Defense of Hard Determinism

Good Essays
A. DEFENCE OF HARD DETERMINISM
Hard Determinism argues that every event is causally determined. For an event ‘A’ to occur casually means that there are antecedent causes that ensure the occurrence of ‘A’ in accordance with impersonal, mechanical causal laws. To clarify hard determinism further, let me present hard determinism as an argument. Basically hard determinism argues that: (a) Determinism is true (b) Determinism is incompatible with free will (Holbach, 451). In defense of premise (a), the hard determinist says that obviously everything is caused, therefore determinism is true. To prove that determinism is false, the opponent would have to come up with an example of an uncaused event. To defend premise (b), the hard determinist would say that no action is free if it must occur. Human actions result from wants, desires, motivations, feelings, etc. The human wants, desires, motivations, feelings, etc are caused by specific antecedent conditions that ensure their occurrence. Therefore, human actions are not free.

So the implication of hard determinism being true is simply that, there is no free will. But the opponents will defend vehemently that there is free will. And the first objection that they will bring to prove that there is free will is that man has the ability to step back from decisions that he has already made and do something different. This seemingly indicates that not all of human decisions are determined and man has free will. But in response to this, the hard determinist will say that since man is a reasonable human being, after carefully considering a situation, he might find something beneficial in not acting according to his initial impulse. He might decide to change his first choice because he has a new motivation, a new idea, which modifies the brain to reconsider the initial choice. And the brain gives him a new impulse by which the action of the former impulse is suspended. Let me clarify my stance with an example. Suppose a man

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    responsibility and its relation to human freedom and determinism: libertarianism, hard determinism and compatibilism. However, I believe there is only one theory that would provide the overall best explanation, and that is the view of libertarianism. For this essay, I will begin with the background information needed to understand the complexity of these theories. Then, I will explain why hard determinism is…

    • 1138 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hard Determinism vs Soft Determinism In this paper, I will show that hard determinism is the best explanation for our lack of free will in our daily decisions. Using a love story as an example will help clarify that free will is simply a fallacy and hard determinism is accurate. Steven was a junior accounting student at the very large Penn State University. He was fairly quite and reserved, but had a few close friends that he grew up with. Steven is one of those guys that is not crazy and…

    • 1634 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    While there are several different viewpoints of free will in philosophy, the main theories are hard determinist, libertarians, and compatibilism. Determinism is the idea that every action you take is heavily influenced by outside forces and past events. A hard determinist has the belief that that people have no free will and therefore no one is responsible for their actions because they were predetermined. Conversely, people with libertarian views of free will believes that our choices are entirely…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Hard Determinism

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages

    disasters were always going to happen. The basis of hard determinism circulates around three main points: 1. Determinism is true of our world; 2. Determinism rules out alternative possibilities; 3. Free will requires that we can do otherwise/have alternative possibilities regarding our actions (Lecture notes). Breaking these down shows possible flaws and well as strengths in the deterministic argument. For people to believe hard determinism governs our lives,…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Chapter 21 Hard Determinism and Libertarianism 1. Free will and the hypothesis of mechanism In the previous chapter we looked at two arguments meant to show that no choice or action anyone ever makes is a choice or action made freely. Both arguments depend crucially on the idea that the behaviour of people, even their thoughtfully willed behaviour, is no less the mechanical result of prior events than is the behaviour of anything else in the world. Both arguments, that is, explicitly suppose…

    • 9871 Words
    • 40 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Defense of Determinism Determinism receives more public attention and inclinations from people because it offers a causal explanation for everything that happens. Opposite to Libertarians’ world based on mere chance and undetermined actions which seems less plausible, Determinists believe that “whatever happens at any given moment is the effect of some antecedent cause”(388), in other words, any state at any given time is completely determined by it’s prior state. According to the theory of…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Hard Determinism And Libertarianism Aren't Compatible. Discuss. The compatibility of hard determinism and libertarianism is the view of compatibilists. Hard determinists do not see this compatibility as they see libertarians as their complete opposites. Libertarians believe we have free will. Whereas hard determinists believe we have no free wil what so ever, they believe our life is predetermined as all our actions have causes making our action predetermined. Hard determinism can be defined…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Determinism

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages

    According to Sider and Conee, determinism conflicts with the concept of free will. Since all events have single or multiple causes and are also caused by a prior event, the existence of free will is questioned. If a person woke up one day and felt energized, there would be a reason as to why he woke up that way and not any other way. Perhaps the reason would be that he had 12 hours of sleep, or that he woke up to a bright, sunny day. Determinism tells us that not only is there a reason why he woke…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Determinism

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Hard Determinism vs. Soft Determinism By: Michael Soltys Determinism is the idea that occurrences in our life have already been determined and are a result of another element in the universe (cause and effect) and every occurrence can be traced back to the original state of the universe therefore nothing is random. Indeterminism, is essentially the opposite of determinism, humans have the free will to do as they please therefore nothing is predetermined. Now assuming one does hold the deterministic…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Free-Will And Determinism

    • 1564 Words
    • 7 Pages

    1 The Compatibility of Free Will and Determinism 2 The Compatibility of Free Will and Determinism One of the biggest issues regarding criminal activity is deciding how to assign moral responsibility to each situation. This critical question has caused the world to take a step back, ponder the origination of individual choices, and decide whether people are determined or not. Determinism supports the claim that “all events are the necessary result of previous causes” (Lawhead, 267)…

    • 1564 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays