31 March 2014
Should Some States Continue with its Death Penalty?
"As if one crime of such nature, done by a single man, acting individually, can be expiated by a similar crime done by all men, acting collectively" (Lewis Lawes, warden of Sing Sing prison in NY in the 1920s and 30s.) Many people think that is right to have payback over something that has been done to them and other think that it is brutal and goes against human morals. Also many people often questioned whether it's fair to continue with the death penalty and whether the punishment is legal or not. Death Penalty is given to criminals because it has been said that it is a danger to society to have such persons. This depends on whether the punishment serves a valid point or not. Death penalty doesn’t prevent people to commit murder; even now the highest rate of homicide happens mostly in states that have the capital punishment. Due to the death penalty many people get to fulfill a desire for revenge, they also get negative results out of it like taking a life away without having the authority as God does to do so. One of the main ideas of using the death penalty is to be an example to the people; however many criminologists agree that the death penalty does not decrease the capital crimes. If it does not fulfill one of its basic functions, how could it be effective? If it cannot be effective at all and fulfill the expectations, why do it? A society that deals violence with violence will only achieve more violence. Today, the people is still not sure if it is fair or not to enforce the death penalty in some states. Should a murderer get his own life taken or should it be called a cruel unusual punishment? People are just beings and can therefore make mistakes. If a prisoner happen to be innocent and was executed there would be nothing to do to change what has been done. Although we have modern tools to know, for example DNA testing, there is still a one percent chance that the person that has been accused is not the person that committed the crime. The killing of one innocent person affects negatively the effectiveness of the punishment because the death penalty is hold against an innocent person that didn’t commit the crime. “Despite the best intentions of law enforcement, prosecutors, defense attorneys, judges and jurors, innocent people have been convicted and sentenced to death” (Ray Samuels, Police Chief of Newark, CA.) People often wonder if this kind of punishment is a way to get revenge for what the murderers have done to their victims, which makes me question many things according to the constitution. No matter how the death penalty is carried out or why, some people feel as if no man should have the right to judge and sentence another to death. We are nobody to judge only God. Although, what the murderers have done was not right and it is a sin, being in prison for life is a good enough punishment for the criminal. In addition, God will have the right punishment not us, humans, because we also commit mistakes. The death penalty has been going on for years and many other states are starting to make the death penalty legal. I personally feel that this punishment about death punishment shouldn’t be allowed. The death penalty only allows us to extend the pain for the criminal and to give the criminal what they think he/she deserves. It allows us to continue to blame one another, to turn against one another, to learn to hate our own kind. “123 death-row prisoners have been released because they were innocent. In addition, at least seven people have been executed since 1976 even though they were probably innocent. Wrongful convictions often result from false confessions, which are frequent among people with mental retardation, mistaken eyewitnesses, jail house snitches, junk science and prosecutorial abuse” (ACLU Capital Punishment Project National Death Penalty Fact Sheet – March 2007.) How does that...
Cited: , ed. "The Classical Argument ." The Writing Center. 242 Bancroft. Web. 1 Apr 2014. .
"Facts." Death Penalty Focus. Working for alternatives to the death penalty. Death Penalty Focus, 31 May 2013. Web. 1 Apr 2014. .
Manning, Alexis. "5 Surprising Facts About the Death Penalty Worldwide." National Geographic Daily News. National Geographic News, 12 Apr 2013. Web. 1 Apr 2014. .
Please join StudyMode to read the full document