normative recommendation are not necessarily linked, however. There are those who grant some credence to the descriptive assertions, yet would pres
umably recommend institutions more social
-
democratic than conservative in content.
6
Others could plausibly argue that
3
if voting and discussion are inaccurate and meaningless, then coercive paternalism is necessarily better than any liberalism for coherent ly shaping
and satisfying people's needs.
7
In his
Liberalism against Populism
, an interpretation of the results of
social choice theory, Riker makes an apparently powerful case against the very intelligibility of majoritarian democracy.
8
Because differen
t voting
systems yield different outcomes from the same profile of individual voters' preferences, he argues, democracy is
inaccurate
. For a simple example,
consider that if a group of people is voting for one among three or more candidates for an office,
then a voting system that on one ballot selected the
candidate with a plurality (the most votes, but not necessarily a majority) might select a different candidate than a system that held a second ballot for a majority runoff between the two top vote

-
gett
ers from a first ballot.
Different methods of aggregating individuals' fixed choices may yield different group choices.
Next, Riker continues, given a fixed voting system, then democracy is
meaningless
: the outcome of voting is manipulable, and it is n
ot possible
to distinguish manipulated from unmanipulated outcomes because of the unknowability of private intentions underlying public actions. The spirit of the argument is best conveyed by presenting Condorcet's paradox of voting. Suppose that there a

re three persons named
1
,
2
, and
3
, deciding by majority
vote among three alternatives
a
,
b
, and
c,
and that individual preference
orders are equivalent to what follows.
Table 1
Voters
Preferences
(left > right)
1
a
b
c

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • democracy

    ...rule, some make an attempt to set up a government in which the people ruled themselves. This form of government is called a democracy, or “rule of the people.” History has also revealed through the Greeks and the French Revolution, that a democracy that gives complete power to the people, “absolute democracy”, is nothing more than a shor...

    Read More
  • Democracy

    ...Democracy: The Best of the Worst Democracy is without a doubt a fairly successful system of governance. Although dozens of systems have been tried over the ages, the world has been continuously edging towards increasingly democratic models, at least in baby steps when not in great leaps and bounds. And yet Winston Churchill - both the product ...

    Read More
  • Democracy

    ...therefore a democracy would be the best choice. Democracy is a government for the people, by the people, of the people. Democracy is the most sufficient type of government. Popular sovereignty and equality are the best core democratic values that support democracy. A core democratic value is the fundamental beliefs and constitutional princi...

    Read More
  • Democracy

    ...Democracy Democracy has become a dominant form of the government, that using in many countries. Democracy is a government form, which is the citizen should have a decision to vote their leader directly for their own country or elect the leader for the other problems. Democracy can develop it, if the majority and the minority party or the as...

    Read More
  • Democracy

    ...What is Democracy? 1.government by the people; a form of government in which thesupreme power is vested in the people and exercised directly bythem or by their elected agents under a free electoral system. 2.a state having such a form of government. 3.a state of society characterized by formal equ...

    Read More
  • Democracy

    ...Today, most of the countries in the world are democracies. Knowing what is a democracy is really important, especially for those who live in a democracy. It allows you to understand what is the rule that the government plays in the society and know what are your rights and duties under a democratic administration. This essay will seek to define ...

    Read More
  • Democracy

    ...Democracy means power in the hand of people. Democracy is a form of government where sovereignty is in the hand of the people, the general public. The basic idea is of equality, freedom and welfare for all. It does not take into consideration the cast or the wealth of some person; every individual is treated fairly and is given equal rights. D...

    Read More
  • Democracy

    ...Etymologically, democracy comes from two Greek words, demos and cratein. Demos means society while cratein means authority. There are many terminological definitions of democracy, one of it is definition is by Henry B. Mayo stating that democracy is a political system showing the public policy determined by representatives audited effectively by...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.